370 likes | 508 Views
Cancer Classification with Data-dependent Kernels. Anne Ya Zhang (with Xue-wen Chen & Huilin Xiong) EECS & ITTC University of Kansas. Outline. Introduction Data-dependent Kernel Results Conclusion. Cancer facts. Cancer is a group of many related diseases
E N D
Cancer Classification with Data-dependent Kernels Anne Ya Zhang (with Xue-wen Chen & Huilin Xiong) EECS & ITTC University of Kansas DIMACS Workshop on Machine Learning Techniques in Bioinformatics
Outline • Introduction • Data-dependent Kernel • Results • Conclusion DIMACS Workshop on Machine Learning Techniques in Bioinformatics
Cancer facts • Cancer is a group of many related diseases • Cells continue to grow and divide and do not die when they should. • Changes in the genes that control normal cell growth and death. • Cancer is the second leading cause of death in the United States • Cancer causes 1 of every 4 deaths • NIH estimate overall costs for cancer in 2004 at $189.8 billion ($64.9 billion for direct medical cost) • Cancer types • Breast cancer, Lung cancer, Colon cancer, … • Death rates vary greatly by cancer type and stage at diagnosis DIMACS Workshop on Machine Learning Techniques in Bioinformatics
Motivation • Why do we need to classify cancers? • The general way of treating cancer is to: • Categorize the cancers in different classes • Use specific treatment for each of the classes • Traditional way to classify cancers • Morphological appearance Not accurate! • Enzyme-based histochemical analyses. • Immunophenotyping. • Cytogenetic analysis. Complicated & needs highly specialized laboratories DIMACS Workshop on Machine Learning Techniques in Bioinformatics
Motivation • Why traditional ways are not enough ? • There exists some tumors in the same class with completely different clinical courses • May be more accurate classification is needed • Assigning new tumors to known cancer classes is not easy • e.g. assigning an acute leukemia tumor to one of the • AML (acute myeloid leukemia) • ALL (acute lymphoblastic leukemia) DIMACS Workshop on Machine Learning Techniques in Bioinformatics
DNA Microarray-based Cancer Diagnosis • Cancer is caused by changes in the genes that control normal cell growth and death. • Molecular diagnostics offer the promise of precise, objective, and systematic cancer classification • These tests are not widely applied because characteristic molecular markers for most solid tumors have to be identified. • Recently, microarray tumor gene expression profiles have been used for cancer diagnosis. DIMACS Workshop on Machine Learning Techniques in Bioinformatics
Low Zero High C1 C2 C3 C4 C5 C6 C7 G1 G2 G3 G4 G5 G6 G7 G6 G7 Microarray • A microarray experiment monitors the expression levels for thousands of genes simultaneously. • Microarray techniques will lead to a more complete understanding of the molecular variations among tumors, hence to a more reliable classification. DIMACS Workshop on Machine Learning Techniques in Bioinformatics
Microarray • Microarray analysis allows the monitoring of the activities of thousands of genes over many different conditions. • From a machine learning point of view… The large volume of the data requires the computational aid in analyzing the expression data. DIMACS Workshop on Machine Learning Techniques in Bioinformatics
Machine learning tasks in cancer classification • There are three main types of machine learning problems associated with cancer classification: • The identification of new cancer classes using gene expression profiles • The classification of cancer into known classes • The identifications of “marker” genes that characterize the different cancer classes • In this presentation, we focus on the second type of problems. DIMACS Workshop on Machine Learning Techniques in Bioinformatics
Project Goals • To develop a more systematic machine learning approach to cancer classification using microarray gene expression profiles. • Use an initial collection of samples belonging to the known classes of cancer to create a “class predictor” for new, unknown, samples. DIMACS Workshop on Machine Learning Techniques in Bioinformatics
AML Challenges in cancer classification • Gene expression data are typically characterized by • high dimensionality (i.e. a large number of genes) • small sample size Curse of dimensionality! • Methods • Kernel techniques • Data resampling • Gene selection DIMACS Workshop on Machine Learning Techniques in Bioinformatics
Outline • Introduction • Data-dependent Kernel • Results • Conclusion DIMACS Workshop on Machine Learning Techniques in Bioinformatics
Data-dependent kernel model Data dependent Optimizing the data-dependent kernel is to choose the coefficient vector DIMACS Workshop on Machine Learning Techniques in Bioinformatics
Optimizing the kernel • Criterion for kernel optimization Maximum class separability of the training data in the kernel-induced feature space DIMACS Workshop on Machine Learning Techniques in Bioinformatics
