370 likes | 554 Views
Veronica Bianchi declares no conflict of interest. Pre & Post morphological selection of oocytes cryopreserved with slow freezing clinical outcomes. Veronica Bianchi Ph.D. ESHRE Senior Embryologist. Outlines. Indications Morphological evaluation (using slow freezing)
E N D
Pre & Post morphological selection of oocytes cryopreserved with slow freezing clinical outcomes Veronica Bianchi Ph.D. ESHRE Senior Embryologist
Outlines • Indications • Morphological evaluation (using slow freezing) • Protocols and procedures available in the literature • Clinical outcome worldwide • Our results with slow cooling • Conclusions
Indications • Restrictions to embryo storage • Ethical • Legal • Failure to produce semen sample and/or no sperm the day of egg retrieval • Fertility preservation in cancer patients • Preservation of women’s fertility • Egg donation
Goals of Cryopreservation Minimize/prevent cryo-injuries from Ice crystals (internally and externally) Toxicity of cryoprotectants Solute effects Osmotic shock Chilling sensitivity Fracture damage Preserve structural integrity and biological viability of cells
sucrose Pr-OH H2O H2O Slow freezing • Wash in PBS • 1.5 M Pr-OH, 10 min • 1.5 Pr-OH / 0.2 M sucrose • load • RT to -8°C, -2°C/min • Seed • Hold, 10 min • -8°C to -30°C, -0.3°C/min • -30°C to -150°C, -50°C/min • Plunge into LN2 Temperature °C Time (min)
Strict adherence to protocol Handling Incubation times 10 min 5 min 1.5 M PROH, 0.1/0.3M sucrose in PBS (L) 1.5 M PROH in PBS (S) Oocyte(s) Loading in straws medium air
Rapid thawing • RT, 30 sec • 30°C water, 40 sec • RT,1.0 M Pr-OH, 0.3 M sucrose, 5 min • RT, 0.5 M Pr-OH, 0.3 M sucrose, 5 min • RT, 0.2 M Pr-OH, 0.3 M sucrose, 10 min • RT, PBS, 10 min • N.B. All freezing/thawing solutions prepared with PBS supplemented with PPS 20% (v/v)
Spindle and chromosome organization in human oocyte frozen after exposure to1.5 Pr-OH / 0.1 M sucrose or1.5 Pr-OH / 0.3 M Coticchio et al., Hum Rep 2006
0.2M/0.3M Protocol Resulted in Less Ultrastructural Damage Title Protocols 0.1M/0.2M 0.3M/0.3M 0.2M/0.3M Ultrastructural damage (vacuolisation) + + + + Cortical granules loss + + + MII spindle damage + – – Coticchio et al., 2006; Nottola et al., 2007; 2008; 2009; De Santis et 2008; Cobo et al., 2008; Bromfield et al., 2009; Coticchio et al., 2009 Bianchi et al 2007
Steady outcome improvement by slow freezing over time 1986 1997 2001-2006 2007 1980 1990 2000 70-75% 70-75% 40-50% Survival 20-30% 70-75% 70-75% 40-50% Fertilization <40% 10-15% 20-30% ??? Cleavage (4-cell) ??? Implantation per thawed oocyte 2.5-2.7% > 5% ??? ???
PROH-Sucrose – SLOW FREEZING protocol 4 different protocols a) 1.5M PROH + 0.1M sucrose (La Salle, 1985; Gook, 1993) b) 1.5M PROH + 0.3M sucrose (Fabbri et al., 2001) c) 0.75 M PROH and 1.5M PROH + 0.2M sucrose (Borini et al. 2009) d) 1.5M PROH + 0.2M sucrose (Bianchi et al. 2007)
0.1M sucrose 0.2M sucrose at freezing at thawing I PROTOCOL (La Salle, 1985; Gook, 1993)
Materials and methods: We started our program on January 1997 until December 2000. 68 couples which asked not to have supernumerary embryos were involved in the program. THREE of the recovered oocytes were inseminated, the remaining oocytes were cryopreserved. Enough oocytes were thawed in order to obtain 3-4 oocytes suitable for ICSI.
0.3M sucrose 0.3M sucrose at freezing at thawing II PROTOCOL (Fabbri et al 2001)
Results from Different Centres Using 0.3 M Protocol were Similar Title Borini Levi Setti La Sala De Santis 2006 2006 2007 2007 % Survived 74 69 73 71 % Fertilised 76 68 N.R. 80 % Implantation 5.2 5.8 3.4 5.7 % Implantation per thawed oocyte 2.6 1.9 2.5 2.6
2 steps PROH (0.75M - 1.5M) + 0.2M sucrose 0.3M sucrose at freezing at thawing III PROTOCOL (Borini et al., 2010)
Slow cooling: multicentric study • Borini et al. 2009 Biological and clinical outcome:
Slow cooling: multicentric study • Borini et al. 2009 Pregnancy outcome:
1 steps PROH (1.5M) + 0.2M sucrose 0.3M sucrose at freezing at thawing IV PROTOCOL (Bianchi et al 2007; submitted)
Our updated results Unpublished data
Overall survival, fertilization and cleavage rates Bianchi et al. submitted 2011
Overall clinical data Bianchi et al. submitted 2011
Survival, fertilization and cleavage rates Bianchi et al. submitted 2011
Overall clinical data Bianchi et al. submitted 2011
Impact of protocol: Performance in vitro of embryos from sibling fresh and frozen oocytes P < 0.001 for all protocols in comparison to control Borini et al., unpublished