1 / 30

The Brave New World of Hedge Fund Indexes Desperately Seeking Pure Style Indexes

The Brave New World of Hedge Fund Indexes Desperately Seeking Pure Style Indexes. Lionel Martellini Marshall School of Business University of Southern California Chercheur Associé EDHEC martelli@usc.edu Joint work with Noël Amenc.

kimn
Download Presentation

The Brave New World of Hedge Fund Indexes Desperately Seeking Pure Style Indexes

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. The Brave New World of Hedge Fund Indexes Desperately Seeking Pure Style Indexes Lionel Martellini Marshall School of Business University of Southern California Chercheur Associé EDHEC martelli@usc.edu Joint work with Noël Amenc © Edhec 2002 Mesure de la Performance et des Risques de la Gestion Alternative 18/06/02

  2. Outline • Motivation • Performance Mesurement and Asset Allocation • Problems with Hedge Fund Indexes • The World of Hedge Fund Indexes • Overview of Popular Hedge Fund Strategies • Survey of Existing Hedge Fund Indexes • Hedge Fund Indexes are not Created Equal • Heterogeity in Competing Hedge Fund Index Returns • Implications for Asset Allocation • Desperately Seeking Pure Style Indexes • Statistical Approach • Portfolio Approach • How Pure is Pure? • The Two Basic Theorems of Pure Indexing • Testing Representativeness of Pure Indexes © Edhec 2002 Mesure de la Performance et des Risques de la Gestion Alternative 18/06/02

  3. Motivation From an Absolute to a Relative Return Perspective • HF managers often use risk-free rate as a benchmark • This absolute return approach is theoretically valid if and only if • CAPM is the true model • Hedge fund beta is zero • Hedge fund indexes and sub-indexes are a natural choice for benchmarking hedge fund returns • Right benchmarking is a fundamental problem in the presence of incentive fees • Reliable HF indexes are also needed for • Strategic Asset Allocation • Tactical Asset Allocation © Edhec 2002 Mesure de la Performance et des Risques de la Gestion Alternative 18/06/02

  4. Universe of Equity (20000+) MSCI Sub-Universe Russell Sub Universe Wilshire Sub-Universe (5000 approx) S&P Indices (value, growth) Russell Indices (growth,value) Motivation Equity Universe, Sub-Universes, and Specialized Indexes • Composite of World Unknown • Sub-universe (e.g., MSCI) may or may not represent World Index • Competing indexes for the same universe © Edhec 2002 Mesure de la Performance et des Risques de la Gestion Alternative 18/06/02

  5. MotivationHF Universe, Sub-Universes, and Specialized Indexes Zurich Sub-Universe (1300 approx) Universe of Hedge Funds (6000+) Zurich Hedge Fund Indices CSFB/Tremont Index TASS Sub-Universe EACM 100 HFR Sub Universe • Composite of World Unknown • Sub-universe (e.g., HFR, TASS) may or may not represent World Index • Competing indexes for the same universe © Edhec 2002 Mesure de la Performance et des Risques de la Gestion Alternative 18/06/02

  6. Motivation Problems are Amplified for Hedge Fund Indexes • Existing indexes are not fully representative • Because of the lack of regulation on hedge fund performance disclosure, existing data bases only cover a relatively small fraction of the hedge fund population • Probably only a little more than half of existing hedge funds choose to self-report their performance to one of the major hedge fund databases • One of the most popular hedge fund indexes, the EACM 100, does not account for more than a tiny percentage of all existing hedge funds • Most HF indexes are equally-weighted (all but CSFB/Tremont) • Existing indexes are biased • Most hedge fund indexes are based upon managers' self-proclaimed styles • Given that hedge fund managers jealously protect the secret of their investment strategies (the so-called black-box problem), relying on managers' self-proclaimed style is actually almost a necessity • This procedure only makes sense under the following two conditions: (1) a manager follows a unique investment and (2) a manager's self-proclaimed style matches the manager's actual trading strategies • Style drift problem (see for example Lhabitant (2001)) © Edhec 2002 Mesure de la Performance et des Risques de la Gestion Alternative 18/06/02

  7. Population of hedge funds following a given strategy Lack of representativeness Sample of hedge funds in the database used by a given commercial index Presence of a style bias MotivationPure Style Indexes are not Observable © Edhec 2002 Mesure de la Performance et des Risques de la Gestion Alternative 18/06/02

  8. World of HF Indexes – Popular StrategiesHedge Funds Classification © Edhec 2002 Mesure de la Performance et des Risques de la Gestion Alternative 18/06/02

