420 likes | 442 Views
English Adjectival Inflection: A radical Radical Construction Grammar Approach. John Newman & Sally Rice University of Alberta CSDL 2006 UC San Diego. Bertrand Russell’s Emotive Conjugations. I’m tenacious you’re stubborn he’s pigheaded. singular. 1 2 3. inflection-specific
E N D
English Adjectival Inflection:A radical Radical Construction Grammar Approach John Newman & Sally Rice University of Alberta CSDL 2006 UC San Diego
Bertrand Russell’s Emotive Conjugations I’mtenacious you’restubborn he’spigheaded singular 1 2 3
inflection-specific adjectival meaning and behavior in English
a radicalRadical Construction Grammar approach language-specific (typologically aware) construction-specific (context sensitive) inflection-specific (lemma sceptical)
a radicalRadical Construction Grammar approach language-specific (typologically aware) construction-specific (context sensitive) inflection-specific (lemma sceptical)
English Adjectival Inflection inflectional periphrastic suppletive positivetall interesting good comparativetallermore interesting better superlative tallestmost interesting best
English Adjectival Inflection –– FACTORS semantics etymology / derivation syllable structure (Quirk & Greenbaum, Kytö & Romaine 1997, Biber et al. 1999 ) phonotactics register / dialect
English Adjectival Inflection –– FACTORS semantics etymology / derivation syllable structure (Quirk & Greenbaum, Kytö & Romaine 1997, Biber et al. 1999 ) phonotactics register / dialect inflectional island effects(Rice & Newman 2005)
Inflectional Islands Syntactic (constructional), semantic, and collocational properties tend to inhere in individual inflections of a lexical item in a register-specific manner. These properties may not extend across all the inflections (the paradigm) to characterize the lemma as a whole.
children tend to use uninflected verb roots before inflected forms verb inflections are mastered on a verb-by-verb basis generalization is gradual initially, particular verbs “strand” inflections adults use particular inflected forms of individual verbs on a register-specific basis verb inflections adhere to verbs on a verb-by-verb basis particularization is gradual eventually, inflections “strand” particular verbs THE VERBISLAND HYPOTHESISTomasello 1992, 2004 THE INFLECTIONAL ISLAND HYPOTHESISRice & Newman 2005 V < < <inflection V> > > inflection
DISTRIBUTION OF SOME BASIC VERBS IN THE BNC BASED ON TAM INFLECTION
IMPLICATIONS OF USAGE-BASED APPROACHES TO GRAMMAR a new starting point for linguistic analysis put lemmas aside (as done earlier with syntactic rule in favor of constructions) substitute words-in-context or WICs (intersection of genre, register, & inflection) a new (lower) level of linguistic generalization find the “hierarchy of lower-level structures...[that] specify the actual array of subcases and specific instances that support and give rise to the higher-level generalization” RWL, Concept, Image, & Symbol, 1991:281-282
WICs locus of lexicalization and grammaticalization active in borrowings and morphological realignment spawn psychological associations, induce priming effects
English Inflected Adjectives as WICs uneven distribution alternate marking newer more new double marking bestest most commonest inflectional gaps sheer *-er sheerest inflectional idiosyncracies irregular semantics collocational preferences of WICs constructional properties of WICs
English Inflected Adjectives as WICs uneven distribution alternate marking newer more new double marking bestest most commonest inflectional gaps sheer *-er sheerest inflectional idiosyncracies irregular semantics collocational preferences of WICs constructional properties of WICs
Our focus here 1. Inflectional idiosyncracies (relative frequencies) 2. N collocates 3. A collocates 4. Constructions
4. Misc. constructions with A, Aer, Aest It is _____ to...
4. Misc. constructions with A, Aer, Aest It is _____ to...
4. Misc. constructions with A, Aer, Aest It is _____ to...
4. Misc. constructions with A, Aer, Aest A-er than NORM
4. Misc. constructions with A, Aer, Aest A-er than NORM
a radical RCG approach to English adjectival inflection A and A A-er and A-er more A and more A A-est and A-est most A and most A even A-er even more A A-er N more A N A-est N most A N N be A-er N be more A N be A-est N be most A
A radical RCG approach to allows us to leave the paradigm behind.Paradigms (lemmas) have value for some purposes, but they often end up straight-jacketing an analysis.The conceit of the paradigm tends to dull our interest in looking at the lexical semantics of inflected forms in their own right (cf. the Russellian conjugations).Some items do escape the shackles of the paradigm and actually become lexical items in their own right.
A radical RCG approach to allows us to leave the paradigm behind. • Paradigms (lemmas) have value for some purposes, but they often end up straight-jacketing an analysis. • The conceit of the paradigm tends to dull our interest in looking at the lexical semantics of inflected forms in their own right. • Some items do escape the shackles of the paradigm and actually become lexical items in their own right (cf. the Russellian conjugations).