1 / 21

ALTCI Actuarial Study — Final Results

September 14, 2005. ALTCI Actuarial Study — Final Results. Actuarial Study Objectives. Determine key cost drivers Identify financing options that promote the goals of ALTCI Recommend a Medi-Cal rate structure that will best match payment to the risk of the enrolled population

makya
Download Presentation

ALTCI Actuarial Study — Final Results

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. September 14, 2005 ALTCIActuarial Study — Final Results

  2. Actuarial Study Objectives • Determine key cost drivers • Identify financing options that promote the goals of ALTCI • Recommend a Medi-Cal rate structure that will best match payment to the risk of the enrolled population • Assess adequacy of Medicare reimbursement for ALTCI population

  3. Key Considerations • Individual health plan risk is driven by a number of factors, including • Program design • Who will be eligible (population subgroups)? • What services will be covered? • Integration with Medicare? • Contracting approach • Mandatory vs. optional enrollment • Number of health plans competing • Operational Issues • Enrollment and screening/assessment process • Case management and care coordination requirements • Administrative responsibilities

  4. Assumptions • For our analysis, we assumed • Mandatory enrollment (for completeness purposes only - i.e., so that the entire population would be subject to analysis, allowing creation of a reimbursement model that would work for a voluntary program) • All adult SPD eligibles (21 and older) • All services, except specialty mental health, dental, and DD waiver services • ALTCI participating health plans would also have to participate in Medicare

  5. What’s New from the Previous Presentation? • Change in population definitions • Medicare Part B only population included in Medi-Cal only population group • Blended IHSS, MSSP, and Home Care together to create a rating category of Community At Risk • Chronic condition analysis for Medi-Cal community population • Medicare sufficiency analysis

  6. Methodology • Review historical Medi-Cal and Medicare CY1998 – 2000 FFS data • Adjust data to include only populations and services expected to be covered under ALTCI • Project data forward to CY2007 by category of service • Adjust data for significant program changes including Medicare Part D

  7. CY2000 Medi-Cal DataSan Diego County • Nursing Home Residents, DD, and At Risk account for 28 percent of the total ALTCI membership in San Diego, but 74 percent of the total San Diego Medi-Cal expenditures

  8. San Diego CountyCY2000 Dually Eligible vs. Medi-Cal Only*ABD Membership * Includes recipients with Part B only coverage.

  9. San Diego CountyCY2000 Dually Eligible vs. Medi-Cal Only*ABD Medi-Cal Expenditures * Includes recipients with Part B only coverage.

  10. San Diego CountyCY2000Elderly vs. Disabled Membership

  11. San Diego CountyCY2000Elderly vs. Disabled Medi-Cal Expenditures

  12. Chronic Condition Analysis • Reviewed 23 chronic disease categories • Analyzed 3 years of data from CY1998 – CY2000 for 3 counties (Alameda, Contra Costa, and San Diego) to enhance credibility • Separate analysis for Community At Risk and Not At Risk • Reviewed cases with annual Medi-Cal costs in excess of $100,000 • Findings show highest cost condition overall for Medi-Cal is ventilator dependents • Of the cases in excess of $100,000 annually, 20% were ventilator dependent • Recommendation is to consider a separate risk adjustor for ventilator dependents in the community

  13. Total $443 Total Setting NH $2,487 Community $261 NHC $2,487 At Risk $731 Not At Risk $157 DD $367 Frailty Medicare Status Medi-Cal Only* $4,230 Dual $26 Medi-Cal Only* $253 Medi-Cal Only* $438 Dual $2,099 Dual $542 Medi-Cal Only* $1,003 Dual $238 Disabled $238 Aged $2,240 Disabled $1,789 Aged $215 Aged $23 Disabled $28 Aged $513 Disabled $564 Category of Aid Aged $119 Disabled $304 Aged $3,188 Disabled $4,589 Aged $694 Disabled $1,135 Aged $1,998 Disabled $438 San Diego CountyCY2000 Medi-Cal ALTCI PMPM Costs *Includes Part B only recipients.

  14. Pharmacy Physician Comm LTC Inst LTC Outpatient Inpatient Other Medi-Cal Only Dual Medicare Dual Medi-Cal San Diego CountyDually Eligible vs. Medi-Cal OnlyCY2000PMPM ALTCI Medi-Cal and Medicare Costs

  15. Medicare Sufficiency Analysis • Used base data (1999 and 2000) to calculate estimated Medicare reimbursement for 2000 • Utilized 2005 Medicare Reimbursement Rules • Compared estimated Medicare reimbursement to actual Medicare FFS costs for 2000 • Reviewed by population subgroup

  16. Medicare Sufficiency Findings • In 2000, Medicare reimbursement would have been sufficient for the ALTCI population in total (across all population subgroups) • Sufficiency of Medicare reimbursement is highly variable by population subgroup • See details on the next slide

  17. All ALTCI Dual Eligibles 2000 Costs $725 Rate $730 Sufficiency 0.67% Total NH $1,366 $986 -28% Community $634 $694 9% Setting At Risk $1,115 $914 -18% Not At Risk $513 $641 25% DD $282 $495 76% NHC $1,366 $986 -28% Frailty Medicare Status Dual* $1,366 $986 -28% Dual* $1,115 $914 -18% Dual* $513 $641 25% Dual* $282 $495 76% Category of Aid Aged $1,120 $780 -30% Aged $1,100 $980 -11% Aged $438 $679 55% Disabled $580 $606 5% Disabled $1,463 $834 -43% Disabled $1,128 $857 -24% Disabled $280 $494 77% Aged $1,304 $1,082 -17% San Diego CountyCY2000 ALTCI Medicare Sufficiency *Includes only recipients with both Part A and B coverage.

  18. Medicare SufficiencyOther Points • Need to update the analysis • Because Medicare beneficiaries would not be forced to select an ALTCI Plan, the mix of the population that chooses is important • Medicare still working on a frailty adjuster for non-PACE plans. This will not be implemented before 2007

  19. ResultsKey Medi-Cal Cost Drivers • Identified 10 key rating categories • Setting — Nursing Home vs. Community • Frailty — Nursing Home Certifiable/At Risk vs. Not At Risk and DD • Medicare Status — Dually Eligible vs. Medi-Cal Only • Category of Assistance — Aged vs. Disabled • Chronic High Risk Conditions — Ventilator Dependents

  20. Recommendations • Reimbursement needs to be sufficiently sophisticated to promote program goals • Utilize multiple capitation risk groupings • Include some risk adjustment mechanism • Incentives should be included to promote increased community based services • Savings achievable through more appropriate use of hospital, emergency room and nursing home services

  21. Recommendations (continued) • Administrative costs should be reflected in rates with sufficient consideration of start up costs • Increased care management should be supported and funded • Implement early reinsurance or risk sharing • Capitated model should allow for flexibility of both Medi-Cal and Medicare funding sources • Reimbursement mechanisms should continue to be refined as the program matures

More Related