100 likes | 317 Views
MALPRACTICE . CIVIL SUITS AGAINST DOCTORS MORE THAN JUST NEGLIGENCE ALSO BREACH OF CONTRACT, FRAUD, ETC. FOCUS TODAY IS NEGLIGENCE NEGLIGENCE IS A “TORT” http://forensicpsychiatry.stanford.edu. CIVIL LAW CONTRACT ◊ PROPERTY ◊ TORT. A TORT IS A CIVIL WRONG
E N D
MALPRACTICE CIVIL SUITS AGAINST DOCTORS MORE THAN JUST NEGLIGENCE ALSO BREACH OF CONTRACT, FRAUD, ETC. FOCUS TODAY IS NEGLIGENCE NEGLIGENCE IS A “TORT” http://forensicpsychiatry.stanford.edu
CIVIL LAW CONTRACT ◊ PROPERTY ◊ TORT • A TORT IS A CIVIL WRONG • SUIT SEEKS COMPENSATORY DAMAGES ($) • THREE TYPES • INTENTIONAL • UNINTENTIONAL (NEGLIGENCE) • STRICT (LIABILITY) • STANDARD OF PROOF FOR LIABILITY • PREPONDERANCE OF EVIDENCE
MEDICAL NEGLIGENCEELEMENTS • DUTY • DO I OWE A DUTY? WHAT IS THE DUTY I OWE? • DERELECTION • BREACH OF STANDARD OF CARE CREATES • UNREASONABLE RISK OF FORESEEABLE HARM • DAMAGE • DIRECTCAUSATION • “BUT FOR” (SCIENTIFIC) • “PROXIMATE” (POLICY ISSUE) • ABSENCE OF DEFENSES • STATUTE OF LIMITATIONS
STANDARD OF CARE • STANDARD OF CARE • ORDINARY, REASONABLE, PRUDENT, UNDER SAME OR SIMILAR CIRCUMSTANCES • NOT SYNONYMOUS WITH OPTIMAL CARE, BEST PRACTICES, ETC • REQUIRES TESTIMONY • FROM EXPERT WITNESS • FROM REASONABLE PATIENT (INFORMED CONSENT) • LEGAL • JUDICIAL (TARASOFF, SAFETY STATUTES) • RES IPSA LOQUITOR • RESPONDEAT SUPERIOR
COMMON CAUSES OF ACTION • NEGLIGENT ASSESSMENT, DIAGNOSIS, CHARTING • NEGLIGENT TREATMENT/FOLLOW-UP • FAILURE TO PREVENT HARM TO PATIENT/OTHERS • LACK OF INFORMED CONSENT (EVENT, PROCESS?) • ABUSE OF TRANSFERENCE (SEX, DECISIONS) • NEGLIGENT SUPERVISION/SUPERVISEE • OTHER • BREACH OF CONTRACT, BREACH OF PRIVACY • DEFAMATION, FRAUD, FALSE IMPRISONMENT
PREVENTIONTHE DUMB DUTIFUL DOCUMENTING SWEETY RARELY SUED • STAY UP TO DATE • PRACTICE IN RIGHT WAY (PROCESS) • IDENTIFY HIGH-RISK PATIENTS • SHARE THERAPEUTIC UNCERTAINTY • MANAGE THERAPEUTIC RELATIONSHIP • THREAT ASSESSMENT: PLAN, ACTION, F/U • GET SECOND OPINION WHEN NECESSARY • ANTICIPATE EVIDENTIARY USE OF CHART
INSURANCE • UNDERSTAND TYPE OF POLICY • KNOW WHAT ACTIVITIES COVERED • KNOW WHEN/HOW TO REPORT AN EVENT • CANNOT INSURE INTENTIONAL WRONGS
MICRA MEDICAL INJURY COMPENSATION REFORM ACT LIMITS AWARDS FOR “PAIN & SUFFERING” LIMITS ATTORNEY CONTINGENCY FEES
MEDICAL BOARD OF CALIFORNIA • CALL IS FROM INVESTIGATOR • 805 REPORT • COST RECOVERY PROGRAM • RANGE OF ENFORCEMENTS/PENALTIES • NO DIVERSION PROGRAMS