390 likes | 751 Views
Fatigue and Cancer Treatment: A Model for the Study of Fatigue. Charles S. Cleeland, PhD Chair, Department of Symptom Research The University of Texas M. D. Anderson Cancer Center. Main Points.
E N D
Fatigue and Cancer Treatment:A Model for the Study of Fatigue Charles S. Cleeland, PhD Chair, Department of Symptom Research The University of Texas M. D. Anderson Cancer Center
Main Points • Cancer treatment is very often associated with large increases in fatigue – related to the toxicity of treatment • The severity of fatigue can be measured by self-report (patient-reported outcomes) • Treatment-related fatigue generally follows a similar trajectory, dependent on type of treatment • This gives us a “window” or model to look at what produces fatigue and what may prevent or treat it
Definition of CRF (One of Many) • Cancer-related fatigue is an unusual, persistent, subjective sense of tiredness related to cancer or cancer treatment that interferes with usual functioning – NCCN Fatigue Guidelines Committee, 2000
Symptoms at End of Life Ng & von Gunten, J Pain Symptom Manage, 1998 • 100 consecutive hospice admissions • Fatigue 81% • Anorexia 70% • Dyspnea 61% • Cough 58% • Pain 49% • Depression 37%
Overview of Treatment-Related Symptoms • With more than 10 million cancer patients and cancer survivors, residual symptoms of both disease and treatment represent a significant and under-recognized public-health burden • Cancer is increasingly becoming a “chronic” disease, amplifying the issue of symptom burden • Until recently, most symptom treatment has been empiric rather than mechanistic, and symptom prevention is virtually unexplored • New developments in immunomodulation present opportunities for reducing or even preventing disease-related and treatment-related symptoms
The Impact • National policy recommendations for increased symptom research (NCI State of Science, 2003) • More knowledgeable consumers asking for symptom control • Patients who terminate (or are ineligible for) treatment because of symptoms/toxicities • Patients and survivors with symptoms that persist (pain, fatigue, impaired cognitive function) • Increase in potential symptom-focused therapies (nonspecific anti-inflammatory agents, antidepressants, immunomodulators)
Common Long-Term Disease-Related and Treatment-Related Symptoms • Neuropathy – pain and loss of fine motor coordination, difficulty with walking • Other pain syndromes (e.g., bone pain) • Fatigue – most patients during treatment and a significant percentage of cancer survivors • Cognitive deficits – Loss of “executive function” and some types of memory, without IQ loss • Persistent sleep disturbance, reflected primarily in sleep quality
Why Study Treatment-Related Symptoms? • Several biologic mechanisms, including Inflammatory cytokines, are hypothesized to be responsible for both disease-related and treatment-related symptoms • The time course of treatment-related symptoms is more predictable, and has a beginning time point, allowing for more precise linkage • Knowledge concerning the mechanisms of treatment-related symptoms may provide information about these symptoms in other conditions as well (such as fatigue in aging)
Brief Fatigue Inventory (Interference) 7. Circle the number that describes how, during the past 24 hours, fatigue has interfered with your: A. General activity 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 Does not Completely Interfere Interferes
Means (SDs) for Fatigue Outcome Measures Across Performance Status Category * Significantly different at each level of ECOG performance status (p<0.001)
Most Common Severe Symptoms During Treatment in M. D. Anderson Outpatients (N=527)7 or greater on M. D. Anderson Symptom Inventory 0–10 scale Cleeland et al, Cancer, 2000)
How Symptom Clusters During Treatment Cleeland et al, Cancer, 2000 Nausea Vomiting Bleeding Diarrhea Mouth sores Shortness of breath Cough Constipation Bloated Remembering Attention Distress Worrying Sad Nervous Irritable Lack of appetite Sick Fatigue Weak Not able to get things done Drowsy Pain Disturbed sleep Dry mouth Numbness/tingling
Cytokine Treatment Melanoma Patients: Symptom Severity over One Cycle
Mean Symptom Scores (0-10 scale) Time Postoperative Studies: Symptom Severity
Symptom Patterns with Aggressive Cancer TherapiesFatigue,Pain,Sleep,Distress,Shortness of Breath NSCLC Thoracic Surgery Weeks NSCLC Chemo-radiation Days AML/MDS Allo-HSCT Days GI Chemo-radiation Days
Example: Fatigue Severity Across Time ChemoXRT (n=48) • Repeated Measures • Benefits • Ease of data gathering • No need keep track of patients across a treatment regiment • High volume of patient data in a limited amount of time • Drawbacks • Limited in scope • Lose impact of symptom between assessments • Partial picture of symptom expression XRT only (n=46) 7 6 5 Fatigue Severity 4 3 2 Wilkes Lambda = .71 F(1,93)=.285, p=.845 1 0 0 1 2 3 4 5 End 7 8 9 10 of Tx Time Point Burkett, et al., 2007, unpublished data.
ChemoXRT (n=48) XRTOnly (n=46) Fatigue Area Under the Curve (AUC): Effectively Combining Severity and Time • Longitudinal Data • Frequent assessment is invaluable • Enables tracking symptoms across treatment regimens • Provides picture of symptom change as the treatment and recovery progresses • Area Under the Curve • Single value representing time and symptom severity • Compare groups using standard statistical methods • Compensates for missing data 60 50 40 30 Average Fatigue AUC 20 t (93)=6.41, p = .04 * 10 0 Week 7 Week 8 Week 9 Week 2 Week 3 Week 4 Week 5 Baseline Week 10 End of Tx Timepoint Burkett, et al., 2007, unpublished data.
