260 likes | 367 Views
Direct CP violation in 3-body B decays. Hai-Yang Cheng Academia Sinica. in collaboration with Chun-Khiang Chua. XS2014, Hefei May 06, 2014. Direct CP asymmetries (2-body). . No CP asymmetry observed by LHCb in B - K -.
E N D
Direct CP violation in 3-body B decays Hai-Yang Cheng Academia Sinica in collaboration with Chun-Khiang Chua XS2014, Hefei May 06, 2014
Direct CP asymmetries (2-body) No CP asymmetry observed by LHCb in B-K- AKACP(K-0) – ACP(K-+) K puzzle: AK is naively expected to vanish 2 2 2
Direct CP asymmetries (3-body) LHCb found evidence of inclusive CP asymmetry in B-+--, K+K-K-, K+K-- Large asymmetries observed in localized regions of p.s. ACP(KK) = -0.6480.0700.0130.007 for mKK2 <1.5 GeV2 ACP(KKK) = -0.2260.0200.0040.007 for 1.2< mKK, low2 <2.0 GeV2, mKK, high2 <15 GeV2 ACP() = 0.5840.0820.0270.007 for m, low2 <0.4 GeV2, m, high2 > 15 GeV2 ACP(K) = 0.6780.0780.0320.007 for 0.08< m, low2 <0.66 GeV2, mK2 <15 GeV2
K-+- K+K+K- ++- K+K+-
Cheng, Chua, Soni [0704.1049] Zhang, Guo, Yang [1303.3676] Bhattacharya, Gronau, Rosner [1306.2625] Xu, Li, He [1307.7186] Bediaga, Frederico, Lourenco [1307.8164] Gronau [1308.3448] Cheng, Chua [1308.5139] Zhang, Guo, Yang [1308.5242] Lesniak, Zenczykowski [1309.1689] Di Salvo [1309.7448] Xu, Li, He [1311.3714] Cheng, Chua [1401.5514] Ying Li [1401.5948] Bhattacharya, Gronau, Imbeault, London, Rosner [1402.2909] Wang, Hu, Li, Lu [1402.5280] Ying Li [1402.6052] Wen-Fei Wang’s talk on May 8th
Many three-body B decays have been observed with BFs ~10-5 (BFs ~ 10-6 for B KK & Bs KKK) • useful for extracting CKM angles, CP violation • A(B→P1P2P3)= resonant + nonresonant (NR) All the quasi-2-body B decays, B→VP,SP (except 00, ) are extracted from Dalitz plot analysis of 3-body decays • NR signal is less than 10% in D decays. Many argued that 3-body B decays are also dominated by resonant contributions (LHCb) 6 6
Three-body B decays A striking feature: Large NR fractions in penguin-dominated modes Nonresonant fraction (%) KKK: 70-90% K: 35-40% by Belle, 20% by BaBar K0: 15-20% : 35% NR contributions are essential in three-body B decays One of our goals is to identify the origin of NR signals 7 HYC, Chua, Soni (’07)
P2 All three mesons energetic b P1 P3 (a) P2 All three mesons energetic, but two of them nearly parallel P1 P3 (b) P3 All three energetic & two of them nearly parallel. The spectator quark is kicked by a hard gluon to become hard P2 P1 (c) (b) & (c) mimic 2-body decays P3 Two energetic (P1, P2) & one soft (P3) P1 P2 (d)
Three factorizable amplitudes for B0→K+K-K0 • current-induced process: <B0→K0><0→K+K-> • transition process: <B0 →K-K0><0→K+> • annihilation process: <B0→0><0→K+K-K0> b→u b→s
b→u NR contribution of • Early attempt: Apply HMChPT to evaluate form factors r and (CLY)2; Wise; Burdman, Donoghue Bajc, Fajfer, Oakes, Pham; Deandrea et al. (’99) K- K0 K- B0 +,r r B- B0 K0 K0 K- K0 +,-,r B0 B*0s B- r B0 B*0s K- 10
NR rates for tree-dominated B→KK, will become too large For example, Br(B-→K+K--)NR = 3310-6 larger than total BF, 510-6 ⇒HMChPT is applicable only to soft mesons ! • Ways of improving the use of HMChPT have been suggested before • We propose to write NR amplitude as Fajfer et al; Yang, HYC,… -- HMChPT is recovered in soft meson limit, p1, p2→0 -- The parameter NR» 1/(2mB) is constrained from B-→+--
b→u - Resonant contribution of + B- - V=, , …, S=f0(980), f0(1370), f0(1500), f(1710),… 12 12
