1 / 9

Alexander Spermann, ZEW European Conference on Long-term Care 21 October 2005

Discussion of Roland Eisen‘s 10 Years Long-Term Care Social Insurance in Germany: What Economists expected, what happened and what we learned for the future design. Alexander Spermann, ZEW European Conference on Long-term Care 21 October 2005. AOK. Disincentive I. Heterogeneous LTC insurers

myrna
Download Presentation

Alexander Spermann, ZEW European Conference on Long-term Care 21 October 2005

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. Discussion of Roland Eisen‘s10 Years Long-Term Care Social Insurance in Germany: What Economists expected, what happened and what we learned for the future design Alexander Spermann, ZEW European Conference on Long-term Care 21 October 2005

  2. AOK Disincentive I Heterogeneous LTC insurers but unitary contribution rate 1.7% • no competition between public insurers • no incentives for public insurers to produce LTC efficiently

  3. Disincentive II Dual system LTC-SI for employees with gross income below Y* higher risk contribution rate1.7 % of Yg Private LTC for self-employed, public officers, and high income earners above Y* low risk individual premium ≤ 1.7 % of Yg

  4. Disincentive III home care Level I Level II Level III nursing home care • Disincentive to switch to nursing home, especially for level I and II • But preference of frail elderly to stay at home

  5. III I II Disincentive IV No incentive for nursing home owners to help frail elderly to reach lower care levels

  6. Alternatives (German discussion) 1. Abolition of private LTC • Proposal of incumbent and future health minister, Ulla Schmidt (SPD) • intensely discussed: use 14 billion € savings of the private LTC insurance companies to finance the public insurance deficit

  7. 2. Slow transition from public LTC to private LTC • Proposal of majority of health economists in Germany • Insurance obligation for everyone • Risk premium according to age and sex like status quo in private LTC insurance • But insurers have to accept frail elderly • Supplementary tax financed transfers for low-income earners

  8. 3. Moderate reform within LTC-SI • Proposal of some German economists • Abolition of care level I or convergence of payments between home care and nursing home care • More competition between public insurers

  9. 4. Integration of LTC and health insurance • Proposal of some economists 5. Abolition of LTC, back to 1993 • No proponents

More Related