140 likes | 404 Views
SHADOW ECONOMY: THEORETICAL CONCEPT AND METHODS OF QUANTITATIVE EVALUATION. Dinara Peskova, PhD (Econ.), prof. Russia. Essential features of the shadow economy:. Legality degree A dequacy of covering economic activity in official statistics
E N D
SHADOW ECONOMY: THEORETICAL CONCEPT AND METHODS OF QUANTITATIVE EVALUATION Dinara Peskova, PhD (Econ.), prof. Russia
Essential features of the shadow economy: • Legality degree • Adequacy of covering economic activity in official statistics • Agreement/contradiction to the society interests
The most defining economic feature of shadow economy is LACK OF OFFICIAL STATISTICAL CONTROL therefore Shadow economy includes all market-based legal production of goods and services that are deliberately concealed from public authorities
Is shadow economy • structurally independent self-generating system? OR • integral element of the whole economic system?
Methods of measuring the shadow economy • Direct (surveys of citizens and companies, mostly referred to reveal shadow income ) • Indirect (the monetary method; the method of technological indices; the Italian method; balance method; econometric model researches, etc.)
Not a single method of measuring can provide an exact result • Direct methods tend to understatethe results • Indirect methodsoverstate the results *Schneider F., Enste D. (2000) Shadow economies : Size, Causes and Consequences [Текст] // Journal of econ. literature. – Pittsburg. – Vol. 38, №1.
How large is the shadow economy in Russia? • 22% of GDP gives official statics of State Statistical Committee of RF • 40 % of GDP- Ministry of Internal Affairs (Police) RF • 40,6 % of GDP – F. Schneider, A. Buehn, Montenegro (2007) • 50-70 % - evaluations of Russian explorers
Credit market behavior method • we offer to measure the shadow income of the population on the basis of average monthly earnings which are mentioned while taking out a loan • the largest shadow income was observed in the construction sphere (35%), in the sphere of wholesale and retail trade (57%), and in the restaurant business (46%).
Restriction of the method: it covers only that part of population which is in need and can afford taking out a loan (does not include the least and the most well-off social class)