230 likes | 327 Views
Head lice A Randomised Controlled Trial. Comparing the effectiveness of traditional head lice lotion with the bug-busting method of managing head lice infestation. L Plastow, M Luthra, M Marshall, D Russell, J Wright. Mt. Pleasant Health Centre, Exeter. R Powell, Exeter & N.Devon RDSU.
E N D
Head lice A Randomised Controlled Trial Comparing the effectiveness of traditional head lice lotion with the bug-busting method of managing head lice infestation. L Plastow, M Luthra, M Marshall, D Russell, J Wright. Mt. Pleasant Health Centre, Exeter. R Powell, Exeter & N.Devon RDSU
Aim To compare the effectiveness of traditional head lice lotion (phenothrin) with the bug-busting method of managing head lice infestation
Intervention versus control Control Group Phenothrin: Smell Tolerability Application
Intervention versus control Intervention Group Bug-busting Pack: C.H.C. Combs Conditioner
Context • Setting: Two semi-rural General Practices in East Devon • Participants: 30 children aged 4-16 years randomly assigned to the two intervention groups phenothrin and bug-busting • Ethical approval: granted by Exeter Ethics Committee • Funding: Northcott Foundation
Rationale • Incidence • Reluctance by parents to use traditional lotions • Trust policy- no evidence base • Cost • Changing role of school nurse
Participants 1. Recruitment – school, G.P., Pharmacy 2. Randomisation-children chose sealed envelopes 3. Parents and siblings – data included only if criteria met
Exclusion Criteria • Active symptomatic asthma • Persistent skin disorder of scalp • Treated with head lice lotion within previous 4 weeks • Hair: bleached, permed, coloured • Sensitivity to pyrethroid, organophosphate and or carbon insecticides • Sensitivity to chrysanthemums
Characteristics Treatment GroupBBP Control Group (Lotion) Mean Age 8.1, SD 2.56 9.27, SD 3.95 Sex: Male 4 3 Sex: Female 11 12 No of single child families 4 1 6 5 No with non-infested siblings 5 9 Hair length short 3 4 Hair length to collar 3 5 Hair length below collar 9 6 Baseline Characteristics No with infested siblings in the same household
Main Outcome Measure • Absence of live lice at Day 14
Intervention Control Group • Day 1- Combed dry. • Lice found stuck on CRF. Lotion applied • Day 4- no intervention • Day 7 – as Day 1 • Day 10- no intervention • Day14 Combed dry. • Lice removed stuck on CRF
Intervention Intervention Group • Day 1- Combed dry. Lice found stuck on CRF. Conditioner applied. Combed using BBP • Day 4- Conditioner applied. Combed using BBP • Day 7 – as Day 1 • Day 10- as Day 4 • Day 14 Combed dry. Lice removed stuck on CRF
Statistical Analysis • Intention to treat analysis was conducted using Mann Whitney U test (Non-parametric) for continuous data. • Where there was no evidence of skewness, Chi-squared was conducted for categorical data
Results Day 1 • Children in BBP infested with median of 8 lice at any stage in development compared with a median of 10 in the lotion group. • This difference was not significant (p>.05).
Day Seven Results • Children in BBP were infested with a median of 3 lice at any stage in development compared with a median of 15 in the lotion group. • This difference was significant (p=0.041)
Day Fourteen Results • Children in BBP were infested with a median of 0 lice at any stage in development compared with a median of 5 in the lotion group. • This difference was significant (p=0.008)
Key Findings Intervention Group • Cumulative body count on days 1,7, 14 = 466 • Reducing body count as a result of effective BB Intervention
Key Findings Control Group • Cumulative body count on days 1,7, 14 = 1028 • Increasing body count as a result of egg hatching and reproduction of lice not killed by lotion application
Key Findings Intervention Group • At Day 7 the number of living nymphs was 218 (47%) • At day 14 the number of living nymphs was 29 (6%) (p<0.001)
Key Findings Control Group • At Day 7 the number of living nymphs was 462 (45%) • At day 14 the number of living nymphs was 280 (27%) (p<0.001)
Summary • NNT 2.5 (95% CI: 2.19 to 2.81) • A minimum of two applications of lotion required for clinical effectiveness • The BBP method is likely to be more effective than traditional methods