WS-RF Technical Committee

1. WS-RF Technical Committee May 2005 Face-to-face Agenda

2. Agenda – Monday 16th • 13:00 - Opening remarks, welcome (Chairs) • Roll call • Approve last telecon minutes • Review Action items from last telecon • Call for AOB for this F2F • 13:30 – 14:30 Validate closure of following issues from updated documents (Doc editors) • Docs: WS-Resource, WS-ResourceProperties, WS-ResourceLifetime, WS-BaseFaults, WS-ServiceGroup, AppNotes • (Doc editors to upload new drafts before start of meeting) • 14:30 – 15:30 Issue review (Chairs) • Remaining issues affecting WS-Resource, WSRF-RP, WSRF-RL, WSRF-BF, AppNotes. • Find new editor(s) for AppNotes. • Objective – clear way for editors to produce committee draft and public review draft. • 15:30 – 16:30 (Ian) • Roadmap to OASIS Standard • Committee draft  Public review  Committee specification  OASIS standard • Outline dates for all TC outputs • 16:30 – 18:00 Primer Review (Tim) • Tim to lead review of Primer (to be distributed prior to F2F). • 18:00 – Close

3. Action items • (Bryan) Move issue WSRF109 to open • (Editors) Further call for comments on AppNotes additions document • Further to comments already recv’d • (IanR/TomM) Organise a call on RMD advertise via the TC web site. • (Bryan) move issues WSRF103, WSRF106, WSRF104 to resolved • (Bryan) move issues WSRF105 to open.

4. Agenda – Monday 16th (detail) • 13:30 – 14:30 Validate closure of following issues from updated documents • WSRF107: Consider whether the WS-MessageDelivery embodiment is still needed • Remove WS-MD Emb. • WSRF89: Document-literal serialization • WSRF91: Resource Access Pattern reaction to the removal of ReferenceProperties • WSRF92: Update examples to be compliant with the recent version of WS-Addressing • WSRF99: Examples in the specs use the SOAP 1.2 namespace • WSRF101: Use of non-normative references • WSRF97 QueryResourceProperties WSDL portType does not reference the property it requires as specified in XML schema • WSRF98: Cardinality of SetResourceProperty content • WSRF102: InvalidDeleteResourcePropertiesRequestContent needed • WSRF63: Which lifetime attributes (ala OGSI) should be specified for resource properties • WSRF106: Not clear how to map faults for SOAP 1.1 and SOAP • WSRF22: QNames as attribute values or text nodes is problematic with signatures/encryption and intermediaries • WSRF44: No obvious mechanism to include only members which extend a certain interface • WSRF58: ServiceGroup WSDL does not need imports for WSRF-RL WSDL/schema • WSRF59: Inconsistencies in ServiceGroups • WSRF65: Need a mechanism to aggregate an operation across several resources in a ServiceGroup • WSRF69: Content should be declared with minOccurs="0" • WSRF87: InitialTerminationTime in Add method needs to have stronger guarantee • WSRF104: Content Rule Applies in Two Ways • WSRF111: Missing fault message for unexpected faults • WSRF 112: Dependency on WS-Notification

5. Agenda – Monday 16th (detail) • WSRF100: Confusion about requirement of using WS-BaseFaults for all faults from WS-Resources - See text from Tom. • WSRF103: Multiple Service Port elements legitimate?Need to confirm wsa:Action in WSDL - apps note issue. • WSRF109: Clarify authoritative precedence earlier (Terminology) • WSRF110: BaseFaults does not allow open content • WSRF 113: Correlation between NS and location • NS = http://docs.oasis-open.org/wsrf/rp[w]-1 • WSRF 114: wsa:Action URI for fault messages. • WSRF 115: SG exposure of RP Doc. • WSRF 116: Move embodiment discussion to app notes • Acknowledgments

