340 likes | 599 Views
FDA Review of NDA 21-304 Valganciclovir for the Treatment of CMV Retinitis in AIDS. Joseph Toerner, MD Medical Officer DAVDP. EFFICACY Induction therapy W V15376 Maintenance therapy Pharmacokinetic data. SAFETY Study W V15376 Study W V15705 Single-arm safety study Study PV16000
E N D
FDA Review of NDA 21-304Valganciclovir for the Treatment of CMV Retinitis in AIDS Joseph Toerner, MDMedical Officer DAVDP
EFFICACY Induction therapy W V15376 Maintenance therapy Pharmacokinetic data SAFETY Study W V15376 Study W V15705 Single-arm safety study Study PV16000 Prevention of CMV in SOT Valganciclovir NDA
Valganciclovir Development for CMV Retinitis • An adequately powered study for equivalence • 200 patients per arm • A feasible study in the current epidemiological climate • 75 patients per arm, under-powered to demonstrate equiv. • Ongoing phase 2 study (W V 15376) was expanded into a phase 3 trial • Academic consultants and FDA concur with the 4 week endpoint
Study WV15376 (Induction) Newly diagnosed CMV retinitis Open-label, 21 day induction therapy • IV ganciclovir 5 mg/kg BID • Oral valganciclovir 900 mg BID Followed by maintenance therapy • IV ganciclovir 5 mg/kg daily • Valganciclovir 900 mg daily All received valganciclovir after week 4
Study WV15376Primary Endpoint • Photographic assessment of CMV retinitis at week 4 compared to baseline • Standardized retinal photography • Used in previous registrational trials • Performed by the University of Wisconsin Fundus Photograph Reading Center
Study WV15376Primary Endpoint Analysis • Potential limitations: small sample size • Agreement was not reached on -25% as the lower limit of the 95% CI • The analysis of the primary endpoint was not pre-specified
Study WV15376FDA Analysis of Efficacy • FDA confirmation of the retinal photography • masked review: complete agreement with exception of one patient • Applicant’s primary analysis is based on evaluable subjects, which excluded deaths and lost to follow-ups. • FDA conducted sensitivity analyses • per protocol to intent to treat
WV15376Intent to Treat Analysis *Asymptotic approximation with continuity adjustment
WV15376: FDA Efficacy Analyses *Asymptotic approximation with continuity adjustment
Summary of Endpoint Evaluation *Asymptotic approximation with continuity adjustment
Are Disproportionate Dropouts Failures of Induction? • Disproportionate dropouts persisted after accounting for week 4 progressors or dropouts • Evaluation of CMV progression during weeks 4 and 12 by retinal photography • Evaluation of reasons for discontinuation • Ophthalmologist clinical diagnosis examined • On-study treatment decisions, photographic scoring not provided in real-time
Are Disproportionate Dropouts Failures of Induction? • Only 1 had photographic evidence of CMV progression between weeks 4 and 12 • Reasons for discontinuation: 4 deaths, 3 voluntary withdrawals, 2 requested GCV implant • Treating ophthalmologists more likely to classify a patients in Valgan as CMV progressors regardless of the photographic determination • Disproportionate dropouts driven by open-label study design
Study WV15376Treatment of Zone 1 Retinitis Previous registrational trials have excluded patients with Zone 1 Similar outcomes to overall population
Study WV15376 Impact of Protease Inhibitors • Few changed HAART during induction • Valganciclovir: 4 patients IV ganciclovir: 5 patients • Majority changed HAART at week 4 visit • Time to CMV retinitis progression much longer in comparison to historical studies
Summary of FDA Analysis of Efficacy • Proportion with CMV progression is similar • Maximum lower bound of 95% CI is approximately -13% • Results of primary endpoint confirmed by FDA masked review of the retinal photographs • Visual acuity scores similar
Valganciclovir Safety WV15376: N = 158 Open label valganciclovir after week 4 WV15705: N = 212 Single-arm, open-label valganciclovir for maintenance therapy PV16000: N = 121 Prevention of CMV disease in SOT Oral GCV vs. Valgan, still masked
Study WV15376Deaths • 4 weeks: • 3 deaths, 2 in IV GCV, 1 in Valgan • 12 weeks: • 10 deaths, 5 in each arm • primarily due to underlying AIDS • One year: • 28 deaths, 18 in IV GCV, 10 in Valgan
Studies WV15376 WV15705Adverse Events Gastrointestinal Diarrhea 41% Nausea/vomiting 30% Abdominal pain 15% Hematologic Neutropenia/anemia 27% Other Fever 31% Candidiasis 24% Rash 22% Headache 22% Retinal Detachment 15% Abnormal LFT’s 9%
PV16000: CMV Prevention Oral Ganciclovir vs. Valganciclovir Total number of patients enrolled: N=121 Patients completed the 100 day course: N=39 Masked data, 41 patients reported 60 SAE’s Hematologic 4% Gastrointestinal 3% Infectious complications 6% Increased creatinine 3% Graft rejection 4%
Safety Conclusions Patients completing at least 6 months of therapy: N=293 Hematologic and Gastrointestinal Adverse Events predominate Similar adverse event profile to ganciclovir
Valganciclovir Review Team Acknowledgements Medical Officer Team Leader Therese Cvetkovich, M.D. Biometrics Andrei Breazna, Ph.D. Greg Soon, Ph.D. Medical Officer, DAAODP William Boyd, M.D. Biopharmaceutics Robert Kumi, Ph.D. Kellie Reynolds, Pharm.D.