40 likes | 53 Views
Gain insights from policy and project-level research to inform national-level modeling. Explore technical issues, such as additionality, duration, and transaction costs, that determine the sequestration achievable nationally. Discover economic and biophysical potential, market failures, and barriers.
E N D
Panel Overview:Insights from Policy & Project-Level Research Ken Andrasko U.S. Environmental Protection Agency Forestry & Agriculture Greenhouse Gas Modeling Forum 2 Shepardstown, WV, 10/8-11/02
How Can Policy & Project-Level Analysis Inform National-Level Modeling? • Much of policy debate focused on sinks project-level technical issues: internationally & domestically. • Technical issues important at national level, especially in voluntary programs: • baseline setting, additionality, leakage, duration of GHG benefits, monitoring. • National programs essentially scale-up farm- or landowner-level activities. • Bundling of heterogeneous land parcels & transaction costs: • determine how much of biophysical potential is economic & can be mobilized.
Technical Issues like Additionality, Duration, Transaction Costs of Bundling Will Determine Sequestration Achievable Nationally Economic Potential Biophysical Potential Market or Achievable Potential ?? ?? Cost of carbon ($/t C) Market Failures & Barriers: Examples: - Bundling costs - Monitoring costs - Low payments/acre - Absence of markets Issues: Examples - Baseline chosen - GHG leakage - Duration of benefits Carbon sequestered or emissions avoided (t C) Source: derived from Sathaye, Makundi, Andrasko et al, 2001
Overview of Panel • 2 talks: soil C measurement & monitoring costs and methods: Sian Mooney & Tris West • Find measurement costs small, & degree of heterogeneity important. • Suggest C management response curves. • Find duration of GHG benefits varies by practice and GHG source or pool, & is critical to quantifying net GHG benefits. • Hall & Lempriere identify issues re developing offset trading market in Canada. • Murray: national dataset (NRI) vs econometric model for setting afforestation baseline in case study in Mississippi bottomlands. • Discussant: John Horowitz, U of MD.