60 likes | 422 Views
Multi-Instance ISIS draft-previdi-isis-mi-mt-01.txt Stefano Previdi - sprevidi@cisco.com Les Ginsberg - ginsberg@cisco.com Mike Shand - mshand@cisco.com Abhay Roy - akr@cisco.com Dave Ward - dward@cisco.com IETF-66 Montreal - July 11, 2006. MI-ISIS Introduction. ISIS extension (YAT)
E N D
Multi-Instance ISISdraft-previdi-isis-mi-mt-01.txtStefano Previdi - sprevidi@cisco.comLes Ginsberg - ginsberg@cisco.com Mike Shand - mshand@cisco.comAbhay Roy - akr@cisco.comDave Ward - dward@cisco.comIETF-66Montreal - July 11, 2006
MI-ISISIntroduction • ISIS extension (YAT) • Allows separate ISIS instances to share nodes and links • Full Topology isolation • Ships in the night approach • Mechanism used to mark packets with instance membership
Update to first version • Dino’s suggestion: • Use of dedicated MAC/Mcast address for MI-ISIS extension • Routers not supporting MI-ISIS extension will ignore packets • Hannes suggestion: work on PDU Version Number • Practically difficult as IETF do not “own” ISIS spec • Door open to many other extension request that would probably indefinitely delay MI-ISIS extension
Update to first version • Possible interoperability issues • Misconfiguration of routers may cause MI-router and non-MI router to flood LSPs • Non-MI-router doesn’t consider IID TLV • Same issue if multiple standard ISIS instances are used and misconfigured • Solution proposed by Les: • Use different System-IDs for different instances
MI-ISIS • Other alternatives have been investigated • New NLPID • New PDU type • New CLNS Header… • IID TLV seems the more straightforward to implement and support • No major interoperability issue • Careful deployment… as usual • Backward compatibility… as usual • Requirement: all routers must support this extension
Multi-Instance ISISdraft-previdi-isis-mi-mt-01.txtStefano Previdi - sprevidi@cisco.comLes Ginsberg - ginsberg@cisco.com Mike Shand - mshand@cisco.comAbhay Roy - akr@cisco.comDave Ward - dward@cisco.comIETF-66Montreal - July 11, 2006