1 / 28

Recent Experience on Building Collapses under Snow Loads

Recent Experience on Building Collapses under Snow Loads. Stewart Macartney – blyth+blyth. Background. A significant number of buildings collapsed in January 2010 and late 2010/early 2011 Majority were agricultural buildings although some unheated industrial buildings also failed

karid
Download Presentation

Recent Experience on Building Collapses under Snow Loads

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. Recent Experience on Building Collapses under Snow Loads Stewart Macartney – blyth+blyth

  2. Background • A significant number of buildings collapsed in January 2010 and late 2010/early 2011 • Majority were agricultural buildings although some unheated industrial buildings also failed • Share with you some of the issues identified in building failures we have looked into • Form of structures varied – portal frames, trussed roofs, and concrete buildings. • I would stress that these are my views and not necessarily those of SER

  3. Some Questions to Consider • What was the weight of snow and ice on the roofs at the time they collapsed • Were the buildings designed and constructed properly for the site, altitude and location • Were the materials used correctly specified • Were there workmanship issues during construction • Were there maintenance issues • Was this an exceptional event??

  4. What is the Density of Snow? • Much research on snow density and how it changes with age has been done in the study of avalanches. • Typically new snow has a density of between 70 – 120 kg/m3. • Wind driven snow can reach a density of between 300 – 400 kg/m3. • Old snow, which has gone through a number of freeze/thaw cycles can reach densities as high as 600kg/m3.

  5. What is the Density of Snow? • BS 6399:Pt 3 Appendix B gives an assumed loading of 2 kN/m3 in drift conditions • EC1 is better and Annex E which is permitted to be used by the National annexe gives a range of values depending on the type of snow:

  6. Measured Density • Measured densities on site ranged from 110 kg/m3 for fresh snow to 550kg/m3 for old crystalline snow • Density varied across the site both with location and height

  7. Agricultural Building Classifications to BS5502

  8. BS5502 guidance on snow loads

  9. Comparison of Design Snow Loads

  10. Design Loads v Actual Snow • Estimated Snow Load on Structures at Time of Collapse was1.51 kN/m2 based on snow structure inspected • Met Office snow records give depths at various weather stations. However it is my opinion that loadings calculated from these would not necessarily recognise any ice build up or snow aging

  11. BS v EC • A comparison of the snow maps between BS6399 and EC1 NA shows that for some areas of Scotland, the loads in Zone 4 may be underestimated compared to the contour map given previously

  12. Other Findings • One of the buildings we looked at was a “second hand” structure that had been rebuilt on a new site. The new location was higher than the altitude assumed in the original design.

  13. Other Findings • One of the buildings had been extended by adding another portal frame creating a valley drift condition.

  14. Conclusions • When considering the reduced design loadings permitted in BS5502 we can see why agricultural buildings were more prone to failure • The climatic conditions which resulted in repeated snow falls and freeze-thaw cycle led to gradual incremental increase in loading to failure • The density of the snow accumulations are likely to have been higher than the codes state

  15. Conclusions • I believe that some of the snow falls were exceptional events - i.e. Greater than the 1:50 yr probability given in the codes • Low temperatures may also have impacted on material performance – i.e. Temps as low as -22oC were recorded.

  16. Some Questions? • Are two consecutive winters of near identical climatic conditions two exceptional events?! • Given that we have had two consecutive winters where considerable loss of property was experienced - do we need to look at revising the design codes? • Are we at risk of under estimating snow loads using the zoning given on snow map in EC1?

  17. A Parting Thought • With the recent changes in Building Regulations in relation to insulation; which will lead to better insulated buildings - Do we need to review snow loading guidelines? • This thought is prompted by the collapses of buildings that were unheated ....... A condition we are effectively creating by limiting heat losses through the roofs

More Related