340 likes | 489 Views
HELMS & GREENE, LLC. When it’s all on the line. Presentation. Introduction. Kirk Willis. Hypothetical #1. Jethro and Ellie Mae’s Weddin’. Hypothetical #2. Thelma and Louise Best of Friends!. Hypothetical #3. Bonnie and Clyde. Wrongful Death. Damages. Damages. i. Survival Claim.
E N D
HELMS & GREENE, LLC When it’s all on the line Presentation Introduction Kirk Willis
Hypothetical #1 Jethro and Ellie Mae’s Weddin’
Hypothetical #2 Thelma and Louise Best of Friends!
Hypothetical #3 Bonnie and Clyde
Wrongful Death Damages Damages i Survival Claim Survival Claim Bystander Claim Bystander Claim
Parties to a Wrongful Death Action Surviving Spouse Children Parents
Spouses Must be a legal spouse at time of death • Formal • Common Law Void Marriage Voidable Marriage
Children Minors and Adoptees Illegitimate Children Adult Children
Parents Natural? Adopted? Stepparents? Foster Parents? Managing Conservator?
No Recovery Family Members Who DoNot Recover Brother Sister Aunts Uncles Close Cousins Great Friends Mother-in-Law
Parents Do Not Take Exemplary Damages Limits to Recovery • Spouse • “Heirs of the Body”
Evidence Needed to Carry Burden No speculation No Passion, Bias or Prejudice
Evidence Law Bias Sympathy Prejudice
Defenses Legal Shoes Parental Immunity Statute of Limitations
Defenses Legal Shoes Parental Immunity Statute of Limitations
Wrongful Death Damages i Survival Claim Bystander Claim
Pecuniary Loss Care Maintenance Support Service Advice Counsel
Loss of Companionship and Society Relationship Living Arrangement Absence Harmony of Family Common Interest
Mental Anguish Emotional Pain Torment Anguish Rather than Physical Pain
Loss of Inheritance Beneficiaries may recover the present value that the deceased would have added to the estate • Apartments • Stocks • Profit Sharing
Jury Consideration Relationship between parties Living arrangement Any absence for long period of time Harmony of family unit Common interests and activities • Letters • Photos • Videotapes • Audiotapes • Movies
Evidence Law Bias Sympathy Prejudice
Jury Consideration Relationship between parties Living arrangement Any absence for long period of time Harmony of family unit Common interests and activities • Letters • Photos • Videotapes • Audiotapes • Movies
Wrongful Death Damages i Survival Claim Bystander Claim
Survivor Action Heirs Appointed Legal Representative Estates Executor of Will
Survivor Action Damages Pain, suffering and mental anguish Medical expenses Funeral and burial expenses Property damages Exemplary damages
Action for Personal Injuries Held by the Victim at the Time of Death
Other Statutes Worker’s Compensation DTPA Claims
Wrongful Death Damages i Survival Claim Bystander Claim
Bystander Claim Elements 3rd party must have suffered serious injury or death The mental anguish suffered by the bystander must be foreseeable as determined by three factors: • Bystander located near scene • The shock to bystander resulted from serious and contemporaneous observation of accident • Bystander must be closely related to victim
“Dillion” Rule “Zone of Danger” “Contemporaneous Perception” “Close Relationship Requirement”
Plaintiff was near scene of accident Contemporaneous perception Where the plaintiff and victim were closely related
HELMS & GREENE, LLC When it’s all on the line Thank You Kirk Willis 469.893.1870 kwillis@helmsgreene.com