2.57k likes | 3.11k Views
The Limited Liability Partnership Act, 2008. 28.2.2009. Choosing the type of organisation structure for SMEs is a challenge Selection of orgnisation structure is influenced by many factors Type of organisation structure determines personal liability of owners
E N D
Choosing the type of organisation structure for SMEs is a challenge • Selection of orgnisation structure is influenced by many factors • Type of organisation structure determines personal liability of owners • The owners of SMEs are personally liable for business failure occurring in the normal course unless operating as a Limited Liability Company • Large number of SMEs operate as Partnerships for operational felxibility • SMEs registered as private companies are subject to rigours of compliance under the Companies Act, 1956 Introduction 28.2.2009
There has been long felt need for a simple legislation for SMEs to carry on • business as a body corporate with limited liability obligation • The LLP Act 2008 has addressed this need • A Snapshot of characteristic features of Partnership Firm, LLP, Private Company and Public Company are given in the following tables Introduction 28.2.2009
Introduction 28.2.2009
Introduction 28.2.2009
Introduction 28.2.2009
Introduction 28.2.2009
Introduction 28.2.2009
Introduction 28.2.2009
Introduction 28.2.2009
Introduction 28.2.2009
Introduction 28.2.2009
Introduction 28.2.2009
Introduction 28.2.2009
Introduction 28.2.2009
Introduction 28.2.2009
Introduction 28.2.2009
Introduction 28.2.2009
Introduction 28.2.2009
Introduction 28.2.2009
Introduction 28.2.2009
Introduction 28.2.2009
Introduction 28.2.2009
The concept of LLP was first introduced informally in Italy in the 7th Century • France was the first country to enact LLP legislation in the year 1673 • In UK the LLP Act was passed in the year 1867.It was replaced in the year 1907 • and a comprehensive LLP legislation was passed with a new Act in the year 2000 • In Singapore the concept of LLP is very recent and LLP Act was passed on 25th January 2005 • Impetus for enacting LLP Act in India was due to pressure from WTO for opening up of multi-disciplinary professional services to the multinational professional firms History 28.2.2009
CG first brought out a Concept Paper on LLP and placed it in the public domain • in November 2005 for comments and suggestions • The LLP Bill 2006 was introduced in Rajyasabha on 15th December 2006 and • was referred to Standing Committee on Finance. • Based on the recommendations the Bill was withdrawn for further improvements • A new LLP Bill 2008 was introduced by the CG in the year 2007 with over 35 • major changes and insertion of 8 new sections and other modifications • Finally, the LLP Bill 2008 has culminated into ‘The Limited Liability Partnership • Act, 2008’ with gazette notification on 9th January 2009 • The LLP Act 2008 is divided into 14 Chapters containing 81 Sections and Four • Schedules • The concept Rules numbering 40 have been put on public domain for comments History 28.2.2009
Chapter I titled “Preliminary” • Contains 2 Sections • Section 1: Describes the title, jurisdiction and effective date of the Act • Section 2: Contains definitions of terms used in the Act Chapter I 28.2.2009
Chapter II titled “Nature of Limited Liability Partnership” • Contains 8 Sections • Section 3: LLP is a separate legal entity and it is a body corporate • Section 4: Partnership Act 1932 is not applicable to LLPs except as provided • Section 5: Who can and who cannot be partners of an LLP • Section 6: Min. no. of Partners and Personal Liability if the number falls below 2 • Section 7: Designated Partners – Requirements for appointment etc • Section 8: Responsibilities and Obligations of Designated Partners Chapter II 28.2.2009
Chapter II titled “Nature of Limited Liability Partnership” • contd…. • Section 9 : Filling up of vacancy in Designated Partners and consequences of • failure • Section 10: Penalty for contravention of provisions of Section 7 (1), (4), (5), • Section 8 and Section 9 Chapter II 28.2.2009
Chapter III titled “Incorporation of LLP and Matters Incidental thereto” • Contains 11 Sections • Section 11: Incorporation of LLP, procedure for incorporation and penalty • Section 12: Registration of LLP by Registrar and Certificate of Incorporation • Section 13: Registered Office and other office of LLP and changes thereof • Section 14: Effect of Registration and Powers of LLP • Section 15: Use of words Limited Liability Partnership or acronym ‘LLP’ as last • words in the name • Section 16: Application for approval and reservation of name of LLP • Section 17: CG’s power to direct change of name by a LLP already registered Chapter III 28.2.2009
