E N D
1. Biodiesel - “Fat to Fuel” Environmental Partnerships –Past, Present, Future Olof Hansen
Waste Management Division
April 2007
2. 2 Contents Part 1
Why waste-derived biodiesel?
Part 2
Past Successes and Learning Lessons
Part 3
Ongoing Projects and Future Goals
3. 3 Part 1 Why waste-derived biodiesel? “To EPA, environmental stewardship means everyone taking responsibility for environmental quality in every aspect of our lives – in our jobs, at home, and in our communities.” “It represents a natural evolution in our thinking about the environment – from pollution control, to pollution prevention, to sustainability.” EPA Administrator Johnson from the same speech.“To EPA, environmental stewardship means everyone taking responsibility for environmental quality in every aspect of our lives – in our jobs, at home, and in our communities.” “It represents a natural evolution in our thinking about the environment – from pollution control, to pollution prevention, to sustainability.” EPA Administrator Johnson from the same speech.
4. 4
“Biodiesel is one of our nation's most promising alternative fuel sources. And by developing biodiesel, you're making this country less dependent on foreign sources of oil.”
President George W. Bush
Remarks at Virginia Biodiesel Refinery May, 2005
5. 5 Benefits of Waste Derived Biodiesel Reduces waste
Protects our environment
(air, water, waste)
Saves costs
Protects workers
Promotes renewable energy
Creates a sustainable market
6. 6 “Advanced Energy Initiative: national goal of replacing more than 75 % of our oil imports by 2025…
Biodiesel will help end dependency on foreign oil …
Foreign oil will go the way of typewriter and walkman…
Restaurant grease which would normally be thrown away, will be turned into fuel…
Biodiesel is making the black puff of diesel smoke a thing of the past. “
Administrator Steve Johnson
Remarks at National Biodiesel Conference
San Diego, February 2006
7. 7 Why Focus on Waste Cooking Oil? Resource Conservation Challenge (RCC)
Reduce waste, and reuse and recycle more products
Recover energy lost in waste going to landfills
U.S. alone: Restaurants and hotels generate 3 billion gallons of waste cooking oil annually
Traditionally grease goes to rendering industry
8. 8 How can Biodiesel Solve Waste and Water Pollution Problems? By converting waste grease to a higher value commodity.
Diverts large waste stream from:
Landfills or illegal dumping
Publicly-owned treatment works (POTWs)
Prevents spills and sewer blockages:
80% of sewer spills in the USA are caused by
FOG (Fat – Oil - Grease)
In 2001, EPA sued Los Angeles for 800 sewer spills,
due to pipes clogged by FOG
9. 9
10. 10 Emission Change between Biodiesel and Petrodiesel
11. 11 Biodiesel’s Effect on NOx Emissions
12. 12 Why is R9’s Waste Management Division Working on Biodiesel? Biodiesel derived from waste grease helps meet national and regional goals for our division
National GPRA goals
35% Recycling rate of MSW
Pollution prevention measures in goal 5
Meet RCC objective to conserve energy and resources
Regional niche
No agricultural crop for biodiesel such as soybean fields as in the Midwest, but lots of urban crop: restaurant grease and other waste grease!
Over 10 million gallons of grease in SF Bay area alone!
13. 13 What are the Economic Benefits?
14. 14 Can Biodiesel Replace Petro-Diesel?
15. 15 How do you Make Biodiesel (C15H31CO2CH3) ? Transesterification
Transesterification is a chemical process that converts oil and fats to their methyl esters for fuel purposes. Glycerin is removed from vegetable oil to make it thinner and less viscous.Transesterification is a chemical process that converts oil and fats to their methyl esters for fuel purposes. Glycerin is removed from vegetable oil to make it thinner and less viscous.
16. 16 Little Known Fact Dr. Rudolph Diesel designed
the diesel engine in 1894 to run on peanut oil
“The use of vegetable oils for
engine fuels may seem
insignificant today. But such
oils may become in the
course of time as important as
petroleum and the coal tar
products of the present time.”
