250 likes | 560 Views
E N D
1. 1 Kerstin Westermark
Prof., Senior expert, Medical Products Agency, Sweden
Chair, Committee for Orphan Medicinal Products, EMEA
Treatment of Rare Diseases and EU Legislation Prag, May 21, 2009 "Role of COMP and support of research and development of drugs with orphan medicinal product designation in the EU"
2. Who wants to be an Orphan?
3. Why an Orphan Regulation? Regulation (EC) No 141/2000 of the European Parliament and of the Council on Orphan Medicinal Products of 16 December 1999
“Persons suffering from rare conditions should be entitled to the same quality of treatment as other patients”
But…
“ the pharmaceutical industry would be unwilling to develop the medicinal product under normal market conditions”
As…
“some conditions occur so infrequently that the cost of developing and bringing to the market a medicinal product (…) would not be recovered by the expected sales”
4. Which Incentives in EU for Orphan designated Medicinal Products (OMP)? Market Exclusivity in the EU
- 10 years for all orphan medicines (from marketing authorisation)
+ 2 years if Paediatrics Investigational Plan (PIP) results included in the MA and reflected in the SPC
Fee reductions for OMP development
Application for OMP Designation: free of charge
Protocol assistance and follow up from the EMEA: free of charge
Application for Marketing Authorisation: free of charge for Small and
Medium-sized Enterprises (from 2009)
+ Extended incentives for SMEs in post authorisation
EU marketing authorisation through unique centralised procedure
Priority to EU Research - Framework programs
Access to Member States Incentives (EC inventory)
5. EMEA European Medicines Agency (EMEA) Coordinates evaluation and supervision of medicinal products
throughout the EU
Brings together scientific resources of the 27 EU Member States – network of the national competent authorities
Has around 100 working groups/parties and access to a network of c:a 4000 European experts
Works through 6 Committees:
- CHMP Committee for Medicinal Products for Human Use
- COMP Committee for Orphan Medicinal Products
- PDCO Paediatric Committee
- CAT Committee for Advanced Therapies
- HMPC Herbal Medicinal products Committee
- CVMP Committee for Veterinary Medicinal Products
The committees give Opinions –
The EU Commission gives Decisions
6. Committee for Orphan MPs (COMP)
7. Tasks of the COMP Examine applications for designation of a medicinal product as an orphan medicinal product (OMP)
Assist the Commission in drawing up guidelines
Assist the Commission in liaising internationally and with patient support groups
Advise the Commission on a policy on orphan medicinal products for the EU
8.
Examine applications for designation of a medicinal product as an orphan medicinal product (OMP)
What was expected in year 2000?
C:a 15 applications
Four-five1 day meetings/year
What was the result?
More than 100 applications/year
Eleven 2-day meetings/year
9. Criteria for Orphan Designation SERIOUS CONDITIONS
(life threatening, chronically disabling)
RARE < 5/10.000 individuals in the EU
or
LACK OF RETURN ON INVESTMENT
NO SATISFACTORY TREATMENT
or
"SIGNIFICANT BENEFIT"
(A clinically relevant advantage or
a major contribution to patient care)
10. Protocol assistance Protocol assistance ? scientific advice
for companies developing OMPs
Questions on quality-efficacy-safety
Questions on significant benefit
Company position required
SAWP (Scientific Advice Working Party) provides answers; COMP represented by 3 members
CHMP adopts answers
COMP involved/adopts answers on significant benefit
Follow-up Protocol Assistance possible
11. Protocol assistance - improved chances for a successful marketing authorisation application! Orphan Drug development requires:
Flexibility at Regulatory level
Potential for alternative approaches
Strive for efficiency
But - No new methods for rare disorders
13. Guidance Documents (cont'd) Points to consider on the calculation and reporting of the prevalence of a condition for orphan designation (EMEA/COMP/436/01)
Guideline on clinical trials in small populations (CHMP/EWP/83561/2005)
+ several CHMP – guidelines (general and disease/drug specific)
15. EMEA Marketing Authorisation – Centralised procedure Mandatory for orphan designated products
One single marketing authorisation application to the EMEA
A single evaluation by the Committee for medicinal products for Human Use (CHMP)
If quality, safety and efficacy sufficiently proven – positive opinion
Opinion sent to EU Commission – transformation into a single marketing authorisation valid for the whole of EU