  9. World of HF Indexes – Popular StrategiesHedge Funds Styles • Directional strategies: aimed at benefiting from market movements and trends • Global macro • Hedge (long bias) • Long (e.g. “growth” or “value” stocks) • Short (e.g. “overvalued”, “glamour” stocks) • Non directional strategies: • Event driven (corporate events such as takeovers, spin-offs, mergers, etc.) • Restructuring (buying or shorting securities of companies under Chapter 11 and/or undergoing some form of reorganization) • Fixed-income arbitrage (long and short via treasuries, corporate and/or asset-backed securities) • Capital structure arbitrage (buying and selling different securities of the same issuer, e.g., convertibles/common stock) • Equity market neutral (long-short zero beta strategies) © Edhec 2002 Mesure de la Performance et des Risques de la Gestion Alternative 18/06/02

  10. World of HF Indexes – Competing ProvidersThere exist at least a Dozen HF Index Providers © Edhec 2002 Mesure de la Performance et des Risques de la Gestion Alternative 18/06/02

  11. World of HF Indexes – Competing ProvidersStrategies Covered in this Paper © Edhec 2002 Mesure de la Performance et des Risques de la Gestion Alternative 18/06/02

  12. World of HF Indexes – Competing ProvidersStrategies Not Covered in this Paper ©Edhec 2002 Mesure de la Performance et des Risques de la Gestion Alternative 18/06/02

  13. Hedge Fund Indexes are not Created EqualHeterogenity in Hedge Fund Indexes – Max Difference © Edhec 2002 Mesure de la Performance et des Risques de la Gestion Alternative 18/06/02

  14. Hedge Fund Indexes are not Created EqualHeterogeity in Hedge Fund Indexes – Correlation © Edhec 2002 Mesure de la Performance et des Risques de la Gestion Alternative 18/06/02

  15. Hedge Fund Indexes are not Created EqualImplications for Asset Allocation Efficient frontiers based on monthly data for the period extending from January 1996 to October 2001 © Edhec 2002 Mesure de la Performance et des Risques de la Gestion Alternative 18/06/02

  16. Desperately Seeking Pure Style IndexesInvestment in Hedge Funds • Problems • Competing indexes disagree • All are potentially flawed • Can not tell which is best • All existing indexes have both advantages and drawbacks • For example, Zurich indexes may be less biased than some of their competitors, but they are less representative • Statistical approach • Portfolio approach • Maximization of Representativeness • Minimization of Bias © Edhec 2002 Mesure de la Performance et des Risques de la Gestion Alternative 18/06/02

  17. Desperately Seeking Pure Style IndexesStatistical Approach – Kalman Filter • Simple model • Rkt is the return on competing index k • It is the (unobservable) return on pure index • ekt is the noise, measurement error resulting from presence of biases and absence of representativeness • Assume normally distributed pure indexes and measurement errors • Kalman filter is used both to evaluate the likelihood function and to forecast and smooth the unobserved state variables • Here, our motivation is to estimate (smooth) the unobserved pure index, based on the observed returns on competing indexes: © Edhec 2002 Mesure de la Performance et des Risques de la Gestion Alternative 18/06/02

  18. Desperately Seeking Pure Style IndexesStatistical Approach – The Results Performance of Kalman filter pure index (in parenthesis, the average of competing index) © Edhec 2002 Mesure de la Performance et des Risques de la Gestion Alternative 18/06/02

  19. Desperately Seeking Pure Style IndexesStatistical Approach – Convertible Arbitrage © Edhec 2002 Mesure de la Performance et des Risques de la Gestion Alternative 18/06/02

  20. Desperately Seeking Pure Style IndexesPortfolio Approach – The Method • Black-Box problem • A pure index generated Kalman filtering techniques has an appealing built-in element of optimality (minimized mean squared error) • It can not, however, be regarded as index in its own right, since it can not be expressed as a portfolio of individual hedge funds • Portfolio approach • Taking a portfolio of existing indexes should intuitively be better than selecting any of them • Is equally-weighting a good scheme? • Maximization of representativeness • Principal component analysis • Minimization of bias • Minimum-variance analysis © Edhec 2002 Mesure de la Performance et des Risques de la Gestion Alternative 18/06/02