The Kernel Optimization In reality, the matrix N0 is usually singular α: eigenvector corresponding to the largest eigenvalue DIMACS Workshop on Machine Learning Techniques in Bioinformatics
Kernel optimization Training data Test data Before Kernel Optimization After Kernel Optimization DIMACS Workshop on Machine Learning Techniques in Bioinformatics
Distributed resampling • Original training data: • Training data with resampling: DIMACS Workshop on Machine Learning Techniques in Bioinformatics
Gene selection • A filter method: class separability DIMACS Workshop on Machine Learning Techniques in Bioinformatics
Outline • Introduction • Data-dependent Kernel • Results • Conclusion DIMACS Workshop on Machine Learning Techniques in Bioinformatics
Comparison with other methods • k-Nearest Neighbor (kNN) • Diagonal linear discriminant analysis (DLDA) • Uncorrelated Linear Discriminant analysis (ULDA) • Support vector machines (SVM) DIMACS Workshop on Machine Learning Techniques in Bioinformatics
Data sets AML Subtypes: ALL vs. AML Status of Estrogen receptor Status of lymph nodal Outcome of treatment Tumor vs. healthy tissue Subtypes: MPM vs. ADCA Different lymphomas cells Cancer vs. non-cancer Tumor vs. healthy tissue DIMACS Workshop on Machine Learning Techniques in Bioinformatics
Experimental setup • Data normalization • Zero mean and unity variance at the gene direction • Random partition data into two disjoint subsets of equal size – training data + test data • Repeat each experiment 100 times DIMACS Workshop on Machine Learning Techniques in Bioinformatics
Parameters • DLDA: no parameter • KNN: Euclidean distance, K=3 • ULDA: K=3 • SVM: Gaussian kernel, use leave-one-out on the training data to tune parameters • KerNN: Gaussian kernel for basic kernel k0, γ0andσare empirically set. Use leave-one-out on the training data to tune the rest parameters. KNN for classification DIMACS Workshop on Machine Learning Techniques in Bioinformatics
Effect of data resampling Lung 181 samples Prostate 102 samples DIMACS Workshop on Machine Learning Techniques in Bioinformatics
Effect of gene selection ALL-AML DIMACS Workshop on Machine Learning Techniques in Bioinformatics
Effect of gene selection Colon DIMACS Workshop on Machine Learning Techniques in Bioinformatics
Effect of gene selection Prostate DIMACS Workshop on Machine Learning Techniques in Bioinformatics
Comparison results BreastER ALL-AML BreastLN Colon DIMACS Workshop on Machine Learning Techniques in Bioinformatics
Comparison results CNS lung Prostate Ovarian DIMACS Workshop on Machine Learning Techniques in Bioinformatics
Outline • Introduction • Data-dependent Kernel • Results • Conclusion DIMACS Workshop on Machine Learning Techniques in Bioinformatics
Conclusion • By maximizing the class separability of training data, the data-dependent kernel is also able to increase the separability of test data. • The kernel method is robust to high dimensional microarray data • The distributed resampling strategy helps to alleviate the problem of overfitting DIMACS Workshop on Machine Learning Techniques in Bioinformatics
Conclusion • The classifier assign samples more accurately than other approaches so we can have better treatments respectively. • The method can be used for clarifying unusual cases • e.g. a patient which was diagnosed as AML but with atypical morphology. • The method can be applied to distinctions relating to future clinical outcomes. DIMACS Workshop on Machine Learning Techniques in Bioinformatics
Future work • How to estimate the parameters • Study the genes selected DIMACS Workshop on Machine Learning Techniques in Bioinformatics
Reference • H. Xiong, M.N.S. Swamy, and M.O. Ahmad. Optimizing the data-dependent kernel in the empirical feature space. IEEE Trans. on Neural Networks 2005, 16:460-474. • H. Xiong, Y. Zhang, and X. Chen. Data-dependent Kernels for Cancer Classification. Under review. • A. Ben-Dor, L. Bruhn, N. Friedman, I. Nachman, M. Schummer, and Z. Yakhini. Tissue classification with gene expression profiles. J. Computational Biology 2000, 7:559-584. • S. Dudoit, J. Fridlyand, and T.P. Speed. Comparison of discrimination method for the classification of tumor using gene expression data. J. Am. Statistical Assoc. 2002, 97:77-87 • T.S. Furey, N. Cristianini, N. Duffy, D.W. Bednarski, M. Schummer, and D. Haussler. Support vector machine classification and validation of cancer tissue samples using microarray expression data. Bioinformatics 2000, 16:906-914. • J. Ye, T. Li, T. Xiong, and R. Janardan. Using uncorrelated discriminant analysis for tissue classification with gene expression data. IEEE/ACM Trans. on Computational Biology and Bioinformatics 2004, 1:181-190. DIMACS Workshop on Machine Learning Techniques in Bioinformatics
Thanks!Questions? DIMACS Workshop on Machine Learning Techniques in Bioinformatics