6. Standards Approval Process • Working draft • any version of a specification or other document produced by the TC which has not yet received any level of approval from the TC. • we used to call these editor drafts. • Committee draft • an interim document approved by a TC • full majority vote of the TC required • no notification to OASIS required • we used to call these working drafts • Public Review Draft • a Committee Draft that has been approved by the TC to go to public review • full majority vote of the TC required • TC Administrator announces on the OASIS members email list • TC Administrator issues a Call For IPR Disclosure. • Public comments addressed to public wsrf-comment list • If changes are required the specification must be withdrawn from review then resubmitted. • The TC may conduct any number of review cycles (i.e. approval to send a Committee Draft to Public Review, collecting comments, making edits to the specification, etc.). • 1st public review of a specification must take place for a minimum of 60 days; any subsequent reviews must be held for a minimum of 15 days. • Committee specification • a Public Review Draft that has completed public review and achieved final approval by a Technical Committee • The TC Administrator conducts a ballot to approve the Committee Specification. • OASIS standard • a Committee Specification that has been submitted by a Technical Committee and reviewed and approved by OASIS membership

7. Agenda – Tuesday 17th • 8:30 – 10:30 ServiceGroup spec (Tom M/Dave S) • Remaining issues affecting WS-ServiceGroup: • WSRF105: ServiceGroupEntry as a WS-Resource is too Heavyweight. • Working session to close down ServiceGroup spec (section by section) to produce committee draft and possibly public review draft. • 10:30 – 12:00 Issues Noon - Lunch (45 mins)12:45 – 15:00 ResourceMetadata spec (Tom M, William V) • Report back on the progress and outcome of the RMD telecon. • Working session to close down RMD spec (section by section) to produce committee draft and possibly public review draft. • 15:00 – 15:30 Roadmap for remaining TC outputs (Ian) • Outline dates to OASIS standard for ResourceMetadata, Primer, AppNotes • 15:30 – 18:00 Break-out sessions • Editors to produce committee draft specifications for:WS-Resource, ResourceProperties, ResourceLifetime, ServiceGroup, BaseFaults, ResourceMetadata, AppNotes, Primer • Editors to prepare public review drafts for:WS-Resource, ResourceProperties, ResourceLifetime, BaseFaults and (if possible) ServiceGroup. • Refresh Requirements document • 18:00 – Close

8. Agenda – Tuesday 17th • 8:30 – 10:30 ServiceGroup spec (Tom M/Dave S) • Remaining issues affecting WS-ServiceGroup: • WSRF105: ServiceGroupEntry as a WS-Resource is too Heavyweight. • Working session to close down ServiceGroup spec (section by section) to produce committee draft and possibly public review draft. • 10:30 – 12:00 Issues (chairs) • Re-review specs from yesterday with updates. Close those issues. • Continue with remaining issues affecting WS-Resource, WSRF-RP, WSRF-RL, WSRF-BF, AppNotes. Noon - Lunch (45 mins) • 12:45 – 13:30 (Ian) • Roadmap to OASIS Standard • Committee draft  Public review  Committee specification  OASIS standard • Outline dates for all TC outputs • 13:30 – 14:00 Primer Review (Tim) • Tim to lead review of Primer (to be distributed prior to F2F). • 14:00 – 15:30 ResourceMetadata spec (Tom M, William V) • Report back on the progress and outcome of the RMD telecon. • Working session to close down RMD spec (section by section) to produce committee draft and possibly public review draft. • 15:30 – 18:00 Break-out sessions • Editors to produce committee draft specifications for:WS-Resource, ResourceProperties, ResourceLifetime, ServiceGroup, BaseFaults, ResourceMetadata, AppNotes, Primer • Editors to prepare public review drafts for:WS-Resource, ResourceProperties, ResourceLifetime, BaseFaults and (if possible) ServiceGroup. • Refresh Requirements document • 18:00 – Close

9. Agenda – Wednesday 18th • 08:30 – 09:30 Approval ballots (Chairs) • committee drafts and public review drafts • 09:30 – 10:00 Follow-on planning (Chairs) • Time and Location for next F2F - 12 or 19 Sep @ Fujitsu UK • 10:00 - 10:30 Primer Review (Tim) • Tim to lead review of Primer (to be distributed prior to F2F). • 10:30 - 12:00 ResourceMetadata spec (Tom M, William V) • Report back on the progress and outcome of the RMD telecon. • 12:00 Close