180 likes | 193 Views
TGad Editor Report. Authors:. Date: 2011-03-13. Draft update and next steps. TGad draft D1.2 released on March 01, 2011 D1.2 = D1.1 + speculative implementation of all technical and editorial comments resolved since the January/11 mtg
E N D
TGad Editor Report Authors: Date: 2011-03-13 Carlos Cordeiro, Intel Corporation
Draft update and next steps • TGad draft D1.2 released on March 01, 2011 • D1.2 = D1.1 + speculative implementation of all technical and editorial comments resolved since the January/11 mtg • All comments as part of LB168 have now been resolved and implemented into D1.2 • D1.2 has gone has gone through an editorial review by TGad’s editorial panel before its release • Goals for this mtg with respect to the draft • Approve creation of D2.0 on the basis of D1.2 • Start a recirculation LB on D2.0 Carlos Cordeiro, Intel Corporation
LB168 update (10/1220r21) • Editorial comments were resolved by Editor and reviewed by the editorial panel • The latest comment database is 802.11-10/1220r21, and contains the resolution to all comments Carlos Cordeiro, Intel Corporation
Report for January 2011 Carlos Cordeiro, Intel Corporation
Draft update and schedule • TGad draft D1.1 released on January 16, 2011 • Speculative implementation of all technical, and some editorial, comments resolved to date (10/1220r12) • Targeting March/11 session to conclude LB168 comment resolution • TGad draft D2.0 will be generated weeks later, which will trigger the start of a recirculation LB Carlos Cordeiro, Intel Corporation
LB168 update (10/1220r12) • Editorial comments will be resolved by Editor after all technical comments are resolved • Some technical comments will resolve editorials • Contact the Editor if you want to volunteer to resolve Open CIDs Carlos Cordeiro, Intel Corporation
Report for November 2010 Carlos Cordeiro, Intel Corporation
TGad draft specification update • Draft 1.0 was released on September 24, 2010 • Implements the approved comments indicated in the D0.1 comment database (10/717r15) • Following the release of D1.0, a 30-day WG letter ballot (LB168) was initiated on D1.0 • LB168 closed on October 24, 2010 Carlos Cordeiro, Intel Corporation
LB168 update (10/1220r1) • LB168 received 1229 comments • Resolution to CID1162 was presented on Oct 14th conf call (802.11-10/1200r1) • Approximately another 160 T/TR CIDs already have proposed resolutions to be presented and are indicated 1220r1 • Contact me if you want to volunteer to resolve CIDs Carlos Cordeiro, Intel Corporation
Report for September 2010 Carlos Cordeiro, Intel Corporation
TGad draft specification update • Draft 0.2 was released on August 05, 2010 • Implements editorial comments and technical comments that passed motion at the July/10 TGad mtg (10/777r0) • Draft 0.3 was released on September 02, 2010 • Speculative draft that implements comments that received no objection during conference calls held after the July/10 TGad mtg • Draft 0.4 was released on September 10, 2010 • Implements corrections identified by the editorial panel • Drafts are publicly available at http://www.ieee802.org/11/TGad/index.html Carlos Cordeiro, Intel Corporation
Comment resolution update (10/717r14) • TGad come out of the July/10 mtg with 120 (out of a total of 513) open comments • Since then, 94 comments had resolutions proposed and received no objections (see list in next slide) • As a result, TGad starts the Sept/10 mtg with 26 open comments • MAC: 1 CID (CID91) • MIB: 16 CIDs • Security: 7 CIDs • Beamforming: 2 CIDs (CID98 and CID292) Carlos Cordeiro, Intel Corporation
CIDs with proposed resolutions which received no objection • Discussed in San Diego, but not motioned: • 320, 330, 331 (BF): 10/717r11 • Conference calls: • 3, 405, 406, 407, 408, 412, 414, 416, 417, 56, 418, 346 (PHY): 10/944r1 • 447, 448, 449, 316, 58, 59, 317, 318, 319, 461, 438, 386, 413 (PHY): 10/894r1 • 112, 113, 141, 232, 247, 378 (MAC): 10/947r1 • 382, 384, 385, 387, 388, 435, 439, 454, 465, 466, 471, 472, 473, 475, 476, 479, 480 (MAC): 10/948r2 • 323, 422, 445, 326, 328, 332, 333, 375, 433, 13, 100, 288, 289, 290, 291, 314, 340, 312, 374, 381, 427, 434, 452, 453, 464, 481, 482 (MAC/BF): 10/977r5 • 159, 256, 225 (MAC): 10/983r0 • 371, 372 (MAC): 10/946r0 • 321, 477 (MAC): 10/1010r0 • 84, 88, 89, 90 (MAC): 10/1007r2 • 175 (MAC): 10/999r0 • 389 (MAC): 10/1014r0 • 368 (MAC): 10/995r5 • 345 (PHY): 10/1029r0 • 487 (General): 10/1004r0, 10/1002r0, 10/1005r0, 10/1013r0, 10/1012r0, 10/1019r0, 10/1026r0, 10/1031r1, 10/1023r1 • 348 (PICS): 10/978r1 Carlos Cordeiro, Intel Corporation
Editorial panel • Email sent to TGad reflector on September 03, 2010, soliciting volunteers for an editorial panel responsible to: • Review drafts for: • Mistakes made by the editor when implementing contributions; and • Editorials • Report those to editor, so that they can be fixed before the TG approves a new draft • Typically, there will be an editorial review for a few days before a new draft is intended to be posted • Volunteers so far: B. Lynch, J. Barr, J. Yee, S. Trainin, S. Grandhi, P. Loc, S. Shankar, T. Derham, L. Chu and I. Toyoda (?) • Contact the editor if you’d like to volunteer Carlos Cordeiro, Intel Corporation
Report for July 2010 Carlos Cordeiro, Intel Corporation
TGad draft specification update • Draft 0.1 was released on May 28, 2010 • Draft is publicly available at http://www.ieee802.org/11/TGad/index.html Carlos Cordeiro, Intel Corporation
Comment submission • Following the release of D0.1, a 3 week commenting period was opened on D0.1 • A total of 513 comments were received – comment database is document 802.11-10/717 • Comments were reviewed during the July 1st conference call and classified into (sub)groups: • 236 editorial comments (ER) = handled directly by the Editor • 277 technical comments (TR) = resolutions to be proposed by volunteers • 2 in the General comment group • 24 in the Beamforming comment group • 207 in the MAC comment group • 41 in the PHY comment group • 3 in the Coexistence comment group Carlos Cordeiro, Intel Corporation
Comment resolution • Comment resolution will take place starting at the July/10 session • Via submissions • Via proposed resolutions suggested by assignees • Via comment review sessions led by the Editor • As per the TGad timeline, goal is to complete comment resolution at the September/10 session and enter WG letter ballot • Any motions to approve comment resolutions should be done by September/10 Carlos Cordeiro, Intel Corporation