b→s Decay constants for scalar mesons have been evaluated in various approaches Chua,Yang, HYC; C.D. Lu et al How about the NR contributions ? 13
<K+K-|qq|0> can be related to the kaon’s e.m. form factors ch, x1, x2 fitted from kaon e.m. data Chua,Hou,Shiau,Tsai (’03) motivated by asymptotic constraint from QCD counting rules Brodsky, Farrar (’75) The fitted ch agrees with the model (~ decay constant x strong coupling) NR NR exp[i/4](3.39+0.18-0.21) GeV from K+K- spectrum of K+K-KS 14 from KSKSKS rate
The decay amplitude of B0 K+K-K0 consists of two pieces: • Nonresonant: <B0K+K-><0K0> • <B0K0><0K+K-> • (<B0K0><0 K+K->)penguin • Resonant:B0f0K0K+K-K0 , f0 = f0(980), f0(1500), f0(1710),… • B0VK0K+K-K0, V =, , ,… Weak phase: CKM matrix elements Strong phases: (i) effective Wilson coefficients (ii) propagator (s - m2 + im)-1 (iii) matrix element <M1M2|qq|0> for NR contribution in the penguin sector
B-→K+K-K- BF(10-6) calculable for the first time theory errors: (NR) , (ms, NR, form factors), () • Large NR rate is penguin-dominated and governed by <K+K-|ss|0>NR NR rates: mostly from b→s (via <KK|ss|0>) and a few percentages from b→u transitions
We predict a larger rate of +-0 than +-- as the former receives and 0 resonant contributions with BF of order 2010-6, while only 0 to the latter. • Belle (’13): Br(B0 K+ K-0) = (2.170.65)10-6 is a surprise ! Recall that Br(B- K+K--) = (5.00.7)10-6 At short-distance level, we obtain BF ~ 510-8 Long-distance contribution due to B0+-0 followed by +- K+K- rescattering BF 0.510-6
Inclusive direct CP asymmetries U-spin symmetry (s d) Xu, Li, He; Bhattacharya, Gronau, Rosner Relative signs between K-K+K- & -+- and between K-+- & -K+K- agree with experiment & U-spin symmetry predictions However, relative signs between -K+K- & -+- and between K-+- & K-K+K- disagree with the data
Xu, Li, He (I, ’13) Naïve U-spin symmetry relations However, momentum dependence of decay amplitudes should be taken into account Xu, Li, He (II, ’13) Correlation seen by LHCb: ACP(K-K+K-) – ACP(K-+-), ACP(-K+K-) – ACP(-+-) It has been conjectured that CPT theorem & final-state rescattering of +- K+K- may play important roles Bediaga et al FSI
Fit to B-K-+- U-spin symmetry U-spin symmetry which relates <K|sd|0> to <KK|ss|0> is badly broken
Direct CP violation in 3-body Bu,d decays predictions
K-+- K+K+K- ++- K+K+- 22
Regional CP asymmetries due to NR contributions (ACPregion)NR+RES22.5+2.9-3.314.1+13.9-11.7 -18.2+1.8-1.8 -17.7+4.9-2.9 Except K+K-K- the magnitude of local CP asymmetries is substantially reduced by nearby resonances Wang et al. 51.9+16.7-23.9 Zhang, Guo, Yang advocated that local CP violation in +-- arises from interference of 0 with f0(500)
BFs & CP violation in 3-body Bs decays LHCb made first observation of three charmless 3-body Bs decays Penguin-dominated (10-6) (10-6) Tree-dominated • Penguin-dominated modes K0K-+, K0K+- have largest rates, dominated by K*0(1430) resonances • Tree-dominated mode K+K-K0 is predicted to have BF ~ 1.410-6 ACP(K0K+K-) - 2ACP(K0+-)
U-spin symmetry relations They cannot be tested by the present available data, but can be checked by dynamical calculations. U-spin relations are generally not well respected as U-spin symmetry is sometimes badly broken
Conclusions • CP asymmetries are the ideal places to discriminate between different models. • Three-body B decays receive sizable NR contributions governed by the matrix elements of scalar densities. • Three sources of strong phases responsible for direct CP violation in 3-body B decays.