16. 10 (+2) years of Market exclusivity Protection against
similar products (structure/mechanism of action) for same indication
Three derogations
Sponsor’s consent
Lack of supply
Clinical superiority
17. International Co-operation (Confidentiality arrangements existing) Facilitating Cooperative Efforts on the Orphan Regulatory Process
EU (EC and EMEA) and the US FDA/DHHS
(actions ongoing)
EU (EC and EMEA) and Japan MHLW/PMDA
(actions planned)
EU (EC and EMEA) and Health Canada
(actions started)
18. Since November 2007Common Application Form EMEA/COMP – FDA/OOPD for Orphan Medicinal Product designation A common form to simplify administrative process
First step in harmonising administrative practices
BUT
Different regulations and procedures:
- Different criteria/requirements (prevalence threshold, significant benefit)
- Different approaches (definition of condition)
- No single opinion EU and US
19. EMEA/COMP-FDA/OOPD(currently ongoing/planned) Regular contacts – monthly teleconferences EMEA-FDA:
Exchange of information on ongoing orphan designation application procedures between the two agencies
Annual reports on development:
Timeline and structure harmonisation
Guidelines on orphan designation:
Existing EMEA/COMP guidelines
Proposal for future discussion and harmonisation of common terms
20. TOMORROW: Facilitating Cooperative Efforts on the Orphan Regulatory Process – The Global Approach Creating an international forum for discussion on the harmonisation of terminology and concepts related to designation
Sharing international expertise and discussing divergent opinions
Creating an international network of experts to be used for designation
Discussing a global approach for stimulation of research linked to orphan designation
Global administrative harmonisation
21. EU Orphan regulation 141/2000 – A SUCCESS STORY Before the EU - 27 different marketing approval procedures for every new drug
Before the EU Orphan Regulation – almost no development of drugs for rare diseases/conditions
Today, after more than 9 years of the Orphan Regulation
– 937 applications for orphan designation/ 648 positive opinions/ 231 withdrawals/ 13 negative opinions
Today, after more than 9 years of the Orphan Regulation
- 53 marketing authorisations for orphan drugs
- via centralised procedure
= 1 procedure for 27 Member States
Update May 6, 2009
22. EU Orphan Regulation 141/2000 - Opportunities for patients with rare conditions Potential benefits for 30 milj. European patients with rare conditions
Potential benefits for neglected diseases, e.g. tbc, malaria, leishmaniasis – rare in the EU – prevalent in the rest of the world
To date, 53 orphan medicinal products have been given marketing authorisation, a main part innovative drugs from micro-, small and medium sized enterprises (e.g. gene therapy for SCID)
Potential benefit for the understanding of and drug development for common diseases
"Learning from the Rare" (William Harvey)
but
Challenges
Profitability – Costs - Avalibility
23. How can COMP contribute- What's on/What's next? COMP members in Scientific Advice Working Party (SAWP) "full advice" – not only significant benefit questions
Increased collaboration/harmonisation between EMEA committees (COMP- CHMP-PDCO-CAT)
Increased transparency in COMP opinions - COMP role in scientific assessment of "clinical added value" of OMPs
Increasing role of COMP visavi stakeholders (patient organisations, industry, health care professionals/academia) – regular meetings/focus groups/conferences
COMP members in EU Commission Rare Disease Task Force (RDTF) – future Committee of Experts on Rare Diseases (CERD)
COMP as advisors to the EU Commission (DG Enterprise/Sanco/Research (Rare diseases FP7 priority: Support fro clincial trials in phase I-II in designated OMPs – 2009?
COMP members as Member States "ambassadeurs" for Rare Diseases/Orphan Drugs (National plans; National registries etc.)
24. From challenge to solution? 4th Eurordis' survey on OMPs availability in the EU(F.Bignami, MEDEV meeting, Brussels, Jan. 2008)
25. The way forward Conclusions and Recommendations from the High Level Pharmaceutical Forum (Oct. 2, 2008)
http://europa.eu/pharmaforum/docs/final_conclusions_en.pdf
- Commission Communication and Recommendation on Rare Diseases; "Rare diseases - Europe's challenges" (Nov. 11, 2008)
http://ec.europa.eu/health/ph_threats/non_com/rare_10_en.htm
Proposal for a COUNCIL RECOMMENDATION on a European action in the field of rare diseases
http://ec.europa.eu/health/ph_threats/non_com/docs/rare_rec_en.pdf