17. 17 Federal Environmental and Energy Conservation Requirements/Incentives IRS, provides for fuel tax credits and refunds of 50 cents/gallon of Biodiesel
http://www.irs.gov/publications/p378/ar01.html
EPAct (Energy Policy Act of 2005), requires alternative fuel vehicles for all public fleets
RCRA 6002, requires federal agencies that generate heat, mechanical, or electrical energy to use fuels derived from solid waste
Executive Order 13101, greens the government through waste prevention, recycling, and federal acquisition
E.O. 13134, develops and promotes bio-based products and bio-energy
E. O. 13423, strengthening Federal environmental, energy, and transportation management
18. 18 Benefits of Biodiesel Environmental (Air, Water, Waste)
Energy Independence (Domestic, Renewable)
Economic/Cost (Waste to Fuel)
Quality/Standards
Energy Policy Compliance
Safety/Emergency Response
19. 19 Summary of Environmental Benefits of Biodiesel Waste reduction/diversion from landfills
Resource conservation: waste to fuel conversion
Currently only alternative fuel passed Clean Air Act Tier I and II health effects testing
Reduction of virtually all regulated air emissions
Over 75% reduction of green house gases
Non-toxic, contains no sulfur: the cause of acid rain
Bio-degradable, no oil spill contamination
20. 20 Obstacles to Biodiesel Acceptance Quality of fuel
Limited supply
Due to both demand and supply reasons
Potential increase of NOx emissions
Depends on engine type and test settings
Lack of familiarity
21. 21 Part 2 FY06 Successes “To EPA, environmental stewardship means everyone taking responsibility for environmental quality in every aspect of our lives – in our jobs, at home, and in our communities.” “It represents a natural evolution in our thinking about the environment – from pollution control, to pollution prevention, to sustainability.” EPA Administrator Johnson from the same speech.“To EPA, environmental stewardship means everyone taking responsibility for environmental quality in every aspect of our lives – in our jobs, at home, and in our communities.” “It represents a natural evolution in our thinking about the environment – from pollution control, to pollution prevention, to sustainability.” EPA Administrator Johnson from the same speech.
22. 22 Created Web-based Biodiesel Guide for Federal Facilities Launched biodiesel guide for federal facilities on Federal Network for Sustainability in Sep 2006
Summer intern wrote guide
Guide was featured among others on the White House OFEE webpage
Heavily used resource: 450 unique hits/month First, the Energy Policy Act of 1992 (EPAct), P.L. 102-486, requires agencies meeting certain criteria to reduce their federal vehicle fleets’ reliance on petroleum. By 2005, these fleets must decrease annual petroleum consumption by 20 percent over 1999 consumption levels. One of the ways agencies may achieve this goal is by relying on biodiesel for their diesel fuel needs. Under the EPAct, the purchase and use of 450 gallons of biodiesel (B20) is considered the equivalent of acquiring one alternative fueled vehicle.
Second, the April 21, 2000 Executive Order 13149 ''Greening the Government Through Federal Fleet and Transportation Efficiency" directs federal agencies to exercise ''leadership in the reduction of petroleum consumption through improvements in fleet fuel efficiency and the use of alternative fuel vehicles (AFVs) and alternative fuels." E.O. 13149 requires agencies to develop compliance strategies, one component of which may be use of biodiesel. First, the Energy Policy Act of 1992 (EPAct), P.L. 102-486, requires agencies meeting certain criteria to reduce their federal vehicle fleets’ reliance on petroleum. By 2005, these fleets must decrease annual petroleum consumption by 20 percent over 1999 consumption levels. One of the ways agencies may achieve this goal is by relying on biodiesel for their diesel fuel needs. Under the EPAct, the purchase and use of 450 gallons of biodiesel (B20) is considered the equivalent of acquiring one alternative fueled vehicle.
Second, the April 21, 2000 Executive Order 13149 ''Greening the Government Through Federal Fleet and Transportation Efficiency" directs federal agencies to exercise ''leadership in the reduction of petroleum consumption through improvements in fleet fuel efficiency and the use of alternative fuel vehicles (AFVs) and alternative fuels." E.O. 13149 requires agencies to develop compliance strategies, one component of which may be use of biodiesel.
