220 likes | 303 Views
News from search for steady-sources analysis. Juan Pablo Gómez González. ANTARES Collaboration Meeting Strasbourg, November 2011. OUTLINE. Introduction: Search method description Simulation of pseudo-experiments Results: Performance Response to different source morphologies
E N D
News fromsearchforsteady-sourcesanalysis Juan Pablo Gómez González ANTARES Collaboration Meeting Strasbourg, November 2011
OUTLINE Introduction: Search method description Simulation of pseudo-experiments Results: Performance Response to different source morphologies Event-by-event angular resolution Conclusions/Outlook 2 News from search for steady-sources analysis J.P. Gómez-González ANTARES C.M Strasbourg Nov. 2011
CHARGE CALIBRATION Likelihood implementation: Numerical maximization with Tminuit MGRAD 3 News from search for steady-sources analysis J.P. Gómez-González ANTARES C.M Strasbourg Nov. 2011
Likelihood Simulate higher number of pex to improve 5sigma level statistics (tail of the distribution) 4 News from search for steady-sources analysis J.P. Gómez-González ANTARES C.M Strasbourg Nov. 2011
Likelihood It also find (aproximatly) the number of injected events 5 News from search for steady-sources analysis J.P. Gómez-González ANTARES C.M Strasbourg Nov. 2011
Gaussianshape Different source extensions wrt the ANTARES PSF (s) 6 News from search for steady-sources analysis J.P. Gómez-González ANTARES C.M Strasbourg Nov. 2011
Response About 70% worst power for a 1º extended source 7 News from search for steady-sources analysis J.P. Gómez-González ANTARES C.M Strasbourg Nov. 2011
Discoverypotential Simulating signal events around the source following a 2D gaussian, or using the actual detector PSD Maximum effect on DP is only of ~5% Conclusion: our PSF is well described by a 2D Gaussian 8 News from search for steady-sources analysis J.P. Gómez-González ANTARES C.M Strasbourg Nov. 2011
Flat disc sourceshape Response to a different source shape: -> Signal events are simulated following a flat disc 9 News from search for steady-sources analysis J.P. Gómez-González ANTARES C.M Strasbourg Nov. 2011
CHARGE CALIBRATION Better performance for a flat disc source -- Gaussian shape -- Disc shape Explanation: Events are more concentrated in the peak(remove of the gaussian tail) events) ??? 10 News from search for steady-sources analysis J.P. Gómez-González ANTARES C.M Strasbourg Nov. 2011
RXJ1713 • Real case: Applied to RXJ 1713 morphology • To be done if Aart can provide me the 2D histogram for the • Pseudo-experiments generation 11 News from search for steady-sources analysis J.P. Gómez-González ANTARES C.M Strasbourg Nov. 2011
E-M comparison Results and comparison when using the E-M algorithm In progress… 12 News from search for steady-sources analysis J.P. Gómez-González ANTARES C.M Strasbourg Nov. 2011
Methodscomparison EM shows a better performance when extension of the source is higher than ~1 degree (wrt to the ANTARES PSF) 13 News from search for steady-sources analysis J.P. Gómez-González ANTARES C.M Strasbourg Nov. 2011
Event- Separating high energy events from low energy ones Separating well reconstructed events from badly reconstructed Angular error between reconstructed tack ant true neutrino direction for different range of the angular uncertainty estimate 14 News from search for steady-sources analysis J.P. Gómez-González ANTARES C.M Strasbourg Nov. 2011
Angular error estimate The angular uncertainty for each reconstructed track in the sample used is draw from the “beta” distribution 15 News from search for steady-sources analysis J.P. Gómez-González ANTARES C.M Strasbourg Nov. 2011
Angular error estimate Discovery potential when using (or not) the estimate on the angular uncertainty About 7% improvement on 3sigma (50% CL) discovery potential 16 News from search for steady-sources analysis J.P. Gómez-González ANTARES C.M Strasbourg Nov. 2011
Comparisons 17 News from search for steady-sources analysis J.P. Gómez-González ANTARES C.M Strasbourg Nov. 2011
FeldmanCousinsbelt Better performance than the EM method, which also finds the correct sigma Note that method B was ran over a larger sample (higher bghigher number of signal events to reach same discovery potential 18 News from search for steady-sources analysis J.P. Gómez-González ANTARES C.M Strasbourg Nov. 2011
FeldmanCousinsbelt Discovery potential at two confidence limits: 3 2.7 nsig 5 5.2 nsig (To have 50% probability of a discovery) 19 News from search for steady-sources analysis J.P. Gómez-González ANTARES C.M Strasbourg Nov. 2011
Fittedsignalevents Finds the correct number of signal events injected 20 News from search for steady-sources analysis J.P. Gómez-González ANTARES C.M Strasbourg Nov. 2011
FeldmanCousinsbelt Find where is the problem with it… 90% CL 68% CL 21 News from search for steady-sources analysis J.P. Gómez-González ANTARES C.M Strasbourg Nov. 2011
CONCLUSIONS Work in progress: -- 22 Calibration systems of the ANTARES NT. J.P. Gómez-González VLVnT, Erlangen 2011