1 / 20

THEME : Judicial Protection of Intellectual Property Rights in Hong Kong

Mainland, Hong Kong SAR and Macau SAR Intellectual Property Symposium 2003 China Intellectual Property Training Center, Beijing. THEME : Judicial Protection of Intellectual Property Rights in Hong Kong. ~ By C. K. Kwong ~ Sit Fung Kwong & Shum http://www.sfks.com.hk.

norina
Download Presentation

THEME : Judicial Protection of Intellectual Property Rights in Hong Kong

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. Mainland, Hong Kong SAR and Macau SAR Intellectual Property Symposium 2003China Intellectual Property Training Center, Beijing THEME : Judicial Protection of Intellectual Property Rights in Hong Kong ~ By C. K. Kwong ~Sit Fung Kwong & Shumhttp://www.sfks.com.hk

  2. I. Brief Outline of the Present Judicial Procedures A. Civil Procedures Cease and Desist Letter  demands: - an undertaking not to infringe - delivery up - disclosure of past dealings - payment of damages - contribution of legal costs

  3.  Less due diligence before action to save costs Legal Action in the Civil Court  writ  Statement of Claim”  Ex-parte Injunction  Anton Piller K G v. Manufacturing Process Ltd. [1976] CH.55 (CA)

  4.  Interlocutory Injunction American Cyanamid v. Ethicon  Defence  Reply  Other interlocutory applications - further & better particulars, interrogatories, security for costs  Summons for Directions - evidence - trial  Summary judgment

  5. Costs  hourly rates (barrister) HK$2,500 per hour from a reasonably competent junior counsel to HK$8,000 per hour for a Senior Counsel  Solicitors hourly rate ranges from HK$1,000 to HK$4,500  Usually costs recoverable is approximately 60% to 70% of actual amount spent  Difficult to estimate costs. It depends on how aggressive will the litigation be conducted by the parties.

  6. B. Criminal Procedures and Remedies  Copyright Ordinance  Trade Descriptions Ordinance  Judicial Trend

  7. II Reform on Civil Procedure Rules Consultation Paper  “Civil Justice Reform : Interim Report and Consultative Paper” November 2001  report on other relevant jurisdictions, review the Hong Kong situation

  8.  formulate proposals for reform  The Woolf reforms in England used as a frame work  Aim to address problems of expense, delay, complexity and inequality in resources  New system be just, fair, efficient, user friendly, economical and practical  80 proposals put forward

  9. Common Complaints  Too expensive  Too slow  Lack of equality  Too uncertain  Too complicated  Misuse of adversarial system  Take up disproportionate judicial resources

  10. Themes for possible reforms  Proportionality  Re-defining procedural requirements  Encouraging earlier settlement  Limiting interlocutory application  Giving court greater case management  Minimising hearings  Introducing costs transparency  Exploring use of voluntary ADR

  11. Comments from Lord Woolf himself  The idea of proportionality. More complex procedures for more complex case. Small disputes should have simple, cheap and speedy procedure  go to the court only as a last resort  No. of cases dropped by one-third  Court only encourage alternative dispute resolution but cannot order it

  12.  Problems include - Balancing between certainty and flexibility - Controlling costs while encouraging lawyers to incur expenses before litigation starts I.e. “front loading” - inconsistencies in the application of the broad powers  won’t degenerate into a trial by expert instead of trial by judge  principles would be applicable in Hong Kong

  13. The Hong Kong Law Society’s Position  The Chief Justice’s Working Party looked at the system from the top down. The Law Society looked at it from bottom up  The Woolf Reform is not a panacea to the costs and delay problems  Keep the existing rules Acknowledged that litigation in Hong Kong is costly and time consuming. That could be due to other reasons  Proposed that pleadings should be “enhanced”

  14.  Positive and substantive grounds of defence should be put forward  The wide ambit of Peruvian Guano test should apply in discovery of documents  There are pros and cons with active case management by the court  Different judges making different and inconsistent decisions is even worse

  15. The Intellectual Property Practitioner’s View Point  Need to be more efficient and less expensive  Generally, the reforms should be supported  The following proposals are useful - adoption of pre-action protocols - favours specialisation

  16. - pleadings to be verified - offer for settlement at any stage - case management, time tabling and milestones - Special List - limited discovery  Compulsory mediation may not be practical for counterfeiters  In other infringement cases, mediation may be useful where IP specialist are available

  17.  Summary assessment of costs may be adopted providedit does not replace a detailed cost analysis in appropriate cases  Court should have control on the scope and use of expert evidence  A Code of Conduct for expert witnesses should be introduced  Welcome solicitors and barristers (i) to disclose to their clients basis of their charges (ii) to provide best estimates

  18.  A new set of rules rather than piecemeal amendments  Essential to have -adequate judicial and court resources -training programmes to familiarise judges and other court staff with reforms, development of computerised system to perform case-flow management, resource allocation and management statistic function

  19. The Working Party is to provide their final report by the end of this year

  20. ~ Thank You ~

More Related