390 likes | 482 Views
Advanced Placement Essays. Self Evaluation Rubric. To receive a score of 8-9. Overall impression. Demonstrates excellent control of the literature Demonstrates outstanding writing competence Writing is: Thorough Effective incisive. Understanding of the Text.
E N D
Advanced Placement Essays Self Evaluation Rubric
Overall impression • Demonstrates excellent control of the literature • Demonstrates outstanding writing competence • Writing is: • Thorough • Effective • incisive
Understanding of the Text • Excellent understanding of the text • Exhibits perception and clarity • Original or unique approach • Includes apt and specific references
Organization and Development • Meticulously organized • Thoroughly developed • Coherent • Unified
Word Choice • Interesting • Effective • Virtually error free
Grammar and Usage • Virtually error free
Overall Impression • Demonstrates good control of literature • Demonstrates good writing competence • Less thorough than an 8 paper • Less incisive than an 8 paper
Understanding of the Text • Good understanding of the text • Exhibits perception and clarity • Includes specific references
Organization and Development • Well-organized • Well-developed • Coherent • unified
Use of Sentences • Varied • Interesting • Few errors
Word Choice • Generally interesting • Generally effective • A few errors
Grammar and Usage • Occasional minor errors
Overall Impression • Reveals simplistic thinking and/or • Immature writing • Adequate skills
Understanding of the Text • Superficial understanding of the text • Elements of literature vague • Mechanical • Over-generalized
Organization and Development • Reasonably organized • Reasonably developed • Mostly coherent • Mostly unified
Use of Sentences • Occasionally interesting • Occasionally effective • Several errors
Grammar and Usage • Several minor errors
Overall Impression • Incomplete thinking • Fails to respond adequately to part or parts of the question • May paraphrase rather than analyze
Understanding of the Text • Misreadings and lack of persuasive evidence from the text • Meager treatment of literary elements • Unconvincing treatment of literary elements
Organization and Development • Somewhat organized • Somewhat developed • Some incoherence • Some lack of unity
Use of Sentences • Somewhat varied • Marginally interesting • One or more major errors
Word Choice • Somewhat dull • Somewhat ordinary • Some errors in diction
Grammar and Usage • Some major errors
Overall Impression • Unacceptably brief • Fails to respond to the question • Little clarity
Understanding of the text • Serious misreadings • Little supporting evidence from the text • Erroneous treatment of literary elements
Organization and Development • Little or no organization • Little or no development • Incoherent • Void of unity
Word Choice • Mostly dull • Mostly conventional • Numerous errors
Grammar and Usage • Severely flawed • Frequent major errors
Magical at times Attempts more challenging concepts Mature beginnings Takes risks Always under control Figurative language Symbolism Extended metaphor Organization Pacing Narrative strategies Descriptors for a 9
Strong sense of control-organization Mature in style & vocabulary Tight link of support (text references to author’s intent) Attempts more challenging concepts Figurative language Symbolism Extended metaphor Organization Pacing Narrative strategies Descriptors for an 8
More fluid in style Sections insightful Often one section well developed by student & affected by time Clear or implied thesis – tied to general intent of question Attempts more difficult tasks Sense of completion Descriptors for a 7
Inconsistent - but adequate Less difficult concepts Linear organization Step by step laborious Rigid organization Occasional insight Summary conclusion “Once over lightly” Descriptors for a 5 & 6
Listers, labelers No analysis Paraphrasing Limited task (diction only) Proving the obvious Poor analogies Obviously, use of you Colloquial diction Implied analysis Funnel opening Truisms Immature focus “gets the reader’s attention” 0 sense of completion Descriptors for a 3 & 4
Off topic Soap box lecture “I” Argues against writer’s position – instead of analysis Testimonials Teacher lecture Defining of terms Major grammar problems Brevity Summary 0 analysis inaccuracies Descriptors for a 1 & 2