160 likes | 175 Views
We the People. The Citizen and the Constitution. Lesson 13. How did the Framers resolve the conflict about representation in Congress?. United States 1787. = Large State (by Population). What important conflict existed between the large and small states?.
E N D
We the People The Citizen and the Constitution
Lesson 13 How did the Framers resolve the conflict about representation in Congress?
United States 1787 = Large State (by Population)
What important conflict existed between the large and small states? • Framers disagreed about reps in Congress • Small states feared large ones would control nat’l gov. • Small states wanted equal representation-each state has same number of reps in Congress • Large states thought equal rep unfair
What important conflict existed between the large and small states? • Large states wanted proportional representation-base number of reps in Congress on number of people in state
What was the Virginia Plan? 1. Plan for strong nat’l govt; James Madison 2. Prop’ed federal system-state & nat’l govt’s get pwr from ppl 3. Nat’l gov power to make/enforce own laws, collect taxes 4. Three branches-legislative, executive, judicial 5. Nat’l legislature-two houses • House of Reps • Senate • Reps in two houses proportional
What was the Virginia Plan? • Considerable debate-small states oppose, do not want to be dominated by large states
What was the New Jersey Plan? • William Paterson introduces new plan for representation- NJ Plan • Weak nat’l gov’t w/ one house of Congress • Equal representation • Congress power to collect taxes, levy fines • Congress has power to regulate trade-states/nations • Exec (several) appointed by Congress & Judicial appointed by Exec.
What was the New Jersey Plan? • Convention is divided; Neither side willing to accept other side • Tension growing; Special committee appointed
How did the Great Compromise solve the problem of representation? • Connecticut Compromise=Great Compromise • Three parts • Congress= two houses Senate & House of Reps • House is proportional; power to tax and control gov spending • Senate is equal representation; power to make changes to bills from House (now) • Passed by one vote
US Capitol-Legislative Branch • Senate • 100 Senators • 2 each state • Equal Rep. • House of Representatives • 435 Representatives • Proportional Rep.
The Great Compromise See p. 232 of Textbook
Summary Write a summary of these notes. • A summary should be a short, well-written paragraph (complete sentences, but okay to abbreviate) • It should mention all parts of the notes • It should address the essential question