1 / 9

Islam & The West

Islam & The West. Enduring Images. ‘Islam’: lascivious, perverted (polygamy and ‘Lustful Turk’- but respect Muslim knowledge (ex. Ibn Sina/Avicenna), occasional chivalry ‘Franks/West’: barbarous, ignorant, morally loose (but respect bravery, honor)

maleah
Download Presentation

Islam & The West

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. Islam &The West

  2. Enduring Images • ‘Islam’: lascivious, perverted (polygamy and ‘Lustful Turk’- but respect Muslim knowledge (ex. Ibn Sina/Avicenna), occasional chivalry • ‘Franks/West’: barbarous, ignorant, morally loose (but respect bravery, honor) • ‘Oriental Despot’ vs. later, ungrounded ‘freedom’ • Invaders & Threats: Crusades and Turks, ‘Terrorists’ vs. ‘Imperialists’

  3. Early Encounters and Polemics • Muslims/Arabs as conquerors • Scourge of God/Sign of Antichrist • Pact of Umar • Benevolent rulers? (John of Phenakwr. 687) • Heretics to be debated • John of Damascus (d. 749): Islam as heresy cooked up by Muhammad; lustful • From Muslim side: Letters of Umar II to Leo (why do you worship saints and relics; Trinity; ignoring Paraclete); rebuttals of Jahiz and al-Kindi etc.

  4. Medieval Images Popular Lore: • Moors as monstrous, idolaters: • Chanson de Gestes: ex. Chanson de Roland of 11th century • Mohammmad as idol, charlatan, governed by appetites • Shared culture of chivalry: Saladin and Crusaders Scholarly Polemics: Peter the Venerable and Robert of Ketton (1143); Dante’s Inferno

  5. Early Modern Images Real Sources: • De Vita et rebus gestic Mohammedis (1723), translation of ‘Abulfeda’ Tarikh al-Bashar by Joannes Gagnier Sympathetic Enlightenment Image: Islam as foil for criticism of Catholicism and Jews • Henri de Boullainvillier (d. 1722), La Vie de Mahomet (London 1730) • Voltaire: complicated image… • Weil, Gustav. Mohammad der Prophet, sein Leben und sein Lehre (1843) • Thomas Carlyle and Mohammad as hero

  6. Enduring Image of Chivalry (and now ‘moderation’) • Saladin Jews and Arabs unite (Ben Hur 1959)? Arabs as backward, in need of European aid (Lawrence of Arabia 1962)?

  7. Post 1973-4 Oil Embargo • Revival of old images: • Arab oil shaykhs • Despotic • Lustful and perverted • Islam as barbaric, violent, irrational

  8. Post 1979 Iranian Revolution Muslims as terrorists Muslims as inhumanly violent and untrustworthy: • The Siege (1998) (boyfriend as terrorist) • Rules of Engagement (2000) (women fire)

  9. Questions & Comments

More Related