140 likes | 270 Views
Conducting Surveys at Cornell University. Marin Clarkberg, Associate Director Institutional Research and Planning Yasamin Miller, Director Survey Research Institute. Who We Are. Institutional Research and Planning (IRP)
E N D
Conducting Surveys atCornell University Marin Clarkberg, Associate Director Institutional Research and Planning Yasamin Miller, DirectorSurvey Research Institute
Who We Are • Institutional Research and Planning (IRP) • Within the Division of Budget and Planning; goal to inform institutional decision-making • Administers regular, large-scale surveys to students and other University constituencies • Survey Research Institute (SRI) • Full service survey enterprise at Cornell • Designed, hosted, and analyzed hundreds of surveys for non-profit, government, corporate, and Cornell clients
Rationales for surveys • Why do a survey? • Increasing call to have “real data” and to assess processes and outcomes • Looks easy (and inexpensive… and maybe even fun) • Why not do a survey? • Lots of data is already available • Survey fatigue • Not as easy at it might seem at first • Serious limitations on what survey data can actually tell you about processes and outcomes
Why you shouldn’t:1. Data already exists • Everyone has some data… • Has existing data been thoroughly analyzed and understood? • In addition, the University archives an enormous amount data about students (and other constituencies) • Students’ academic records • IRP Surveys, other surveys
Why you shouldn’t:2. Survey fatigue • Surveys are more common • IRP surveying regularly since 2000 • CIT-hosted surveys, e.g. WebSurveyor: • Over 1600 surveys in 2005-2006 • Survey response rates are down • Senior Survey response rates: 61% in 1998; 50% in 2002; 45% in 2006 • Student (staff, faculty) time is a university resource
Why you shouldn’t:3. There is such a thing as survey expertise • Question design • Bad questions give you bad data • Instrument design • Respondents often bail out of unsatisfactory surveys • Sample design • Samples are often adequate to the task • Sampling saves all kinds of resources
Why you shouldn’t:4. Survey research has major limitations • Ability to generalize with survey data a function of response patterns • Respondents may differ in important ways from nonrespondents • Surveys cannot demonstrate causation
What are the alternatives to surveys? • Ransack existing sources of data • Multiple sources of data help “triangulate” • If nothing else, you can learn more about what you don’t know (and thus what remains to be learned) • Look at alternate modes of collecting data • Some questions better addressed with observation, focus groups, interviews, etc.
So when is a survey appropriate? • Existing data is well-understood • Unanswered questions clearly identified • Scope of survey will minimize the imposition on respondents • As short as possible, asked to as few as possible • Appropriate survey expertise in involved in designing the study • Allow ample time for coordination, consultation, design and pre-testing • Shared understanding of study limitations • Start small and manage expectations
How to Survey • Develop a reasonable timeline • Define your research questions • Design the survey instrument and sampling plan • Develop a data security plan • Notify and secure approvals • Data analysis and reporting
1. Develop a reasonable timeline • Putting questions on the web, collecting responses, and even data analyses are the easy parts • Having established a clarity of task, four to six months is not an unreasonable amount to develop and pre-test a survey instrument
4. Develop a data security plan • Anonymous DataIdentities of respondents are never captured • Fewer data security concerns • Impossible to know who responded (or how often) • Impossible to link survey data with other data sources • Confidential Data • Identities of respondents are kept, but secured • Necessary to have very secure file storage • Possible to link survey data to other data of interest
5. Notify and Secure Approvals • IRP Survey Calendar • Notification courtesy • Institutional Review BoardIf a project is “research” (i.e. develops or contributes to generalizable knowledge), it needs to be reviewed and approved by the IRB. • Data Stewards • Students: the Office of the Registrar • Student and Academic Services • SAS-Research Group
Resources on campus • Find the help you need • Institutional Research and Planning (IRP) • Serves the University • Stewards of much existing student survey data • Available to consult with institutional studies (sampling plans, instrument design and review) • Survey Research Institute (SRI) • Comprehensive survey services from initial planning to data analysis and reporting • IRP uses SRI for survey hosting and administration • Institutional Review Board for Human Participants • First and last authority on mandated review requirements and processes – ask them.