200 likes | 443 Views
Latin America in Hollywood Film. Lessons about our Neighbors. Angharad N. Valdivia Institute of Communications Research University of Illinois, CU. Media Studies Latin American and Caribbean Studies Latina/o Studies Gender and Women Studies Unit for Interpretive Criticism.
E N D
Latin America in Hollywood Film Lessons about our Neighbors
Angharad N. ValdiviaInstitute of Communications ResearchUniversity of Illinois, CU • Media Studies • Latin American and Caribbean Studies • Latina/o Studies • Gender and Women Studies • Unit for Interpretive Criticism
Analytical framework • Looking at the mainstream • Long history of representations • “Representation” over “image” • Differentiation or flattening? • Issues of gender, ethnicity, class, generation, and location
Representations • Re-present, not reflect/mirror • About content and signification • What is and not there • In relation and difference to each other • Does not tell about effect or interpretation though there are dominant themes
Practical strategies • Ask yourself, would that make sense/be funny/be sad if it were a US person/man • Elements of scene, including music, setting, dialogue, costumes, action • What is it quoting [to you as a member of this culture] • Relationality, explicit or implicit
Latin America • Close enough to be familiar • Far enough to be foreign/other • Close enough to be within US sphere of influence • Far enough to have its own politics
Latin America in film • Mostly a flattening of difference [anything south of the border melts into similar otherness] • Land of indigenous and brown • Land of political instability, disorder, revolution [banana republics]
Latin America [cont.] • Land of feminized otherness [to be conquered] • Less civilized, traditional in relation to our modernity • Source of raw materials, market for our products
Competing discourses • Similar to how rest of world is treated in film but with its own themes • Overlap with Latina/o Studies • The tropicalist discourse • The traditional Mexican discourse • Many times these conflated
Tropicalism • Assigning tropical traces to South of the Border peoples, locations, cultural forms • Combustible/fire, fuchsia/yellow palette, tropical background music [salsa, drums], people in heat and frantic movement • Traced to any LA location • Contemporary assimilationist
Traditional Mexican • Though Mexican inflected, traced to any LA location • Larger, poorer families • Different, brown and orange, color palette • Slow movement, near stasis • Ranchera, mariachi music
Gender • Tons of great work, Ana Lopez, Rosa Linda Fregoso and new book called “From Bananas to Buttocks” by Myra Mendible • Latin American women pose a double threat, sexual and racial • dark lady, spitfire, or self abnegated/virginal; in relation to Roman Catholicism
More on Gender • Also bleeding into U.S. Latina/o; in fact many can’t differentiate [Valdivia and Molina Guzman] • The whole region is gendered feminine in relation to the masculine power of U.S. and industrialized West • Not just women but men [machismo]
Race and ethnicity • Location of racial otherness • Usually the Brown race with implicit whiteness of the Spanish and dark brown of the indigenous • Sometimes acknowledged Blackness • Seldom including whiteness
Common themes • Romance, the class and ethnic twist • War, a land of disorder and tendencies toward authoritarianism • Economic disarray, rampant poverty and extremely uneven distribution of wealth • Production of raw materials; from bananas to cocaine • Myth of discovery • Our modern culture superior to their uncivilized nature
Themes in relation to our concerns • Good Neighbors during 40s • Cold war • Drug war • Terrorism and immigration
Resulting film themes • A place to stamp out communism and bring democracy • Original location of drug trade • Source of terrorism • Rampant poverty and political instability leads to illegal migration to U.S.
Contemporary gender • Women as part of drug trade • Women as bearers of illegal migration [they are the ones who reproduce] • Men ruthless machistas; masculinity [in relation to both drug trade and terrorism]
Implications • Critical reading leads to forms of global citizenship • Some themes can be applied to other global regions • More lessons about ourselves than them • Becomes part of a way we interpret the world and ourselves
More implications • Justifies US dominance in the hemisphere • Either when happy natives are tamed [because they want it] or unruly ones are tamed [that they don’t want the taming justifies it all the more] the end result is still our superior status to tame others • Since these films circulate globally, including in Latin America, they generate interpretive communities