Chapter III titled “Incorporation of LLP and Matters Incidental thereto” • contd…. • Section 18: Application by a Company, LLP or Entity to Registrar for directing • change of name of LLP registered with similar name • Section 19: Change of name by LLP on own volition • Section 20: Penalty for misuse of words LLP in the name • Section 21: Publishing of name, address and registered number in invoices etc. Chapter III 28.2.2009
Chapter IV titled “Partners and their Relations” • Contains 4 Sections • Section 22:How to become partners of a LLP • Section 23:Mutual Rights & Duties of Partners inter-se partners and LLP and its • partners etc. • Section 24:Cessation/Resignation of a partner • Section 25:Partner to report change in name and address to LLP etc. Chapter IV 28.2.2009
Chapter V titled “Extent and Limitation of Liability of LLP and Partners” • Contains 6 Sections • Section 26: Partner is an Agent of LLP and not of other partners • Section 27: Liability of LLP when and how much • Section 28: Partner’s liabilities and extent of liability • Section 29: Person holding out to be a partner shall be liable to creditors • Section 30: Unlimited liability of partners and LLP under certain circumstances • Section 31: Whistle Blowing benefits to a partner and an employee Chapter V 28.2.2009
Chapter VI titled “Contributions” • Contains 2 Sections • Section 32: Contributions by partners - by way of money, tangible and • intangible assets etc. • Section 33: Obligation of partners to contribute money or property or other • benefit shall be as per LLP Agreement Chapter VI 28.2.2009
Chapter VII titled “Financial Disclosures” • Contains 8 Sections • Section 34: Maintenance of Books, preparation and filing of Statement of • Account and Solvency with the Registrar • Section 35: LLP to file Annual Return with the Registrar • Section 36: Public Inspection of documents filed by LLP with the Registrar • Section 37: Penalty for false return, statement or document required under the • Act • Section 38: Registrar right to call for information, statement, document etc Chapter VII 28.2.2009
Chapter VII titled “Financial Disclosures” • contd…. • Section 39: Compounding of Offence committed - where punishable with fine • Section 40: Registrar to destroy documents filed in accordance with Rules • Section 41: Registrar may require filing of corrected or amended document etc. Chapter VII 28.2.2009
Chapter VIII titled “Assignment and Transfer of Partnership Rights” • Contains 1 Section • Section 42: A Partner can transfer his rights to share in profits or receive • contributions and still continue to be a partner in a LLP etc. Chapter VIII 28.2.2009
Chapter IX titled “Investigation” • Contains 12 Sections • Section 43: CG to appoint Inspectors under certain circumstances • Section 44: Partners application for ordering inspection by Tribunal should be • supported by evidence and deposit of security amount • Section 45: No Firm, Body Corporate or other Association can be appointed as • an Inspector • Section 46: Inspector can inspect the affairs of an associated entity also • Section 47: Duty of Designated Partners or partners to produce documents Chapter IX 28.2.2009
Chapter IX titled “Investigation” • contd…. • Section 48: Inspector to approach First Class Magistrate or Judicial Magistrate • for order for confiscation of records or documents • Section 49: Inspector to make interim if required by CG and also make final • report to the CG • Section 50: CG may prosecute a person in relation to LLP or any other entity • whose affairs are investigated found to be guilty after conducting • inspection • Section 51: If it is that it is expedient to wind up as per the Order, the LLP shall • be wound up by order of Tribunal Chapter IX 28.2.2009
Chapter IX titled “Investigation” • contd…. • Section 52: CG may bring proceedings for recovery of damages or property • Section 53: Initial expenses of investigation will be borne by CG but upon • conviction the person convicted shall bear the expenses • Section 54: The Inspectors Report will be will be admissible as evidence in any • legal proceeding Chapter IX 28.2.2009
Chapter X titled “Conversion into Limited Liability Partnership” • Contains 4 Sections • Section 55: A Partnership Firm may convert itself into LLP • Section 56: A private company may convert itself into LLP • Section 57: An unlisted public company may convert itself into LLP • Section 58: Registration of LLP on conversion and duty of Partnership • Firm/Private Company/Unlisted Company to intimate the Registrar • of Firms/Companies etc. Chapter X 28.2.2009
Chapter XI titled “Foreign LLPs” Contains 1 Section Section 59: Central Government’s power to formulate rules applicable to foreign LLPs establishing place of business in India Chapter XI 28.2.2009
