1 / 16

FINANCIAL INTEGRATION

FINANCIAL INTEGRATION. Paula Garrido Mirat. Background. H igh levels of financial integration a hundred years ago. British investment in Argentina, Australia, Canada and US between 1865 and 1890 went mostly into railroads and government bonds. Obstacles for investing abroad then.

mercury
Download Presentation

FINANCIAL INTEGRATION

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. FINANCIAL INTEGRATION Paula GarridoMirat

  2. Background • High levels of financial integrationa hundred years ago. • British investment in Argentina, Australia, Canada and US between 1865 and 1890 went mostly into railroads and government bonds.

  3. Obstacles for investing abroad then • INFORMATION PROBLEMS • Communications technology of the day • Asymmetric information • CONTRACTING PROBLEMS • US laws VS. Britain laws • MACROECONOMIC RISKS • Exchange rate risk • Unstable and uncertain monetary and fiscal policies • ACCOUNTING PROBLEMS

  4. Information problems • Communications technology of the day: • Transatlantic cable (1860) • Time for cable transmission less than a minute by 1914 • Equalization in prices in different places of the world

  5. Information problems • Information asymmetry: • Adverse selection • Disproportionate share of railway bonds in foreign investment portfolios • Family groups and merchant and investment banks • Freestanding companies for FDI

  6. Contracting problems • Uncertainty of legal security of the claims of foreign investors in the US was an issue for British investors • The US prohibited foreigners from serving as directors of the corporations chartered there • Freestanding companies were very trusted then because they were subject to British law.

  7. Macroeconomic Risks • British investors viewed securities issued by countries not on the gold standard riskier than those of the countries that were. • Loans to countries with a fluctuating standard value commanded significantly higher interest rates

  8. Absence of adequate accounting standards • Suggestion to create generally accepted accounting principles • British investors insisted on the transfer to the US of accounting practices accepted in Britain • Need for regulatory intervention: Interstate Commerce Commission for the railroads until the Securities Exchange Commission • British accountants set up practice in the US from the mid-19th century

  9. Financial integration now • Deeper and broader economic integration • More complexity of financial markets • More regulation • More financial innovations • Improvements in communication • Bankruptcies, scandals and fraud still there

  10. Problems. The Enron scandal • INFORMATION PROBLEMS • Still asymmetry information • Hidden information • DEREGULATED MARKETS • California deregulated the energy market • RISKS • Credit rating agencies • Enron´s sophisticated financial risk management tools • ACCOUNTING AND AUDITING • Arthur Andersen downfall with the scandal

  11. Information problems • Failed investments • ENRON formed partnerships to hide $500 Million in company losses • People continued buying ENRON stocks and the price didn’t go down • NO INFORMATION OF THE REAL STATUS OF THE COMPANY

  12. Deregulated markets • 1996: California deregulated the energy market in order to increase competition • Market manipulations and illegal shutdowns • State of emergency in January 2001 • ENRON saw opportunity to make money to cover their huge losses: TAKE ADVANTAGE OF THE DEREGULATED MARKET IN CRISIS • Government regulated the market: no more opportunity to make money for ENRON • ENRON announced its first losses in more than four years

  13. Macroeconomic risks • Credit agencies: • They were giving Enron the highest qualifications, when Enron was facing huge losses, which prevented their stock price from falling. • They downgraded Enron´s credit rate too late, when it was already bankrupt. • ENRON´s sophisticated financial risk management tools • Enron's bankruptcy downfall was attributed to its reckless use of derivatives and special purpose entities

  14. Accounting and auditing • ENRON succeeded in hiding some important facts, such as off-book liabilities, from banks and shareholders • ENRON's auditor´s firm, Arthur Andersen, was accused of applying reckless standards in its audits because of a conflict of interest over the significant consulting fees generated by ENRON • Arthur Andersen fell with the Enron´s fall • ENRON was attributed as the biggest audit failure in history

  15. COMPARISSONS After more than a century, similar problems to those that faced British investors still exist but in a more complex and integrated financial system: • Asymmetry information: the investors (now and then) didn’t have all the real information of the economic status of the company, despite the improvements in communication technologies • British investors and ENRON company also took into account the laws in different places in order to choose the best apparent investment opportunity • Even though there have been many improvements in risk management, sometimes it is very hard to measure it • Distinction between the auditor´s inspective function and the accountant´sanalytical function emerged in the 20th centurybut it doesn´t prevent conflict of interests

  16. Conclusion • INFORMATION IS THE KEY ELEMENT IN AN INVESTMENT • THERE WILL ALWAYS BE COMPANIES AND PEOPLE THAT WILL HAVE OTHER INTERESTS • MORE REGULATION CAN HELP BUT WON´T SOLVE THE PROBLEM COMPLETELY

More Related