1.03k likes | 1.19k Views
Zone and Polygon Menus:. Shengdong Zhao Maneesh Agrawala Ken Hinckley. Using Relative Position to Increase the Breadth of Multi-Stroke Marking Menus. Marking Menus. Compound-stroke Marking Menus [Kurtenbach and Buxton, 1993]. Compound-stroke Marking Menus. Novice Mode.
E N D
Zone and Polygon Menus: Shengdong Zhao Maneesh Agrawala Ken Hinckley Using Relative Position to Increase the Breadth of Multi-Stroke Marking Menus
Marking Menus Compound-stroke Marking Menus [Kurtenbach and Buxton, 1993]
Compound-stroke Marking Menus Novice Mode
Compound-stroke Marking Menus Novice Mode Expert Mode
Compound-stroke Marking Menus Novice Mode
Compound-stroke Marking Menus Novice Mode Expert Mode
Compound-stroke Marking Menus Advantages [Kurtenbach and Buxton, 1993] Seamless novice to expert transition 3.5 x faster than linear menus Scale invariance =
Compound-stroke Marking Menus Limitations – Error Rate [Kurtenbach and Buxton, 1993] Breadth/depth & speed/accuracy trade-off 8
Compound-stroke Marking Menus Limitations – Error Rate [Kurtenbach and Buxton, 1993] Breadth/depth/speed/accuracy trade-off 8x8 8
Marking Menus Compound-stroke Marking Menus [Kurtenbach and Buxton, 1993] Multi-stroke Marking Menus [Zhao and Balakrishnan, 2004]
Multi-stroke Marking Menu Novice Mode
Multi-stroke Marking Menu Novice Mode Expert Mode
Multi-stroke Marking Menu Novice Mode
Multi-stroke Marking Menu Novice Mode Expert Mode
8x8x8 Multi-stroke Marking Menus Advantages [Zhao and Balakrishnan, 2004] Faster, more accurate Space efficient Increase hierarchy depth
8 Multi-stroke Marking Menus Limitations Breadth limit remains
Observations – Word Menu File: 15 Submenu Items
Observations – Word Menu Tools: 17 Submenu Items
Observations – Word Menu Average breadth: 13.7 items Minimum breadth: Window (4 items) Maximum breadth: Tools (17 items)
Save Grp 1 Grp 8 Grp 2 Grp 7 Grp 3 Grp 6 Grp 4 Save As Grp 5 Limitations - Breadth Expert Novice Save Group 2 Level-2 Level-1
length q = orientation position origin Geometric Design Space
length q = orientation position origin Geometric Design Space
q = orientation position origin Geometric Design Space
q = orientation position origin Geometric Design Space Compound-stroke Marking Menus Multi-stroke Marking Menus
q = orientation position origin Geometric Design Space Compound-stroke Marking Menus Multi-stroke Marking Menus
q = orientation position origin Geometric Design Space Compound-stroke Marking Menus Multi-stroke Marking Menus Orientation-based Marking Menus
q = orientation position origin Geometric Design Space
Relative Position Input Area
Relative location + orientation Input Area Scale Independent
Relative location + orientation Input Area Scale Independent
Polygon Menu Input Area Orientation-based Polygon
Polygon Menu Input Area Orientation-based Polygon
Polygon Menu Input Area Orientation-based Polygon
Polygon Menu Input Area Orientation-based Polygon
Polygon Menu Input Area Orientation-based Polygon
Polygon Menu Input Area Orientation-based Polygon
Polygon Menu Input Area Orientation-based Polygon
Polygon Menu Input Area Orientation-based Polygon
Polygon Menu Input Area Orientation-based Polygon
Polygon Menu Input Area Orientation-based Polygon
Polygon Menu Input Area Orientation-based Polygon
Polygon Menu Input Area Orientation-based Polygon
Zone vs. Polygon • Stroke directions Zone