Heating Showdown: Tubular Heaters vs. Cartridge Heaters – Unveiling the Key Diff

1. Heating Showdown: Tubular Heaters vs. Cartridge Heaters – Unveiling the Key Differences NexThermal Mfg (I) Pvt Ltd

3. Tubular Heaters vs. Cartridge Heaters Heating elements are essential components in many industrial processes and commercial appliances. Two of the most common electric heating elements are tubular and cartridge heaters. While both serve the purpose of converting electrical energy into heat, there are some key differences between the two that impact their optimal applications and performance.

4. Overview of tubular and cartridge heater designs Tubular heaters consist of a metal tube (usually stainless steel or alloy steel) that contains a coiled heating wire. The tube protects the wire and provides efficient heat transfer. Cartridge heaters have a cylindrical shape but lack an outer metal sleeve. Instead, the heating element wire is insulated with magnesium oxide and enclosed in a stainless-steel sheath. This allows insertion into drilled holes.

5. Some key physical differences between the two: • Tubular heaters consist of a metal tube surrounding a heating coil. • Cartridge heaters have an insulated heating wire pressed into a metal sheath. • Tubular heaters can be much longer than cartridge heaters. Tubes over 36 inches are common. • Cartridge heaters are limited to shorter lengths, typically under 16 inches. • Tubular heater diameters range from 0.25 inch to 2 inches. Cartridge diameters span 0.25 inch to 1 inch. • Tubular heaters can handle higher wattage densities than cartridge heaters. Now that we’ve compared the basic designs let’s look at how these physical factors influence the performance and applications of tubular and cartridge heaters.

6. 1. Temperature capabilities: Key performance differences • The maximum temperature a heater can reach depends on the materials used in its construction. • Tubular heaters made from steel alloy tubes can withstand temperatures up to 1400°F. Stainless steel tubes allow temperatures up to 1600°F. • Cartridge heaters typically max out at lower temperatures, around 750°F for stainless steel sheathed heaters. However, Incoloy sheathed cartridge heaters can reach 1200°F. • The ability to handle higher temperatures makes tubular heaters better suited for processes like heat-treating metals, preheating combustion air, and maintaining molten polymers. • Cartridge heaters are often selected when temperatures below 1000°F are needed, such as warming adhesives or heating diesel fuel.

7. 2. Watt density and wattage output: • Watt density refers to the number of watts dissipated per square inch of heater surface area. A higher watt density means more watts can be packed into a smaller space. • The tubular design allows tubular heaters to achieve watt densities over 100 w/in2. Cartridge heaters typically max out around 60 w/in2. • Higher watt densities enable tubular heaters to deliver more power overall. Tubular heaters are available for over 70 kW, while most cartridge heaters top below 2 kW. • When high heat output is required in a compact area, tubular heaters have the advantage. Cartridge heaters are often favored for lower-wattage applications

8. 3. Duty cycle rating: • A heater’s duty cycle describes how long it can operate at full-rated power without overheating. This is expressed as a percentage or minutes per hour. • Tubular heaters often have a 100% continuous duty cycle rating, meaning they can run steadily at full power. • Cartridge heaters are only rated for intermittent operation, around 25% duty cycle. This equates to 15 minutes per hour at full-rated wattage. • The tube metal in tubular heaters provides a more effective dissipation of heat generated by the internal coil. The compact cartridge design lacks this additional heat-sinking ability. • For applications requiring constant heating, tubular heaters are the better choice. Cartridge heaters work well for short-burst heating needs.

9. 4. Robustness and durability: • The metal tube encasing the heating element makes tubular heaters durable and resistant to damage. They can withstand harsh industrial environments and vibration without failure. • Cartridge heaters lack an outer metal sleeve, making the heating wire vulnerable. Care must be taken to avoid crushing the cartridge or exposing the internal coil. • Tubular heaters also handle high-pressure washdown and moisture better. Their screen barrier helps prevent water ingress. Cartridge heaters rely on potting compounds and seals to protect the element. • Tubular heaters are often preferred for critical applications where ruggedness and reliability are priorities. Cartridge heaters may make sense for gentler low-pressure uses.

