160 likes | 281 Views
Shaping a Constructive Regulatory Environment. Greg Carter 9 th June 2010. Agenda. How does Regulation impact ratings?. 5 Key areas of analysis. Conclusion. Agenda. How does Regulation impact ratings?. 5 Key areas of analysis. Conclusion. Analytical Methodology. Source: Fitch. 3.
E N D
Shaping a Constructive Regulatory Environment Greg Carter 9th June 2010
Agenda How does Regulation impact ratings? 5 Key areas of analysis Conclusion
Agenda How does Regulation impact ratings? 5 Key areas of analysis Conclusion
Analytical Methodology Source: Fitch 3
Methodology – Where does Regulation sit? Source: Fitch 4
Methodology – What does Regulation influence? Source: Fitch 5
Agenda How does Regulation impact ratings? 5 Key areas of analysis Conclusion
1) Expected Regulatory Solvency Position Solvency Ratios From QIS4 Compared With Solvency I Source: CEIOPS QIS4 final report
2) Sources of Additional Capital Capital Shortfalls in QIS4, Selected Countries Source: CEIOPS QIS4 final report
3) Options for Reducing Capital Requirements QIS4 Solvency Capital Requirement (SCR) Composition Source: CEIOPS QIS4 final report
Interest rate risk Equity risk Property risk Spread risk Concentration risk Currency risk Less diversification (%) 160 140 120 100 80 60 40 20 0 -20 -40 -60 Non-life Life Composites 3) Options for Reducing Capital Requirements (cont) QIS4 Composition of Required Capital for Market Risk Source: CEIOPS QIS4 final report
4) Own Funds composition & Allowance for Hybrids • Tier 1 or Tier 2? • Grandfathering? • Longer term impact on Financial Flexibility
5) Internal Model Use • “Solvency II compliance” • The Use Test • Partial model • Comparability and Transparency
Agenda How does Regulation impact ratings? 5 Key areas of analysis Conclusion
Conclusion • QIS 5 brings some clarity, but the picture is still not clear • QIS 5 results will bring the capital landscape into focus • Regulatory capital is one part of our Capital Adequacy analysis • Capital Adequacy is one part of our Credit Rating