90 likes | 222 Views
Changing Precedent. Monday 27 June 2011. Distinguishing. A precedent does not apply because the facts are different The precedent is either added to or not applied. Disapproving. A judge in a lower court disagrees with a precedent set by a higher court.
E N D
Changing Precedent Monday 27 June 2011
Distinguishing • A precedent does not apply because the facts are different • The precedent is either added to or not applied
Disapproving • A judge in a lower court disagrees with a precedent set by a higher court. • However, the precedent must still be followed.
Overruling • A judge in a higher court replaces the original precedent with a different one. • The original precedent is no longer binding.
Reversing • A higher court disagrees with a legal principle stated by a lower court. • The original precedent no longer applies.