180 likes | 206 Views
THE COACH’S DILEMMA. by Daniele & Gianfranco Gambarelli. Group D FIRST DAY: June 14th. Group D. NEXT MATCH. vs. ATTACK OR DEFENSE?. Costa Rica. Italy. Cesare Prandelli Jorge Luis Pinto. THE FORECASTS. THE FORECASTS. , ,. % ITA win. % C.R. win. % draw.
E N D
THE COACH’S DILEMMA by Daniele & Gianfranco Gambarelli
Group D FIRST DAY: June 14th
NEXT MATCH vs
ATTACK OR DEFENSE? Costa Rica Italy Cesare Prandelli Jorge Luis Pinto
THE FORECASTS , , % ITA win. % C.R. win. % draw 56, 34, 10 76, 19, 05 61, 24, 15 66, 09, 25 66, 14, 20 THE PAYOFFS DEFENSE - DEFENSE ITA Payoff 0.56 x 3 + 0.34 x 1 = 2.02 C.R. Payoff 0.10 x 3 + 0.34 x 1 = 0.64
THE PAYOFFS THE STRATEGIES , ITA Payoff C.R. Payoff < 2.02 , 0.64 2.47, 0.34 < < < 2.07, 0.84 2.12 , 0.74 THE SOLUTION ATTACK DEFENSE
NO DOMINANCE? Nash (1950) Having called qAD = % defense of A qAO = % attack of A h = (aOD - aOO) / (aDO + aOD - aDD - aOO), it is: qAD = h if 0 h 1. Elsewhere 0 if min (aDD, aDO) < min (aOD, aOO) qAD = 1 if min (aDD, aDO) > min (aOD, aOO) x: 0 < x < 1 otherwise qAO = 1 - qAD.
THE STABILITY +10% -10% 61, 65, 15 20,31, 08 20, 24,15 73,65,03 56, 34, 10 76, 19, 05 71,65, 15 20,08, 21 68, 17, 15 20, 65,15 66, 09, 25 66, 14, 20
AN OPEN PROBLEM: • Discrete Continuum
CONCLUSIONS: • To Game-Theorists: Discrete Continuum • To Coaches: Before the match No stone unturned • To Curious: …