1 / 13

Chapter 24 …And Rarely Just Illness

Chapter 24 …And Rarely Just Illness. 6 th 9/28/11 Isoke Burnett. A Quote from HTRLLAP. “The unnamed young narrator mentions that his old friend and mentor, a priest, is dying. There is no hope… A priest with no hope?” (Foster 213). …And rarely just illness.

neviah
Download Presentation

Chapter 24 …And Rarely Just Illness

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. Chapter 24…And Rarely Just Illness 6th 9/28/11 Isoke Burnett

  2. A Quote from HTRLLAP • “The unnamed young narrator mentions that his old friend and mentor, a priest, is dying. There is no hope… A priest with no hope?” (Foster 213).

  3. …And rarely just illness • Foster begins the chapter using an excerpt from a book about a boy who examines a priest dying and not even God can save him. • It seems to be a contradiction to what a priest preaches and that God is all-powerful and can save anyone, even a priest.

  4. …And rarely just illnessCont’d • This story was used to set-up the chapterwhich introduces the reader to ways in which literature wrote about diseases. • What is interesting about the literature is that not only did the writers lacked knowledge about maladies but doctors lacked knowledge as well.

  5. Foster’s Four Principles • According to Foster, there were four principles governing the use of disease in works of literature: • Not all diseases are created equal. • It should be picturesque. • It should be mysterious in origin. • It should have strong symbolic or metaphorical possibilities.

  6. Not All Diseases Are Created Equal • Foster argues that Tuberculosis took precedent over other diseases like syphilis, gonorrhea, and cholera among writers because it was safer in terms of perceptionsabout the diseases. • For example, prostitutes only got venereal diseases and cholera was such a nasty and gross way to die. • Tuberculosis was “public relations” friendly.

  7. It Should Picturesque • Foster argues that while TB is a deadly illness, there is a certain acceptance as to how one looks when they are suffering from it as opposed to the other diseases. • For example, Foster described the look of a TB sufferer as, “the skin becomes almost translucent, the eye sockets dark, so that the sufferer takes on the appearance of a martyr in medieval paintings” (p. 216).

  8. It Should Be Mysterious In Origin • Foster argues that TB was a clear choice for writing about the mysterious disease because of the description I provided in an earlier slide, “medieval painting.” • For example, no one really knew what caused TB or how one would acquire it but, it was very clear how one could obtain a venereal disease which was through sexual transmission and that was morally unacceptable during those times.

  9. It Should Have Strong Symbolic Or Metaphorical Possibilities • Tuberculosis could easily be described metaphorically because the death was slow and the body did not display signs of disfigurement. • Whereas, other diseases modifiedthe appearance of the body which made it difficult to use “positive” metaphors to describe it. • For example, TB was described as, “wasting away.”

  10. Comparing Tuberculosis and HIV/AIDS In Literature • I will take a look at the four principles governing the uses of diseases in the works of literature as it relates to HIV/AIDS • Not All Diseases Are Created Equal. • AIDS/HIV was separated from Syphilis and Gonorrhea in the 1980’s because it was considered a “Homo-sexual” disease. If you obtained VD, you may have contracted from your “heterosexual” partner. • It Should Be Picturesque. •Writers would promote the fact that it was only “Homo-sexual” men who were contracting the disease. It took years to conclude that “heterosexuals” were contracting it as well. • It Should Be Mysterious in Origin. • It came from an undeveloped country??? The disease came from an animal??? • It should have strong symbolic or metaphorical possibilities. •Heterosexuals didn’t want to be perceived as homosexuals so metaphors were used to describe HIV/AIDS.

  11. ● Illness is reflected in the novel Great expectations. ●After Magwitch dies Pip catches a fever statingthat—”I ought rather to write that I should have been alarmed if I had any energy and concentration enough to help me to the clear perception of any truth beyond the fact I was falling very ill” indicates that pip was ill, and wasn’t really able to focus (Dickens 491). http://www.lucreid.com/wp-content/uploads/2010/10/great-expectations.jpg

  12. How “….And rarely just illness” relates to everyday life in general • Cancer as an example relates to this chapter by being perceived as not so negative as it really is. • Usually, the doctors would say “you would have 6 months to live” rather than “6 months until you’ll die”, which is metaphorically turned around. • In movies, Cancer’s perspectives are usually lightly negative, but rarely you would see the movie getting deeper into the situation.

  13. WORKS CITED • Dickens, Charles. Great Expectations. New York: Bantam Dell, 1986. Print. • Foster, Thomas C. How to read literature like a professor. New York: Harper-Collins Publishers, Inc., 2003. Print. • Publisher’s Weekly, 2008

More Related