10. 5. Flexibility and shape options: • Tubular heaters are produced in straight or bent tubes, allowing some flexibility in shape. But they are still essentially limited to a cylindrical form. • Cartridge heaters can be manufactured in straight, L-shaped, and helical coiled designs. This allows cartridges to fit unique spaces and wrap around components. • When flat or contoured heating surfaces are needed, cartridge heaters provide more variability. Tubular heaters offer simplicity and consistency in basic tube shapes.

11. 6. Cost considerations: • Tubular heaters generally have a higher upfront cost than comparable cartridge heaters. The metal tube adds material and manufacturing costs versus cartridge heaters. • However, the higher duty cycles and lifetimes achieved with tubular heaters can lead to lower operating costs in the long run. The increased robustness also means fewer unexpected failures and less downtime. • Cartridge heaters provide a lower initial price point but may need replacement more frequently. Determining the total cost of ownership helps identify the better value.

12. Typical applications and uses 1. Tubular heaters applications 2. Cartridge heater applications • Heating liquid baths and tanks • Maintaining molten metals like zinc, tin, and bitumen • Preheating combustion air for ovens and furnaces • baking and drying ovens • Plastic injection molding nozzles and barrels • Gas line and pipe heating • Industrial process heating • Diesel fuel heating • Adhesive melting pots • Hot stamping tools • Medical equipment sterilization • Food service equipment warming • Shrink wrap machines • Packaging equipment, seaming tools

13. Installation and maintenance Proper installation and maintenance help ensure optimal performance and lifetime for tubular and cartridge heaters. Here are some best practices: For tubular heaters: • Ensure heater tubes are properly inserted into bored holes. Use thermal grease to aid conduction. • Avoid bending tubes tighter than the minimum recommended bend radii. • Use insulated power leads rated for max temperature and wattage. • Allow space for air circulation around the heater body. • Check for leaks and inspect for damage during routine maintenance.

14. For cartridge heaters: • Never insert cartridges beyond the recommended insertion depth. • Apply thermal paste inside holes to maximize contact. • Secure cartridge flanges with plates or collars when possible. • Using short power leads to minimizing the heating of wires. • Ensure wet or high moisture conditions are avoided. • Check cartridge seals and terminals during routine maintenance. Adhering to manufacturers’ recommendations can maximize heater lifespan and safety.

15. Choosing between tubular and cartridge heaters When selecting a heating element for an application, consider these key factors: • Required power output and temperature rating • Available space and shape needs • Duty cycle and longevity demands • Environmental and safety concerns Tubular heaters tend to be better choices for applications like: • High temperature (above 750°F) heating • Continuous, intensive industrial processes • Large tanks and baths needing high watt densities • Harsh, high-moisture environments

16. Cartridge heaters offer advantages for: • Compact spaces requiring short heating elements • Lower temperature (below 750°F) intermittent uses • Custom shapes and sizes • Cost-sensitive, replaceable applications Of course, many factors beyond those compared here may apply to specific heating situations. Working with a qualified heating element supplier is the best way to ensure you get the right tubular or cartridge heater for your unique needs.

17. Conclusion Tubular and cartridge heaters provide localized heat for various industrial and commercial applications. Understanding the key differences in their construction and performance allows selecting the right heater for optimal results and cost-effectiveness. Tubular heaters offer high temperatures, watt densities, and durability in basic cylindrical shapes. Cartridge heaters provide more flexibility and lower costs for intermittent lower-temperature uses. With careful selection, installation, and maintenance, tubular and cartridge heaters can provide long-lasting, efficient heating solutions.

18. Contact us: Media Contact : Company name : INexThermal Mfg (I) Pvt Ltd Website : https://www.nexthermal.in/ Email : sales@nexthermal.in Facebook : https://www.facebook.com/NexThermalMfg Linkedin:https://www.linkedin.com/company/nexthermal-mfg-i-pvt-ltd- Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/nexthermal_/ Twitter: https://twitter.com/nexthermal_