Chapter XII titled “Compromise, Arrangement or Reconstruction (CAR) of LLPs” • Contains 3 Sections • Section 60: Procedure for C or A and Order of Tribunal for C or A • Section 61: Tribunal shall have power to supervise carrying out of C or A • Section 62: Tribunal may approve C or A proposal and order the scheme for R • or amalgamation of 2 or more LLPs Chapter XII 28.2.2009
Chapter XIII titled “Winding Up and Dissolution” • Contains 3 Sections • Section 63: Voluntary Winding up and/or through Order of the Tribunal • Section 64: Circumstances under which Tribunal may order winding up • Section 65: CG may make rules in relation to winding up of LLPs Chapter XIII 28.2.2009
Chapter XIV titled “Miscellaneous” • Contains 16 Sections • Section 66: A partner may lend money or transact business with LLP • Section 67: CG’s power to notify that provisions of Companies Act, 1956 may • apply with or without modifications to LLPs • Section 68: Filing of documents in Electronic Form, copy of any document or • extract of any document filed with Registrar shall be admissible • as evidence etc. • Section 69: Document required to be filed with Registrar if not filed within due • date can be filed within 300 days on payment of additional fees and • beyond 300 days also • Section 70: Imprisonment of partner or designated partner for 2nd and • subsequent offences and levy of fine upto twice the amount • prescribed Chapter XIV 28.2.2009
Chapter XIV titled “Miscellaneous” • contd…. • Section 71: Provisions of this Act shall be in addition and not in derogation of • provisions of any other law • Section 72: Tribunal may exercise such powers conferred on it by this Act or any • other Law in force • Section 73: Failing to comply with order of the Tribunal shall attract imprisonment • upto 6 months and shall also be liable to fine of not less than • Rs.50,000/- • Section 74: If the Act is silent on fines, the person can be punishable with fine • with Min. of Rs.5,000/- and Max. of Rs.50/- per day of default (subject • to Maximum amount of Rs.5,00,000/-) Chapter XIV 28.2.2009
Chapter XIV titled “Miscellaneous” • contd…. • Section 75: Registrar’s power strike off name of LLP if LLP is not carrying • on business • Section 76: Punishment of Partners/Designated Partners/LLP for Offences • committed • Section 77: Jurisdiction of Courts • Section 78: CG’s power to alter the provisions of Schedules to the Act • Section 79: CG’s power to make Rules for carrying out provisions of this Act Chapter XIV 28.2.2009
Chapter XIV titled “Miscellaneous” • contd…. • Section 80: CG’s power to make provisions to remove difficulties but the power • cannot be exercised after 2 years from the date of commencement of • the Act • Section 81: Transitionary provisions until Tribunal is constituted under Companies • Act, 1956 Chapter XIV 28.2.2009
Implications under Stamp Duty • What should be stamp duty for LLP Agreement? • LLP Agreement attracts stamp duty as per State Stamp Act. • For clarity on stamp duty payable for LLP Agreement State Stamp Act needs • amendment • Implications under Income Tax Act 1961 • Whether capital gains tax under Section 45 is attracted on conversion of Partnership Firm/Private Company/Unlisted Public Company into LLP? • On conversion of Partnership firm/private company/unlisted public company • into LLP as per Second/Third/Fourth Schedule all the assets etc. of the firm • shall be transferred toandvest in the LLP • The word ‘convert’ in relation to firm/private company/unlisted public company • means transfer of property • The above situation is different from that of registration of a partnership firm as • a company under part IX of the Companies Act, 1956. Issues under a few important Enactments 28.2.2009
Under Part IX property belonging to or vested in a Registered Partnership Firms • shall on registration under Part IX pass toandvest in the company incorporated • under the Companies Act, 1956. As per Andhra High Court, on such vesting there • is no capital gains tax on the partnership firm. • Whether benefits under Section 72A of the Income Tax Act is available to the Amalgamated LLP in case of Amalgamation of LLPs ? • As per Section 72A of the Income Tax Act carry forward losses and unabsorbed • depreciation of Amalgamating Company is allowed in the hands of Amalgamated • Company subject to certain conditions stipulated therein. • Unless Section 72A is amended to include LLPs also, the benefits will not be • available to LLPs in case of Amalgamation. • Implication under Industrial Policy and FEMA regulations for FDI in a LLP Whether FDI is permitted into a LLP ? • A foreign LLP or a foreign Company can become a Partner of a Indian LLP. The • existing Industrial Policy and FEMA need amendment for making contributions Issues under a few important Enactments 28.2.2009
Cost Advantage of LLP over a company • Maximum registration fee in the case of a LLP is Rs.5,000/- • Maximum registration fee for a company having share capital is Rs.2 Crores Registration Fees 28.2.2009