430 likes | 515 Views
Linguistic and geographical co-occurrence constraints on /r/ and /g/ in Dutch dialects. Ton Goeman (Meertens Institute Amsterdam) Hans Van de Velde (Université Libre de Bruxelles). Based on a new dialect survey. A. Dutch-Flemish Dialect Conference 1975
E N D
Linguistic and geographical co-occurrence constraints on /r/ and /g/ in Dutch dialects Ton Goeman (Meertens Institute Amsterdam) Hans Van de Velde (Université Libre de Bruxelles)
Based on a new dialect survey • A. Dutch-Flemish Dialect Conference 1975 • B. Lacuna’s in phonological and morphological dialect knowledge • C. Structure of changing dialects at the end of the 20th century • D. Fieldwork
HOW? • A. Questionnaire & transcriptions in narrow IPA • B. Localities • 410 localities in the Netherlands • 210 localities in Belgium • 52 localities in the province of Friesland • C. Collaboration • Meertens Instituut / Ghent / Leuven / Groningen / Fryske Akademy / Free University Amsterdam
Results fieldwork 1982-1992 • Transcriptions entered in databank: • Netherlands: 365 localities; 25 by Groningen: Drente • Belgium: 189 localities • Total: 554 • Friesland: 23 localities only fragmentarily
Distribution of the 554 localities
Phonology: what? Vocalism: Long (also historically long) Short (id.) Diphthongs (id.) With & without front mutation factor Open & closed syllables
Vocalism (cont.) • Before all rhyme positions (voiced & voiceless ): • -t/d, s/z, p/b, f/v, k, ch/g, l, r, n, m, w, j, morpheme final, st/sp/sk, ts/ps/ks, ft/cht, • r+t/d, r+s/z, r+labial, l+velar, r+l, r+n, r+m • n+t/d, n+s/z, m+p, ng(+velar) • l+alveolar, l+labial, l+velar, l+m • l+CC, r+CC, n+CC
Consonants wordinitially (before different vowels) • New with respect to past projects: • Completeness • Unknown state of affairs: e.g.: pronunciation of / g /: ‘soft’ g en ‘harsh’ g • Not transcribed in the past • Not retraceable by postal questionnaire • Example as making part of future volume of FAND: ‘g’ in geven ‘give’: __[-back]
/ƒ/ in ‘geven’ Fieldwork Amsterdam Leuven Gent Groningen
Total: 1878 wordforms, wordgroups or sentences • 286 wordforms with / g / • 76 wordinitial wordforms with / r / • 62 wordfinal wordforms with / r /
Items chosen for /r/ • Initial / r / • riem ‘belt’ / i / regen ‘rain’ / e. /, rest ‘rest’ / E /, rood ‘red’ / o. / • Initial / r / cluster • vroeg ‘early’ / u /, groen ‘green’, droog ‘dry’ /o./, groot ‘great’ /o./ • Final / r / • bier ‘beer / i. /’, weer ‘anew’ / e. /, meer ‘more’, zwaar ‘heavy’ / a, /, zuur ‘sour’ / y /, duur ‘expensive’ / y /
Items chosen for /g/ • Initial (/ I , e. , E , a ,A,ç , o. , u /) • gisteren ‘yesterday’, geel ‘yellow’, geven ‘give, geld ‘money’, gapen ‘yawn’, gaan ‘go’, gal ‘bile’, god ‘god’, goot ‘gutter, goed ‘good’ • Final (/ e. , E, u /) • deeg ‘pastry’, weg ‘way, vroeg ‘early’
Overall frequency of variants and geographical distribution • Frequencies of variants may be more or less the same when the whole linguistic area is taken into account • tables • However, the distribution of variants may differ when we look at their geographical spread • maps
Different realisations of ‘palatal’ /g / Goeman (1999)
/ r / versus / g / word initially Front vowels
/ r / versus / g / word finally Front vowels
Conclusions for / r / and / g / • Regions with velar g show also apical r • Regions with palatal g show uvular R • But not in the North East • Not word finally in North Holland • Regions with extremely fronted /g/ are kernel regions with uvular R • Initially • Region with faryngeal~h g show apical r • Finally • Region with velar g show apical r • In Zealand
Conclusions specific for / g / • Word finally, allophonic distribution is more clear than word initially • Sometimes word specific • Contrary to the Standard Language, uvular / g / is in the minority in the dialects
Conclusions specific for / r / compared to / g / • Initially, no allophonic vowel distribution effects for / r / • Cfr. Van Reenen • While light allophonic vowel distribution effects for for / g / • South and East /R/ from Germany • Cfr. Van Reenen (Cologne?) • While palatal / g / autochtonous (or from Cologne?) • Cfr. for Cologne Weijnen
Correlation Coefficients all correlations are significant, p<.001
Fieldwork, IPA transcriptions or data entry/correction Amsterdam • J. Aben, B. van den Berg, J. Buitenhuis, D. Coppes, J. Daan, M. Engelen, M. Fransen, L. Gijsbers, T. Goeman, R. Hofstee, E. van Houten, T. de Jong, I. Kemperman-van Driel, A. Klaassen, M. Klamer, G. Kocks, J. Kruijssen, Lutz, E. Matthijs, M. van Mulken, A. Ottow-Kolman, B. Pijn, S. van der Ree, P. van Reenen, K. van Reenen-Stein, A. de Reus, J. de Rooij, M. Schellevis, M. Stols, H. Veenhof-Haan, P. Veerman, P. van Vliet, A. de Vries, C. van Zaanen