Ongoing CRF Studies: www.clinicaltrials.gov • ATP • American Gingseng • Co-enzyme Q10 • Etanercept • Levocarnitine • Modafinil • Methyphenidate • Zoloft
Sickness Behavior: An Animal Model for Cancer-Related Symptoms? • Physiological components – fever, pain, wasting, increased HPA, autonomic activity • Behavioral components – somnolence, hyperalgesia, impaired learning, and decreased social interaction, exploration, and eating • Inflammatory cytokines/chemokines and neurotransmitters may play central mechanistic role
Examples: Cancer- and Treatment-Related Symptoms Associated with Inflammation • Anorexia/Cachexia: Elevated serum IL-6, TNF-a is confirmed to affect animals; TNF-a is important but not exclusively responsible for anorexic effects of tumor • Fatigue: IL-6mAb blocks IL-6 activity in Castleman disease; IL-6 is high in fatigued breast cancer survivors • Pain: IL-1b, IL-6 and TNF-a are increased in neuropathic pain, hyperalgesia, and extreme sensitivity to pain • Cognitive Dysfunction: Elevated IL-6 is associated with cognitive deficits in AML/MDS and LMD patients • Sleep: IL-6, TNF-a are increased in sleep deprivation • Paraneoplastic syndrome in SCLC or metastatic RCC: IL-6–related fever, fatigue, weight loss
Serum IL-6 Fluctuates with Symptom Peak:100 days of Allo-BMT in AML/MDS Patients Wang et al, Cancer, in press.
Random Effects Modeling: Serum Cytokines Predicted Symptom Changes from Baseline to Peak Wang et al, Cancer, in press. Dependent variable is a symptom component score. Age, gender, race, disease status, infusion cell service, conditioning regimen, and infusion dose of CD34+ cells were adjusted in all models.
Random Effects Modeling: Association of Changes Symptom Severity and Cytokines for 7 weeks Concurrent CXRT (N=60) Wang et al, unpublished data. Controlled for age, gender, race, recurrent, chemo, total XRT dose, and XRT technique (3DCRT or IMRT).
Random Effects Modeling: Association of Symptom Severity and Cytokines from Baseline to 10 weeks from Start of Concurrent CXRT Wang et al, unpublished data.
Etanercept and Clinical Outcomes, Fatigue, and Depression in Psoriasis: Double-blind Placebo-controlled Randomized Phase III Trial Tyring s et al, Lancet, 2006. • With etanercept, a soluble TNF-α receptor, improvements in fatigue were correlated with decreasing joint pain; improvements in depression were less correlated with objective measures of skin clearance or joint pain. • Etanercept treatment might relieve fatigue and symptoms of depression associated with this chronic disease.
Future Research Directions • Additional longitudinal studies of biology of fatigue development and risk for fatigue (genetics) in response to cancer treatment • More testing of interventions that modify pathways for inflammation (NF-kB, cytokine inhibition • Neuroimaging of treatment-based fatigue • Animal models of fatigue for preclinical investigation
Surgery Radiation and/or to remove tumor chemotherapy Symptom severity * differential between patients = points of interest Results of interdisciplinary efforts lead to new hypotheses to be tested first in animals Symptom Research Strategy Clinical Oncology Tested interventions move into community DISCIPLINES * Clinical Trials Interventions Phase I and II clinical trials * * Protective measures Pre-Surgery TREATMENT TRAJECTORY Symptom Research MDASI MDASI MDASI MDASI Protein Measurement Cytokines Cytokines Cytokines Cytokines Genomics DNA & RNA RNA RNA RNA RNA Neurosensory Sensory testing Sensory testing Biostatistics Longitudinal modeling Neuroimaging fMRI and PET fMRI and PET Neurocognitive Cognitive testing Cognitive testing Emotion Mood assessment Mood assessment Animal Behavior Models of cancer and cancer treatment to test compounds and inform clinical trials
Conclusions • Increased fatigue is endemic in cancer, and most prominent reported symptom before death • Fatigue is conceptually complex, but patient report of tiredness/fatigue represents the state • Treatment-related fatigue often follows a similar trajectory, and presents a model for understanding the biology of fatigue • Several avenues of investigation of fatigue are now available, and could be applied to this model
Examples: Cancer- and Treatment-Related Symptoms Associated with Inflammation • Anorexia/Cachexia: Elevated serum IL-6, TNF-a is confirmed to affect animals; TNF-a is important but not exclusively responsible for anorexic effects of tumor • Fatigue: IL-6mAb blocks IL-6 activity in Castleman disease; IL-6 is high in fatigued breast cancer survivors • Pain: IL-1b, IL-6 and TNF-a are increased in neuropathic pain, hyperalgesia, and extreme sensitivity to pain • Cognitive Dysfunction: Elevated IL-6 is associated with cognitive deficits in AML/MDS and LMD patients • Sleep: IL-6, TNF-a are increased in sleep deprivation • Paraneoplastic syndrome in SCLC or metastatic RCC: IL-6–related fever, fatigue, weight loss