160 likes | 272 Views
Functional Data Analysis of Continuous Judgments in Music Cognition. Gesture in Musical Performance. What role do a musician’s gestures play in a performance? Do they convey emotion? Do gestures convey the same things as does the music? Popular study in field of music psychology
E N D
Functional Data Analysis of Continuous Judgments in Music Cognition
Gesture in Musical Performance • What role do a musician’s gestures play in a performance? • Do they convey emotion? • Do gestures convey the same things as does the music? • Popular study in field of music psychology • Data on listener’s emotions are collected in real-time • With a real-time Optotrak slider, which • Measures location of the slider 10 times per second. Continuous Judgments of Music
The Tension & Gesture Experiment • Musical performance recorded on video • Stravinsky’s 2nd Piece for Solo Clarinet • 30 musically-trained participants either • Watched & Listened to the recording (Natural) • Watched the silent recording (Video Only), or • Listened to the recording (Audio Only). • And reported their continuous “level of tension [emotion]”.
The Data • Vectors of length 800 • 10 “Audio Only,” 10 “Video Only,” 10 “Audio + Video” • Scaled to [0,1] interval
The Functional Objects • 150 order 6 B-splines, using FDA software in Matlab. • Then smoothed.
Functional Principal Components Analysis • 25 s – 65 s: crucial separation • Effect of amplification / attenuation: how strong are the changes of emotion?
Functional Linear Model Emotion(t) = µ(t) + β0(t){AudRemoved} + β1(t){VidRemoved} + ε(t)
Functional Linear Model Emotion(t) = µ(t) + β0(t){AudRemoved} + β1(t){VidRemoved} + ε(t)
Derivatives describe music dynamics: Tension • These judgments are really measures of musical emotion. • ‘Tension/Resolution’ is rate of change of emotion (velocity). • When emotion is rapidly increasing, music has strong tension. • When emotion is rapidly decreasing, music has strong resolution.
Derivatives describe music dynamics: Force/Release • ‘Force/Release’ is rate of change of tension (acceleration). • When tension is rapidly increasing, we feel a musical force. • When tension is rapidly decreasing, we feel a musical release. • When both derivatives are near zero, music is inert (the “new age/massage music” effect).
Phase-Plane Plots • Can examine dynamics with plot of acceleration vs velocity. • Purely harmonic behavior gives a circle. • The larger the radius, the more musical energy transfer.
25 – 33 s: • AUDIO: high volume, note density, and pitch; end of musical phrase • tension then strong resolution; big energy transfer • VIDEO: routine gestures; then dramatic flourish • low tension and small resolution; moderate pull with flourish; small energy transfer 33 – 65 s: • AUDIO: decrease in volume (mezzo forte to pianissimo), note density, and pitch • continued resolution; push from new phrase; back to inertness • VIDEO: eyebrow and body movements • push from new phrase, moderate tension from movements
What have we learned? • New applications • PCA as exploration • Derivatives have physical (and scientific) meaning • Phase-Plane plots highlight relationships