210 likes | 234 Views
PETROLEUM PIPELINES BILL. Arthur Dykes Consultant. WHITE PAPER ON ENERGY POLICY (December 1998). “Government will promote competition in the transport of liquid fuels.”
E N D
PETROLEUM PIPELINES BILL Arthur Dykes Consultant
WHITE PAPER ON ENERGY POLICY (December 1998) • “Government will promote competition in the transport of liquid fuels.” • “The petroleum regulatory regime will inhibit monopolistic abuse of pipelines and storage facilities. Pipelines will be required to provide non-discriminatory open access to uncommitted capacity, transparency of tariffs, and disclosure of cost and pricing information to a suitable authority.”
GENERIC PROVISIONS (1) • 67% of the Gas Act is directly applicable to the Petroleum Pipelines Bill • 78% of the Petroleum Pipelines Bill could be taken from the Gas Act with very minor changes for context • Non-generic provisions are found mainly in definitions, license conditions and regulations
GENERIC PROVISIONS (2) • Private companies could deal with gas, electricity and petroleum pipelines Acts • Substantive, style & word differences on the same issues in the 3 Acts will lead to confusion e.g. review/appeal, transparency • Cabinet decision on single regulator could mean an interim common regulator administering the 3 Acts
GENERIC PROVISIONS (3) Recommendations • Distinguish between changes in the 2 Bills from generic issues in the Gas Act that: • Merely reflect personal preferences of style and wording – reject • Lower standards - reject • Are well-motivated and positive - accept
NON-GENRIC DEFINITIONSLoading, Pipelines, Storage • Will a third party be able to use uncommitted capacity to import petroleum and petroleum products at non-discriminatory tariffs and conditions? • The key is that the loading facilities and pipelines, with associated storage facilities, are a continuous system, notwithstanding ownership
OBJECTS OF ACT • The regulatory philosophy is the same as in the Gas Act, so most of the objectives are generic but: • The order has been changed • Some objectives omitted e.g. equitable basis • Security has been added
PROVISIONS RELATING TO THE AUTHORITY Section 4 – Powers and Duties • Format changed (two sub-sections) • This section lists the main functions, not an exhaustive list of all functions • Compared with the Gas Act: • Some functions have been deleted e.g. remedial action • Others have been added e.g mediators
PROVISIONS RELATING TO THE AUTHORITY Section 4 (continued) • Competition Commission: • Negotiate agreement • Right to participate in Authority’s meetings • Give and receive advice • Review legislation and regulations
PROVISIONS RELATING TO THE AUTHORITY Section 4 (continued) • Health, Safety and Environment • Incorporation by referral • ASME plans and procedures • Security • Plan based on the National Key Points Act, 1980 (Act No 102 of 1980);
PROVISIONS RELATED TO THE AUTHORITY Section 6 - Appointment • Word and style changes • Provisions omitted: • State employers (referee and player) • Requirements relating to spouse, life partner, child, business partner or associate or employer
PROVISIONS RELATED TO THE AUTHORITY Sections 7, 8 and 9 • Minor word and style changes • Perhaps “meeting” should be defined? Section 10 • Provision for decisions to be taken under review by High Court omitted
PROVISIONS RELATED TO THE AUTHORITY Section 12 (Funds) & 13 (Accounting) • Provision made for donations Section 14 • Changes mean that two reports must be submitted and that the Authority loses discretion on additional content
LICENSING Sections 15,16, 17, 18 and 19 • Basically the same as the Gas Act except that: • Minister’s power to direct criteria for licenses deleted, including the disposal of state assets obtained in this way
CONDITIONS OF LICENCESection 20 • Separate accounting and management may be required • Existing State controlled entities operated as common carriers with phase-in period of: • 5 years for existing contracts • 180 days if capacity not used
CONDITIONS OF LICENCESection 20 • Private entities and state entities’ new pipelines have choice of: • Common carrier • TPA for uncommitted capacity • TPA for loading and storage facilities • Negotiated changes for pipelines and loading and storage facilities at own cost
CONDITIONS OF LICENCESection 20 • Tariffs set by Authority for pipelines • Tariffs approved by Authority for loading facilities and storage facilities • Authority may set standards or incorporate other legislation by reference for: • Construction, operation, health, safety, environment and security
LICENCE PROVISIONS Section 22 (term of licence) • New provisions • Automatic renewal only if licence conditions have been complied with • Specifying new owner must apply for new licence - see section 24 (1) (c) Section 23 (amendment of licence) • New provision – in case of an emergency
LICENCE PROVISIONS Section 25 (contraventions) • New provision – appeal to High Court • Section 35 (3) (o) of the Constitution ensures the right of every accused person the right of appeal or review by a higher court • Section 10 (3) of the Gas Act (omitted in this Bill) gave the right of review to decisions of the Regulator
LICENCE PROVISIONS Section 28 (setting and approval of tariffs) • As for section 33 (1) (f) (regulations) • Tariffs to be determined by methodology prescribed by regulation • Review by Authority on own initiative or on request by the licensee
GENERAL COMMENTS • National Gas Regulator (the Regulator), Petroleum Pipelines Regulatory Authority (the Authority) and National Electricity Regulatory Authority (regulatory authority) • “Prescribed by regulation” or “prescribed by rule” seems unnecessary as there is no discretion as to content of rules