1 / 18

Casualty Actuarial Society May 17, 2005

Casualty Actuarial Society May 17, 2005. MMC Capital. Property/Casualty Industry’s ROE is Lower than All Industries’ ROE. Source: Insurance Information Institute, Fortune. Property/Casualty Industry’s ROE is Lower than Other Financial Services Industries’ ROEs. Asset Management.

kamuzu
Download Presentation

Casualty Actuarial Society May 17, 2005

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. Casualty Actuarial SocietyMay 17, 2005 MMC Capital

  2. Property/Casualty Industry’s ROE is Lower than All Industries’ ROE Source: Insurance Information Institute, Fortune

  3. Property/Casualty Industry’s ROE is Lower than Other Financial Services Industries’ ROEs Asset Management Investment Banks Credit Cards Brokerages Commercial Banks Life P&C Source: McKinsey & Company

  4. Insurance Industry can be an Attractive Sector for Investments • Large, growing and profitable • Investment opportunities created by market dislocations, restructuring and outsourcing trends • Very complex, diversified and highly regulated • Few private equity investors focus on this sector • Wide disparity between best and worst performers

  5. Top Performing Quintile Second Quintile Third Quintile Fourth Quintile Fifth Quintile Performance of Property/Casualty Companies Varies Widely Source: McKinsey & Company

  6. Categories WinnersLosers Commercial Lines AIG Reliance/Kemper Reinsurance Renaissance Re Trenwick/Gerling Re Personal Lines Progressive American Horizon Start-Ups AXIS ESG Re Services Sedgwick CMS MRM The Insurance Industry Is Made Up Of Winners And Losers

  7. Underwriting Performance is the Key to Book Value Growth Source: Dowling & Partners

  8. The U.S. P/C Insurance Industry Is Large U.S. P/C premiums were $423bn in 2004 (3.6% of U.S. GDP) Source: A.M. Best.

  9. U.S. Property/Casualty Premiums Have Grown Faster Than The U.S. Economy U.S. P/C Insurance Premiums were $423bn in 2004 U.S. Property & Casualty NPW CAGR: 6.6% U.S. Nominal GDP CAGR: 5.6% Source: Bureau of Economic Analysis, A.M. Best and Insurance Information Institute.

  10. P/C Industry Has Earned $337 Billion In Net Income Since 1985 U.S. P/C net income Average ROE = 8.6% Source: Insurance Services Office and Insurance Information Institute. Net income includes realized capital gains. Average ROE is represents average ROE for 1986 – 2004 period.

  11. P/C Insurance Underwriting Fundamentals Are Not Correlated With Equity Markets Change in commercial lines rates versus change in S&P 500 Source: Goldman Sachs Research and Bloomberg.

  12. The Private Equity Industry Is Under-Invested In The Insurance Industry ($ in billions) Contribution of Insurance Premiums to GDP U.S. (1) Global (2) Insurance Premiums $ 890 $ 2,408 GDP $10,446 $30,757 % of GDP 8.5% 7.8% Private Equity Capital Invested (’93 – ’02) (3) Total Ex. 9/11 (4) Insurance Investments $ 8.9 $ 5.6 Total Investments $ 174.5 $ 171.2 % of Total 5.1% 3.3% • Source: A.M. Best and Bureau of Economic Analysis 2002 Data. • Source: Sigma Research 2001 Data. • (3) Source: PricewaterhouseCoopers/Venture Economics/NVCA MoneyTree Survey and MMC Capital.Excludes venture capital investments. • (4) Excludes AXIS, Allied World, Endurance, Montpelier Re, Arch and Olympus.

  13. Periodic Market Dislocations

  14. Post 9/11 Start-ups have Generated Attractive Investment Returns

  15. P/C Industry Undergoes Constant Business Realignments Consolidation/Entering New Businesses Divestitures/Exiting Businesses • Travelers – Aetna P/C • AIG – Sun America, American General • Chubb – Executive Risk, Hiscox • St. Paul – USF&G, MMI • Berkshire Hathaway – General Re • ACE – Tempest Re, CIGNA P/C • XL – Mid Ocean, NAC Re • Fairfax Financial – Crum & Forster, Seneca, Odyssey Re • Citigroup – Travelers • Zurich – Converium • St. Paul – Platinum • CNA – personal lines • Multi-lines: • Aetna – P/C, Reinsurance • Cigna – P/C • Lincoln Financial – P/C Outsourcing Market Dislocations • Claims Administration – CMS, Gallager Basset, Crawford, Cambridge • Warranty Servicing – Signal, Asurion, Lock/line, NEW • Software & Information Services – AMS, Applied, A.M. Best, ISO • Run-off Management – Castlewood, East Gate, Resolution Group (Fairfax) • Investment management – Wellington, BlackRock, New England, PIMCO • HR / Benefits – Hewitt, Towers Perrin • Liability crisis – ACE, XL • Property Catastrophe reinsurance – Mid Ocean, Partner Re, Renaissance Re, IPC Holdings, LaSalle Re • 9/11 – AXIS, Arch, Allied World, Endurance, Montpelier Re

  16. Ownership Changes – Top 50 Property/Casualty Groups in 1985

  17. MMC Capital Investment Considerations • Market Size • Supply / demand imbalance • Rate adequacy • Historical profitability • Management track record • Key success factors • Distribution • Capital/rating • Exit

  18. Trident Has Invested Successfully In A Variety of Underwriting Situations Valuations as of 3/31/2005

More Related