1 / 22

Financial&economic sustainability of an economy Some exploratory remarks J.P. Fitoussi

Financial&economic sustainability of an economy Some exploratory remarks J.P. Fitoussi X. Timbeau. Based on the OFCE working paper «   Financial&economic sustainability of an economy, Some exploratory remarks », available at www.ofce.sciences-po.fr xavier.timbeau@ofce.sciences-po.fr.

Download Presentation

Financial&economic sustainability of an economy Some exploratory remarks J.P. Fitoussi

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Financial&economic sustainability of an economy Some exploratory remarks J.P. Fitoussi X. Timbeau Based on the OFCE workingpaper«  Financial&economicsustainability of an economy, Some exploratory remarks», available at www.ofce.sciences-po.fr xavier.timbeau@ofce.sciences-po.fr

  2. Aim and method • Better understanding of financial of public and private sector situation • Starting from “usual” sustainability of public debt • To sustainability of public finance (public wealth account, private wealth) • To sustainability of debt, public and private • Long term sustainability has to do with wealth : wealth is a looking forward value; • Short term sustainability relates flow to flow (debt to gdp) • What is wealth ? • Financial Balance sheets • Assets (equity, pension funds); liabilities (debts) • Public sector and household : non Modigliani Miller theorem agents, debt is the only lever • In a closed economy, net worth of firms and financial sector is held by public or households • The concept of sustainability used here exclude sustainability of business (financial&non financial sector) • Financial and non financial balance sheets • Adding physical assets when available (balance sheets) • Correcting for pension funds and land value when possible JPF&XT

  3. Part I : public debt • We will consider net debt • Gross (Maastricht) debt is improper for international comparison • Gross debt is a wrongful when used as a goal • Discussion over inclusion of sone entities in public debt is important when considering groos debt, much less when considering net debt • Gross debt is easier to manipulate • Gross debt leads to state reduction, not good governance • Stability of public debt is a short term indicator of (macro) public finance stance • Stability of public debt is linked to public deficit (or surplus) • sp being primary surplus, d net public liabilities (or net debt), g potential growth, gap output gap, r (real) interest rate • s* primary balance stabilizing debt is define ass* = - d (g – r) • Rot Tax gap is the gap between s* and structural primary balance (a negative tax gap means that net debt will be decreasing when gap will be null) is defined usually astax gap =sd- (sp - 0.5gap) JPF&XT

  4. (rot) Tax Gap in 2013 for various countries • Tax gap is positive for most countries • Calls for a large reduction in public deficit Tax gap in 2013, as % of potential GDP Source : OECD Economic Outlook, june 2014. JPF&XT

  5. Naivetax gap does’ntconsiderouput gap dynamic • Deficits are large because gaps are negative • But structural deficits are positive : long lasting impact of crisis • This is the usualcalculus • Reducingdeficitwill cause more gap (fiscal multiplier) • Gap dynamicwillbe to close, but in the meantime, balance isgoing to belessthan structural • That willadd up more debt and call for more structural surplus in the end • That isdependent on 2 key parameters : the soonerisyourtarget for debt, the harder ; the critical gap (r-g) plays a role, as well as g : deflationis a trap JPF&XT

  6. Modelisation of debt dynamic • A simple « model » • is net debt (as a % of potential output); is primary public surplus (as a % of potential output); is structural primary surplus (as a % of potential output); isinterestrate;is rate of potentialgrowth; is output gap; is fiscal multiplier; • Rot taxgap is • is close to rot tax gap, plus a reduction of debt to a target • Similar to presentspecification of europeantreaties JPF&XT

  7. Output gap dynamic, multiplier and surplus • Surplus is the sum of structural and cyclical surplus • Output gap is following a simple dynamic • Fiscal policy is measured as • Multiplier effect is set to zero in the long term • Cumulated fiscal multiplier depends on and • Tax gap is then With and Debt gap (and snowballeffect) Output gap loss Multiplier effect of consolidation JPF&XT

  8. Dynamictax gap Source : authorscalculation, JPF&XT

  9. Debt targets are overwhelming JPF&XT

  10. Sensibility to key parameters JPF&XT

  11. In 2007 thingswerelookingbetter JPF&XT

  12. There couldbe a correlation… JPF&XT

  13. Going one step further : financial accounts • A broader view on financial situation • Agregating households and public sector Financial wealth, %GDP, ranked on hedge Source : OECD Economic Outlook #95, june 2014, financial accounts, march 2014. JPF&XT

  14. Evolution since 2007 JPF&XT

  15. An evenbroaderview : includingphysical capital as well Financial&non financial wealth, %GDP, ranked on hedge Source : OECD Economic Outlook #95, june 2014, financial accounts, march 2014. JPF&XT

  16. Evolution for France JPF&XT

  17. Evolution for Italy JPF&XT

  18. Evolution for United Kingdom JPF&XT

  19. Evolution for USA JPF&XT

  20. Evolution for Germany JPF&XT

  21. That brings a slightlydifferent perspective on what’s to bedone • Reduction in net public debt for the samemeasure of sustainabilitythan in 2007 JPF&XT

  22. Nevertheless, debttargets are implying large consolidation • One off global wealth tax (IMF) or permanent global wealth tax (Piketty) can solve the problem • General inventory of wealth, deal with tax heavens and tax evasion • 2 times column 5 as a marginal rate allow to exempt low wealth from taxation and tax « moderatly » high wealth • 2 times column 5 over 20 years implies annual taxation from .2% (DEU) to .8% (FRA) • Certainly better than defaulting; wich is nearly inevitable for ESP, GRC and PRT (and probably IRL) • Or, keep the debt as it is… *2007 net debt in 2034 JPF&XT

More Related