1 / 18

16 - Auditing Financial Markets

16 - Auditing Financial Markets. Managing Compliance Risks arising from Financial Instruments. Policy and legislation Appropriate rules Including anti avoidance rules Administrative approaches Determinations and rulings process

jolene
Download Presentation

16 - Auditing Financial Markets

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. 16 - Auditing Financial Markets

  2. Managing Compliance Risks arising from Financial Instruments • Policy and legislation • Appropriate rules • Including anti avoidance rules • Administrative approaches • Determinations and rulings process • Advanced pricing arrangements (APAs) on financial arrangements between related parties to deal with transfer pricing issues • Disclosures of complex financial arrangements • Audits of complex financial arrangements • Specialised technical skills

  3. Policy and Legislation • Sound legislative framework to facilitate financial innovation • Eg Repos taxed as secured loans • Much aggressive tax planning based on exploiting perceived weaknesses in legislation • Objective of legislation should be • To be clear in purpose • Trust courts to interpret in a way that is compatible with that purpose

  4. Policy and Legislation • Design legislation with avoidance opportunities in mind • A clear statement of purpose “principles based drafting” is one tool for making law robust and assists courts in interpreting legislation in a way that fits original intention • Another strategy is to incorporate anti avoidance legislation into the primary legislation as it is introduced

  5. Policy and Legislation • But • No matter how good the proofing of legislation is there is always the risk that someone will find a way round the legislation • Good primary legislation may reduce the planning opportunities, but it will not eliminate them entirely. • Other defences needed.

  6. Anti- Avoidance Legislation • Anti avoidance measures • General Anti Avoidance Rule (GAAR) • Specific Anti Avoidance Rules • GAARs can be effective but not a cure all • In particular cannot be used to remedy defective primary legislation eg Japan on REPOS, Canada fully hedged foreign currency loans, • Some legal systems cannot incorporate a GAAR

  7. Anti- Avoidance Legislation • Specific anti avoidance legislation e.g. UK targets arrangements • One of the main purposes of which is to … • Generate capital losses • To secure a tax advantage • Retroactive legislation • Full rectro active (illegal in many countries) • Partial retroactive (illegal in some countries e.g. France Italy) • Partial retro active legislation can be effective when coupled with disclosures regime (see later)

  8. Determinations and Rulings • Rationale • Determinations can be issued by tax authorities or requested by taxpayers on • Generic type of instruments (e.g. options, swaps, etc.) • Product or arrangement specific • Taxpayer specific • Practical Issues • Fees to cover costs • Transparency in public and private rulings (publish principles anonymously) • Can be challenged

  9. Disclosure Requirements • Purpose is to provide tax authorities with information about complex financial arrangements with tax avoidance implications • Use as an audit selection basis to determine whether to investigate further • Focus on complex related arrangements, but ‘relatedness’ is difficult to define • Exempt inter-related arrangements that are generally accepted commercial practice (e.g. hedges) • Look in more detail at UK disclosure regime

  10. Administrative Approach • Financial instruments are complex, with own specialist terminology, accounting and tax rules • Tax administrations need to be able to handle this • Specialist units • Accountancy skills

  11. Administrative Approach • Improve commercial awareness of staff • Ask banks to provide training? • Banks allow staff to be seconded for short periods? • Recruit private sector financial specialists? • Enhanced relationship with banks • Work with banks through rulings, guidance real time discussion • Encourage banks to be transparent so as to better understand the commercial context of complex financial instruments • Banks need an incentive to behave this way

  12. Administrative Approach • Risk assessment • Ensure have strategies in place to better prevent, detect and respond to aggressive tax planning involving financial instruments • Auditors should alert policy makers to use of financial instruments • E.g. where transactions comply with law yet have undesirable effects

  13. Administrative Approach • Auditors should alert policy makers to use of financial instruments • E.g. situations where transactions are treated differently in another jurisdiction to determine whether the policy makers are comfortable with existence of arbitrage opportunity (see later session)

  14. Auditing • Many financial avoidance schemes work and important role of auditor is to bring such schemes to attention of policy makers • However, not all of them work, especially if they don’t get the paperwork right • Know your taxpayer. Are they prone to making mistakes. If so they may mess up an otherwise effective scheme

  15. Auditing • Audit approach • Understand the accounting • Understand the financial products • Is the tax treatment achieved by taxpayer consistent with objectives of legislation • If not, what are your available tools • Are all the considerations of a financial arrangement included in your calculation? • When are two arrangements independent or interdependent?

  16. Auditing • Things to look for • Accounting profits, but no tax profit • Items treated as income/interest for accounting purposes but as capital for tax purposes • Losses on currencies/assets when no obvious commercial reason for holding those assets • Several Transactions happening at same time • Self cancelling transaction

  17. Auditing • Things to look for • Differences between consolidated financial expenses and individual company tax returns • Transactions with associated enterprises • Transactions with non tax paying entities (charities, tax havens, loss making companies)

  18. Auditing • Things to ask for • Contracts on financial instruments • Master agreement between bank and the MNE • Commercial reasons for entering into contract • Documentation to meet accounting or regulatory requirements • [ Know the accounting and regulatory requirements]

More Related