1.27k likes | 1.44k Views
Oxygen / ventilatory support in COPD. University Medical Centre Groningen The Netherlands. OXYGEN. MEDICATION. LTX. Severe COPD. LVRS. VENTILATORY SUPPORT. REHABILITATION. OXYGEN. MEDICATION. LTX. Severe COPD. LVRS. VENTILATORY SUPPORT. REHABILITATION. 100. 90.
E N D
Oxygen / ventilatory support in COPD University Medical Centre Groningen The Netherlands
OXYGEN MEDICATION LTX Severe COPD LVRS VENTILATORY SUPPORT REHABILITATION
OXYGEN MEDICATION LTX Severe COPD LVRS VENTILATORY SUPPORT REHABILITATION
100 90 NOTT 80 19 hrs 70 MRC 60 Cumulative Survival % 50 15 hrs 12 hrs 40 No Oxygen 30 20 10 0 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 Time (months) 203 subjects randomized to continuous or 12 hours of oxygen for at least 12 months 87 subjects randomized to oxygen 15 hours/day or none Composite slide NOTT and MRC studies
Dynamic Hyperinflation in COPD • Increases work of breathing from added elastic loads • Respiratory muscles at a mechanical disadvantage • Contributes to the sensation of dyspnea with increasing inspiratory pressures
3 32 14 30 12 2.5 28 10 2 26 Inspiratory capacity (L) Respiratory rate (breath/min) Endurance time (min) 8 24 1.5 6 22 1 4 20 0.5 2 18 0.2 0.3 0.5 0.75 1.0 0.2 0.3 0.5 0.75 1.0 0.2 0.3 0.5 0.75 1.0 FiO2 FiO2 FiO2 Effect of Oxygen in 10 Non-hypoxemic Patients with Severe COPD, During Constant Work Modified from Somfay A, ERJ 2001;18:77
Reduces ventilation Reduces air trapping Reduces hyperinflation Relieves dyspnea Increases exercise Improves health-related quality of life Medical Volume Reduction with Oxygen
-50 0 50 Favours placebo Favours oxygen Systematic Review of RCT’s of Short Term Benefit of Ambulatory Oxygen in COPD Exercise capacity – Endurance distance
Supplementary Oxygen and Exercise • Strong laboratory support for oxygen improving exercise, by decreasing ventilation • Funding criteria vary among jurisdictions • Few controlled trials of oxygen during exercise training
700 600 500 400 6MWD (m) 300 200 100 0 Air Oxygen Supplemental Oxygenin hypoxemic COPD Rooyackers J, ERJ 1997;10:1278
Supplemental Oxygen in hypoxemic COPD Garrod et al Thorax 2000;55:543
70 60 Work Rate (Watt) B 50 A 40 30 20 0 5 10 15 20 Training Sessions Supplemental Oxygen in Non-hypoxemic COPD Emtner M, AJRCCM 2003;168
Supplemental Oxygen in Non-hypoxemic COPD • Oxygen room air Emnter. AJRCCM 2003;168:1034
Supplemental Oxygen in Non-hypoxemic COPD Emnter. AJRCCM 2003;168:1034
Conclusion • LTOT is life saving for those with resting hypoxaemia • Ambulatory oxygen should increase mobility for those who require LTOT, but the evidence to support this is incomplete • Oxygen for exercise training reduces ventilation and may enable training at a higher load.
