160 likes | 242 Views
Buddhism in China. Madyamica and Yogacara influence Schemes of intellectualization of Buddhist achievement Realize something = enlightenment –usually not speakable Madyamika positive to Yogacara Negative Buddha nature (Nirvana) as substantive nothing Merge into Major Chinese Schools
E N D
Buddhism in China • Madyamica and Yogacara influence • Schemes of intellectualization of Buddhist achievement • Realize something = enlightenment –usually not speakable • Madyamika positive to Yogacara Negative • Buddha nature (Nirvana) as substantive nothing • Merge into Major Chinese Schools • 天台 Tiantai and 華嚴 Huayan for theory • 禪 chan/sim/zen for practice • Meditation school without meditation (and lots!)
Internal & External Stories • Hui Neng symbolizes the simplicity • Activity and enlightenment • No “dust” (no illusions) only pure Buddha-nature • Paradox of desire final conclusion • External story of rebellion • Intellectualized (metaphysical), impractical • Shift of culture to the South • Rejects authority (official recognition) • Politics and taxes • Daoist painter/poet as author
Questions Last Quiz Final test in prep—question to Cathy
Daoism and Desires • Desires caused by distinctions • Like Nietzsche—give up the contrast together • Reject other contrasts (meditation, enlightenment) • Positive about life & skill-transcendence goals • Reject distinction of these and the metaphysical other—transcending world • Not quite “this is nirvana;” more like do not conclude “there is only the apparent world” • Just stop talking that way and get back to savoring your sandwich
Great Liberation • Rush to claim descent from Hui Neng • Wide variety but Feng's 5 common doctrines: • No (expressible) highest truth • Spiritual cultivation cannot be cultivated • In the last resort nothing is gained • There is nothing much in Buddhist teaching • In carrying water and chopping wood lies the wonderful dao
Iconoclastic Stories • Function: like koans? • Burning or spitting on the Buddha • Just wood (everything is Buddha) • No temples, praying, bowing, shaving, begging, ritual, chanting • Chan as Buddhist atheism • Survival in persecutions
Umbrella to left or right of clogs? Every Moment Zen
Begs release from fear of death A Koan– meaningless Absorbed in care for patients and lost fear of death Zen is care for patients Doctor Story
Values of eating, drinking, sleeping Tiger and strawberry The Strawberry
Teaching Techniques • Interview time—anti-metaphysical • Spit, beat, shout, awaken! • Koan—give up • Walking Zen • Never tell too plainly • Envy of Confucians
Final Jump • Modern scientific philosophy • With a social model of language • Social cooperation rather than picturing the world • Closer to Chinese/Nietzsche conception • Reality in the back door • Science as a dao
Evolution and Utility • Some ways of talking dominate, others die out • Science with the Nietzsche twist • A social way to survive and thrive • Science: a system of "useful" beliefs • Natural framework—also anti-Plato and anti-Descartes
Belief Analysis • Habits of action • not internal pictures • Practical (practice) focus • Successful or not: utility and survival • Different interpretations of “success” • Peirce, Dewey, James
First Formulation: Peirce • Hard time finding a job and publisher • Popular mechanics for “The Fixation of Belief" and “How to Make Our Ideas Clear." • Radical new analysis of belief/doubt • An "irritation," • Belief as a comfortable "habit of action" • Not a picture of a fact!
Practical Problem • How to achieve that comfort? • Fixed beliefs allow smooth, efficient action • Stability and "constancy" • Requires less of the "disruption" of doubt • Four candidates: tenacity, authority, a priori, science/reality