370 likes | 564 Views
Creating a New Data Science Track In a Traditional Biomedical Informatics Training Program. W. Chapman, D. Borbolla , K. Eilbeck , S. Abdelrahman, J. Ferraro, B. Chapman, C. Weir, J. Hurdle, O. Patterson, E. Hernandez University of Utah. Disclosure. Wendy Chapman is a consultant for IBM.
E N D
Creating a New Data Science Track • In a Traditional Biomedical Informatics • Training Program W. Chapman, D. Borbolla, K. Eilbeck, S. Abdelrahman, J. Ferraro, B. Chapman, C. Weir, J. Hurdle, O. Patterson, E. Hernandez University of Utah
Disclosure • Wendy Chapman is a consultant for IBM.
University of Utah1st informatics department in the U.S. 1964 – department 1965 – 1st PhD Homer Warner, Al Pryor, Reed Gardner Clayton PD. “Why not? Let's do it!” Presentation of the Morris F. Collen Award to Homer R. Warner, MD, PhD. J Am Med Inform Assoc 1995;2:2 137-142.
Interviews with new PhD graduates I never hire informatics students—they can do what my research requires There are many things I wanted to do but I didn’t have the technical skills. students faculty
I wouldn’t hire most of our grads as a data scientist We are producing informaticists with data science skills What type of graduate are you trying to produce?
Programming Language R is better for statistics Introducing two languages in the first year is not as effective for learning
Leaning towards this • 1st year Python • Intro to Programming • Intro to Data Science from CS • Summer SIG in R • Second year Advanced Stats in R
Unique vs duplicative vs outsourcing CS is not in the business of teaching graduate students to program We shouldn’t be teaching introductory programming
Unique vs duplicative vs outsourcing CS is not in the business of teaching graduate students to program We shouldn’t be teaching introductory programming Teaching introduction to programming
Unique vs duplicative vs outsourcing Many of our data science track students do not have enough math background Why can’t students take machine learning from CS?
Unique vs duplicative vs outsourcing We are an informatics department and shouldn’t be replicating all classes We will be irrelevant if we send our students to CS for too many courses
Unique vs duplicative vs outsourcing Many of our data science track students do not have enough math background Why can’t students take machine learning from CS? Teaching 2 machine learning courses Advanced students take CS ML
Evening the playing field Others have strong computational backgrounds Some of our data science track students are pivoting
Evening the playing field Others have strong computational backgrounds Some of our data science track students are pivoting Summer Data Camp Intro to Python
Data Science Track within BMI Degree This class goes way too slow and caters to beginners! This class is way too advanced!
Data Science Track within BMI Degree This class goes way too slow and caters to beginners! This class is way too advanced! Two Intro to Programming courses
What Not to Teach Data science grads need to know more Data science track requires too many credits Special Interest Group
Relationship of data science and informatics https://www.innoarchitech.com/blog/what-is-data-science-does-data-scientist-do
Learning Health System Thanks to Jonathan Silverstein
Knowledge Data Wisdom Thanks to Jonathan Silverstein
Decision making Data Science Committee Brings decisions to curriculum committee Final voting by all faculty Who makes what decisions?
Assess and improve the quality of teaching https://sites.google.com/view/biomed-data-science-edu/home
Building infrastructure Creating an On-demand On-line Learning Environment for Biomedical Informatics and Data Science Wed. 15:45 – 16:15 Grand Ballroom Salon EFG
Iterative Report to curriculum committee Focus groups Individual discussions Try Assess Improve Repeat
Conclusion We keep improving Our “products” are pretty impressive - In spite of the implication of our improving over time
AMIA is the professional home for more than 5,400 informatics professionals, representing frontline clinicians, researchers, public health experts and educators who bring meaning to data, manage information and generate new knowledge across the research and healthcare enterprise. AMIA 2019 Informatics Educators Forum | amia.org