OXYGEN MEDICATION LTX Severe COPD LVRS VENTILATORY SUPPORT REHABILITATION
Chronic ventilatory support in COPD • Why should we start NIPPV in COPD ? • What is the evidence ? • New studies
Sleep hypothesis Meecham Jones et al.1995:152:538-544
Hyperinflationhypothesis Diaz et al. ERJ 2002;20:1490
Study FEV1 PaCO2 BIpap Effects Strumpf 1991 0.54 49 15/2 Psych. Meecham Jones 1995 0.86 56 18/2 QOL Gasex. Sleep Gay 1996 0.68 55 10/2 = Casanova2000 0.85 51 12/4 Psych. Dysp. Short term randomised controlled trials
Study FEV1 PaCO2 BIpap Monitoring Strumpf 1991 0.54 6.5 15/2 no Meecham Jones 1995 0.86 7.4 18/2 ETCO2 Gay 1996 0.68 7.3 10/2 no Casanova2000 0.85 6.7 12/4 No Randomised controlled trials
Chronic ventilatory support in COPD • Why should we start NIPPV in COPD ? • What is the evidence ? • New studies
OXYGEN LTX NUTRITION COPD LVRS NIPPV + REHABILITATION
Ventilatory support during exercise Oxygen Ventilation Dreher ERJ 2007;29:930
Ventilatory support during exercise Dreher ERJ 2007;29:930
OXYGEN LTX NUTRITION COPD LVRS NIPPV + REHABILITATION
Nocturnal NIPPV in stable COPD Randomisation NIPPV 12 weeks 12 weeks NIPPV + PR 3 months Baseline Measurements PR Measurements Measurements Duiverman ATS 2008 abstract
Assessed for eligibility (n= 87) Not meeting inclusioncriteria (n= 15) Randomised (n =72) Allocated to rehabilitation (n=35) Allocated to NIPPV + rehabilitation (n= 37) Early drop-outs (n=6) - 2 died - 2 withdrew - 2 other diseases Run in Baseline Baseline measurements (n = 35) Baseline measurements (n = 31) Drop-outs (n=7) - 5 intolerance to NIPPV - 1 noncompliant rehab - 1 died Drop-outs (n=3) noncompliant 3 months Analysed (n= 32) Analysed (n = 24)
15000 * 12500 10000 Daily step count (steps/day) 7500 5000 2500 0 Baseline After 3 months Rehabilitation NIPPV + Rehabilitation Activities in daily livingSteps/day
Chronic ventilatory support in COPD • No strong evidence to provide ventilatory to patients with COPD routinely. • Ventilatory support during exercise might improve its effects, although more studies are needed • Nocturnal ventilatory support improves the effects of rehabilitation in hypercapnic COPD patients.
Muscle resting hypothesis Diaz et al. ERJ 2002;20:1490
Nocturnal NIPPV and daytime exercise training <-------- P <0.009 -------- > < P<0.01> Garrod et al.AJRCCM 2000:162:1335
Shuttle walk test <-------- P <0.009 -------- > < P<0.01> Garrod et al.AJRCCM 2000:162:1335
OXYGEN LTX NUTRITION COPD and hypercapnia LVRS NIPPV + REHABILITATION
Inclusion criteria • COPD • FEV1< 50% pred. • symptoms : dyspnoea on exertion / impaired exercise tolerance • Age < 75 years • PaCO2> 45 mmHg
Exclusion criteria • Any diagnosis interfering with a successfull rehabilitation • OSAS : AHI > 10 • Currently on NIPPV • Within last 2 years started a rehabilitation programma
Design (1) • Randomised open trial • 2 arms : NIPPV + rehabilitation (A) rehabilitation alone (B) • Duration : 24 months
Design (2) 0 inclusion / randomisation 3 m control period 3 m A : start NIPPV and after 2 weeks rehab B : start rehabilitation 6 m end of clinical / outpatient rehab 6m start follow-up rehabilitation community
Effect-parameters • Primary health related quality of life • Secundary dyspnoea ADL activities PSG gasexchange EMG respiratory muscles freq./duur opnames exacerbations freq. exercise tolerance
MEASUREMENTS CONTROL CLINICAL COMMUNITY 0 3 6 12 24 HRQL dyspneu ADL PSG BGA EMG SWT LF HRQL dyspneu ADL BGA EMG SWT LF HRQL dyspneu ADL BGA EMG SWT LF HRQL dyspneu ADL PSG BGA EMG SWT LF HRQL dyspneu ADL PSG BGA EMG SWT LF
Discussion • No clear evidence for rationale of NIPPV • Effect of NIPPV still controversial • What did we learn ? • Level of hypercapnia • Adequate ventilatory support / monitoring • What kind of research is needed in COPD ?