110 likes | 311 Views
Ancillary tests used for Brain Death Diagnosis in Buenos Aires City. Previgliano I, Fioretti S, Lara J, Balbuena V, Baqué MC Buenos Aires Trasplant Institute – GCBA Neurocritical Care and Organ and Tissue Procurement for Trasplantation Management Unit – Hospital J. A. Fernández. Background.
E N D
Ancillary tests used for Brain Death Diagnosis in Buenos Aires City Previgliano I, Fioretti S, Lara J, Balbuena V, Baqué MC Buenos Aires Trasplant Institute – GCBA Neurocritical Care and Organ and Tissue Procurement for Trasplantation Management Unit – Hospital J. A. Fernández
Background • Argentinean Organ Donation Law establishes several methods for brain death diagnosis • The protocol includes clinical examination, apnea test (AT) and one or more ancillary tests: • Electroencephalography (EEG) • Multimodality evoked potentials (somatosensory (EPSS), auditory (EPA), visual (EPV)) • Transcranial doppler (TCD) • Cerebral angiography (CA) • Radioisotopic angiography (RA) • Multislice computed tomography angiography with cerebral perfusion (CTA).
Aim • The aim of the study is to evaluate the ratio of use of each ancillary test in Brain Death Diagnosis by the procuration team
Material and method • Study design: Prospective collected database analysis. • Inclusion criteria: Patients with brain death diagnosis from 01/01/10 to 31/12/10. • Data collected: AT, EEG, DTC, EPSS, EPA, EPV, TCD, CA, RA, CTA, presence of depressor drugs and decompress craniectomy.
Results • 80 patients were brain death diagnosed • Neither of them was submitted to Cerebral Angiography, Radiosotopic Angiography or Computed Tomography Angiography • Apnea test was performed in 61 patients (76%)
Results • EEG in 72 (90%) • TCD in 17 (21%) • EPA in 11 (14%) • EPSS in 5 (6%) • EPV in 1 (1%)
Results • 12 patients receiving depressor drugs were diagnosed by means of: • TCD 10 (83%), only 4 (33%) as single method • EEG 8 (67%), always associated to another method • EPA 4 (33%), always associated to another method • EPSS 1 (1%), associated to EEG
Results • Six patients submitted to decompress craniectomy were diagnosed by means of: • AT (100%) • EEG (83%) • TCD (40%).
Results • In 16 patients in which apnea test could not be performed, diagnosis was made by means of: • TCD in 10 (62%) • EP in 6 (38%) • EEG was associated to TCD in 5 patients and to EP in 6
Conclusions • Our research demonstrates that neurologists are more confident to traditional brain death approach (AT plus EEG) than to modern tools • Combination of AT and EEG was the preferred combination in 63% of cases • DTC was the preferred ancillary test when apnea test couldn’t be performed • EP’s were never used alone as diagnostic criteria • CA, RA and CTA weren’t used as ancillary tests
Questions? Questions? Instituto de Trasplante de Buenos Aires