170 likes | 368 Views
2. Agenda. IntroductionHydrology Study Results presented by Chris Dusza with CiviltecNext Steps. 3. Introduction. The consensus of the Ridgeline to Rio Summit = Drainage Master Plan is key short-term action Need to quantify the hazard before designing solutionDrainage Master Plan has two major components: 1. Hydrology = peak discharges; used to size improvements 2. Hydraulics = where the flood waters go, how deep and how fast; used to locate and design impr29991
E N D
1. 1 Drainage Master PlanSchultz Flood AreaDecember 7, 2010
2. 2 Agenda
Introduction
Hydrology Study Results presented by Chris Dusza with Civiltec
Next Steps
3. 3 Introduction The consensus of the Ridgeline to Rio Summit = Drainage Master Plan is key short-term action
Need to quantify the hazard before designing solution
Drainage Master Plan has two major components:
1. Hydrology = peak discharges; used to size
improvements
2. Hydraulics = where the flood waters go, how deep
and how fast; used to locate and design improvements
4. 4 Introduction Civiltec was contracted with in October to study the hydrology of the area at a cost of $31,000
Civiltec completed their analysis December 1
Chris Dusza, with Civiltec, will present the results of the hydrology study
5. 5 Hydrology Study Results
Presented by Chris Dusza with Civiltec Flood flows under this scenario are comparable to a 150 year storm pre-fire
Flood flows under this scenario are comparable to a 150 year storm pre-fire
6. 6 Hydrology Study Results HEC-1 Model - 3 Modeling Scenarios:
? Immediate Post Burn (2010)
? Short-Term Recovery (2015±)
? Long-Term Recovery (2030±)
Total Watershed Area ~54 square miles
? Includes Wupatki Trails, Timberline, Fernwood, and Doney Park
? 58 Sub Basins/Concentration Points
? 2 Point Precipitation Positional Values (Upper and Lower Watershed) – NOAA 14 Atlas
? 29 Soil Types - Coconino National Forest Terrestrial Ecosystem Survey
? 9 Land Use Classifications
7. 7 Hydrology Study Results
8. 8 Hydrology Study Results
9. 9 Hydrology Study Results
10. 10 Hydrology Study Results Modeling Methodology
? Rainfall Events - 2, 10, 25, 50, and 100 year events modeled
? Rainfall Losses – SCS Methodology Used (Curve Numbers, Lag Time)
? Curve Numbers estimated using
- Soil Data (HSG)
- SCS published tables (TR55)
- BAER Tools (Curve Number Supplement)
- Discussions with USFS
- Field Observations
? Routing – Normal Depth – Modified Puls Channel Routing
? Indirect Methods of Discharge Verification
11. 11 Hydrology Study Results
12. 12 Questions?
13. 13 Next Steps
Engineering Firms’ Recommendations:
Study results provided to six engineering firms – they are requested to provide input as to 1) the design storm(s) that should be considered for additional modeling, 2) the design standard, and 3) the potential recommendations regarding flood mitigation measures (structural and non-structural)
Additional modeling and studies based on comparison of different design storms
Model “typical” design storms for winter & summer to understand implications, if any
Cinder Lake Capacity Study - USGS
14. 14 Next Steps Input from Ridgeline to Rio Summit Participants and Other Partners and Agency Stakeholders
USFS, ADOT, NRCS, AZDEM/FEMA, ACE
Complete Preliminary Drainage Master Plan
Use engineering firm recommendations and extract the common potential solutions to create scenarios to consider
15. 15 Next Steps Public Participation
Contract Public Relations firm to support the process
Provide public education on hydrology study results
Conduct public participation process
Incorporate public feedback/input into final Drainage Master Plan
Consider/determine solutions for the area:
Timeframe, constructability, assumable risk, costs
Permits, NEPA, Archeological, utilities, rights-of-way
16. 16 Next Steps Fiscal Planning
Identify authorization and funding sources for potential solutions within the plan- FEMA, FHWA, NRCS, County, State
Finalize Drainage Master Plan
After considering public feedback, costs and funding, ROWs and other legal and technical considerations, finalize plan and the timeline
17. 17 Study is Available on the Flood Webpage www.coconino.az.gov/schultzfloodinformation.aspx
18. 18 Questions?