220 likes | 257 Views
Smallholder production and markets of bolaina blanca ( Guazuma crinita ) in Ucayali, Peru. Jonathan P. Cornelius, L. Julio Ugarte-Guerra World Agroforestry Centre (ICRAF) ) Presented at Smallholder Timber Workshop, ICRAF, Nairobi, Kenya, December 2004. The Ucayali Region, Peru. Pucallpa.
E N D
Smallholder production and markets of bolaina blanca (Guazuma crinita) in Ucayali, Peru Jonathan P. Cornelius, L. Julio Ugarte-Guerra World Agroforestry Centre (ICRAF)) Presented at Smallholder Timber Workshop, ICRAF, Nairobi, Kenya, December 2004
The Ucayali Region, Peru Pucallpa
Bolaina supply chain in Pucallpa Smallholders’ secondary forest, fallow $90 ($0.50 stem-1) 180 stems ha-1 Source: CIFOR/CATIE, 1998 Middlemen (extrctn, freight) $405 ($0.45 log-1) 5-6 logs stem-1 Sawmill / wood merchant 8 pieces sawntimber log-1 (2.5mx10cmx1.7cm) Private consumers in Pucallpa Industry in Pucallpa (lolly-sticks, fruit packaging, matches, etc $2,160 ($0.3 piece-1)
….now available in Lima • Door frames, 3 pieces, Peruvian S/. 39.90 (USD 12.00)
Bolaina plantations • Fast growth (on the right site) (Hdom=13.7m, 24 months) • FONDEBOSQUE is projecting large-scale production and sale of bolaina seedlings in 2005 • Incipient planting by wealthier farmers • Unrealistic projections in some quarters
A standing tree of bolaina sells for around $0.50 • From a standing tree, around 40 pieces can be sawn • Finished sawnwood sells for around $50/m3 (about 200 pieces) • 40 pieces are worth around $10
Is plantation production of bolaina a viable option for smallholder farmers? • If so, how?
Financial analyses • 4 scenarios • Costs and revenues estimated from published and unpublished sources1 • 400 final crop trees 1 CIFOR / CATIE, 1998. Curso - taller sobre metodologías de investigación en bosques secundarios.González, L.A. 2003. Evaluación técnico-económica de plantaciones de bolaina blanca en zonas inundables del Rio Aguaytía. B.Sc. Thesis, UNALM, Lima.Ugarte-Guerra, L.J. Unpublished data
Option 1 • Block plantation at 3m x 3m • Weeding in first two years • Thinning after three years, to final crop density of 400 trees ha-1 • Standing sale at 6 years of age
Cash income at sale of $182 NDR@10%:-$646 ha-1
Food for thought for potential bolaina planters… • A bolaina seedling costs around $0.30 • A six year old standing tree sells for around $0.50
Bolaina supply chain in Pucallpa Smallholders’ secondary forest, fallow $90 ($0.50 stem-1) 180 stems ha-1 Middlemen (extrctn, frght) $405 ($0.45 log-1) 5-6 logs stem-1 Sawmill / wood merchant 8 pieces sawntimber log-1 (2.5mx10cmx1.7cm) Private consumers in Pucallpa Industry in Pucallpa (lolly-sticks, fruit packaging, matches, etc $2,200 ($0.3 piece-1)
Option 2 • Farmer fells, crosscuts trees himself • Pays for transport of 2.5m logs to river port • Average of five 2.5m logs tree-1 • Logs sold at $0.30 (<20cm) or $0.45 (>20cm)
Cash income at sale of $770 NDR@10%:-$686 ha-1
Option 3 • Farmer pays for sawmill service, producing average of 8.6 unfinished pieces (2.5m x 10cm x 1.7cm) per log • Pays for transport to Pucallpa • Sells pieces at $0.15 each
Cash income at sale of $2600 NDR @ 10%:-$113.52 ha-1,IRR 6.4%
Option 4 • Lengthen rotation to 9 years • Average of 7 logs tree-1, and 12.9pieces log-1
Cash income at sale of $5500 NDR @ 10%:$385 ha-1,IRR=15.8%
Added value - easier said than done Needs: • Stronger organization • Equitable alliances with industry