  21. Desperately Seeking Pure Style IndexesPortfolio Approach – PCA • Use factor analysis techniques to generate a set of pure indexes • They can be thought of as the best possible one-dimensional summaries of information conveyed by competing indexes for a given style, in the sense of the larger fraction of the variance explained. • Here, we are looking for the portfolio weights that make the combination of competing indexes capture the largest possible fraction of the information contained in the data from the various competing indexes • The method • From a mathematical standpoint, it involves transforming a set of K correlated competing indexes into a set of orthogonal variables, or implicit factors, which reproduces the original information present in the correlation structure • Each implicit factor is defined as a linear combination of original variables • Use the first component of a PCA of competing indexes as a candidate for a pure style index (typically captures a large proportion of cross-sectional variations because competing styles tend to be at least somewhat positively correlated) © Edhec 2002 Mesure de la Performance et des Risques de la Gestion Alternative 18/06/02

  22. Desperately Seeking Pure Style IndexesPCA – The Results © Edhec 2002 Mesure de la Performance et des Risques de la Gestion Alternative 18/06/02

  23. Desperately Seeking Pure Style IndexesPortfolio Approach – Min Var Analysis • Pure hedge fund indexes generated as the first component in a factor analysis should be as representative as possible since there is no other linear combination of competing indexes that implies a lower information loss • Another approach consists in focusing on minimization of the bias • Use same model as before • Add assumptions • Noise term is zero on average • Noise term is uncorrelated with return on pure index • Homoscedastic model © Edhec 2002 Mesure de la Performance et des Risques de la Gestion Alternative 18/06/02

  24. Desperately Seeking Pure Style IndexesPortfolio Approach – Min Var Analysis • Define the return on a portfolio of indexes • Under previous assumptions, we have that • The problem of minimizing the bias is • Solution is © Edhec 2002 Mesure de la Performance et des Risques de la Gestion Alternative 18/06/02

  25. Desperately Seeking Pure Style IndexesPortfolio Approach – Additional Assumption • If one is willing to make the additional assumption of no correlation between noise terms for various competing indexes, then the variance-covariance matrix of residuals is diagonal, and one obtains the following simple solution • May also impose positivity constraints to ensure that resulting index is a long-only portfolio of individual hedge funds © Edhec 2002 Mesure de la Performance et des Risques de la Gestion Alternative 18/06/02

  26. Desperately Seeking Pure Style IndexesPortfolio Approach – Additional Assumption © Edhec 2002 Mesure de la Performance et des Risques de la Gestion Alternative 18/06/02

  27. Index 1 Index 2 Index 3 How Pure is Pure?The Two (Obvious) Theorems of Pure Indexing • PCA and min-var analysis have appealing element of optimality • However, any portfolio (e.g., equally-weighted portfolio) should perform better than competing indexes • Theorem 1: An index of the indexes is always less biased than the average of the set of indexes it is extracted from • Theorem 2: An index of the indexes is always more representative than any competing index © Edhec 2002 Mesure de la Performance et des Risques de la Gestion Alternative 18/06/02

  28. How Pure is Pure?Testing Representativeness – The Method • Reduction of bias is very hard to test (chicken-and-egg problem) • We have tested enhancement of representativeness using the following test experiment • We have merged the 3 major databases providing information on individual fund return (MAR, TASS and HFR) • We have also added data on funds which do not report to any data base, that had been directly obtained from administrators • We have gathered monthly returns on a total of 7,422 hedge funds, including 2,317 funds that do not report their returns to the major data bases • We have formed equally-weighted portfolios for each style based on managers’ self-proclaimed styles and compute correlation with pure indexes • These portfolios are • Arguably biased • Undoubtly representative © Edhec 2002 Mesure de la Performance et des Risques de la Gestion Alternative 18/06/02

  29. How Pure is Pure?Testing Representativeness – The Results © Edhec 2002 Mesure de la Performance et des Risques de la Gestion Alternative 18/06/02

  30. Conclusion • Contribution • Document heterogeneity in competing hedge fund index providers • Attempt to provide remedies to the problem • Extensions • We have suggested that a database of pure style indexes be maintained at the EDHEC-MISYS Risk and Asset Management Research Center, and posted on a dedicated web site • The index construction methodology • Step 1: Use the first 3 years of monthly returns to calibrate the model. • Step 2: Perform a PCA analysis of competing indexes for each strategy on the data used for calibration purposes • Step 3: These portfolios are held for 3 months, their monthly returns are recorded, and the same process is repeated • Our results can easily be extended to traditional investment styles such as growth/value, small-cap/large-cap © Edhec 2002 Mesure de la Performance et des Risques de la Gestion Alternative 18/06/02

More Related