23. 23 Biodiesel Research at University of Nevada in Reno Managed IWG Grant with Chemical engineering department with 2 goals:
lower NOx emissions in pre-production ways (w/o additives)
decrease costs by continuous production unit vs. batch process
Grantee produced several promising results, already:
Biodiesel production takes far less time and energy than found in previous studies
Nitrogen content of biodiesel is over 40% lower than previous research has shown
24. 24 Community Biodiesel Business Model in Santa Cruz, California Oversaw IWG grant with Ecology Action (NGO)
Cradle-to-cradle market model
Unique partners: local restaurants, hauling companies, diesel manufacturers, fuel distributors, City and County
Plans to divert 100,000 gallons of waste cooking oil from landfills to fuel public fleet
25. 25 Collaboration with San Francisco In 2005, responded to request from SF Department of the Environment on waste derived biodiesel project
Assisted SF in development of biodiesel plan by working with diverse, unconventional stakeholders: SF Environment, solid waste recycling section, grants office, SFPUC, Biofuels Co-op, MUNI, city college, consultant
IN 2006, convened meetings at EPA and made them aware of WCC RFP
Met during RFP process to assist w/ grant process
Successful grant application means that SF is the largest city in the US to convert its municipal fleet to biodiesel
Part of Mayor’s goal to convert whole city fleet to B20 by the end of 2007 (8 million gallons of diesel/year)
26. 26 Cooperation of Air and Waste Div. through West Coast Collaborative (WCC) Added a cleaner fuel section to trucking, marine, agriculture, rail, and construction work groups
Grant RFP contained cleaner fuel (biodiesel) section
Results for Biodiesel in RFP:
27 out of 56 proposals focus on Biodiesel
Half of money requested ($10 Million) was for Biodiesel
Our convening efforts resulted in at least 8 WCC proposals
2 biodiesel projects were selected and are being funded
27. 27 WCC Biodiesel Grant Proposals City College of San Francisco
Clean Cities Coalition in Honolulu
City of Pacifica POTW
EBMUD on-site biodiesel production
Greener Oakland fuels initiative
Port of LA biodiesel infrastructure
Car-Lite (Construction) in Sebastopol
Juneau mobile mini-refinery
28. 28 Partnership with Casinos on Biodiesel Replicate successful Resource Conversation Fund grant with the Gila River Indian Community project “From Frybread to the Fuel Tank” with other R9 Tribes
Presented on biodiesel at “Greening Tribal Casinos” workshop in Sacramento
Work with Pomo Tribe and biodiesel vendor
Initiate partnership with Quartz Tribe
Coordinated with ORD Las Vegas lab and biodiesel vendors using Casino grease in Las Vegas
29. 29 Part 3 FY07 Goals “To EPA, environmental stewardship means everyone taking responsibility for environmental quality in every aspect of our lives – in our jobs, at home, and in our communities.” “It represents a natural evolution in our thinking about the environment – from pollution control, to pollution prevention, to sustainability.” EPA Administrator Johnson from the same speech.“To EPA, environmental stewardship means everyone taking responsibility for environmental quality in every aspect of our lives – in our jobs, at home, and in our communities.” “It represents a natural evolution in our thinking about the environment – from pollution control, to pollution prevention, to sustainability.” EPA Administrator Johnson from the same speech.
30. 30 Biodiesel FY07 Goals Launch our R9 Biodiesel webpage, up and running since January 2007
http://www.epa.gov/region9/biodiesel
Target institutions with existing drivers, and
where supply and demand are co-located
where large supplies of used cooking oil exist, and
where project can be scaled up or replicated
such as
wastewater treatment plants
universities/colleges
Tribal or commercial casinos
food processing industry
31. 31 Partnership Opportunities with Waste Water Treatment Plants in FY07 Potential Partners
EBMUD (Non-funded WCC Project)
Convert FOG to fuel for trucks on-site
Cal FOG (State professional association, meeting in fall)
Share waste-to-fuel message w/ state-wide group
Pacifica (Non-funded WCC Project)
FOG to biodiesel and NOx emission reduction technology
8 Marin POTWs (FOG assessment study)
Where from, how much, where to feasibility study
32. 32 Current Collaborations with Wastewater Treatment Plants As follow-up to WRPPN conference, approached CalFOG (POTW association) to view biodiesel as a solution to FOG
Meeting in October at LA Sanitation District
Assist EBMUD with project demonstrating the benefits and cost effectiveness of biodiesel as a clean, renewable alternative fuel from brown grease
Non-funded WCC grant
Explore partnership w/Eastern Municipal Water District (California’s 5th largest water district) looking at biodiesel as a source reduction project
33. 33 Partnership Opportunities with Universities in FY07 Potential Partners
University of California Office of the President (UCOP)
UC system wide sustainable transportation project
Biodiesel for individual campus fleet managers
Unfunded WCC UC-Davis project
San Francisco City College
WCC project, PR event in March
Lots of partners, City, grease hauler, petroleum industry, consultant
Los Angeles Community College
Beneficial Use Summit partner, cross partnership
Model for other community colleges
34. 34 Ongoing collaborations with UC Office of the President Contacted individual campuses of UC system
Spoke at UC system-wide sustainability conference
Met w/ some UC fleet managers
Launched sustainable transportation project
Will meet w/ UC fleet managers in October
Will formalize program through UCOP
35. 35 Partnership Opportunities with Casinos in FY07 Potential Partners
Tribal Casinos
Hopland Pomo and Sho-Kah-Wah Casino
UN-R IWG Project and Washoe Tribe
Quartz Valley Tribe in N. California
Outreach at R9 Tribal Conference in November
Commercial Casinos
Finish EPA ORD LV lab project
Duplicate Reno casinos project of using used cooking oil in furnaces and boilers
36. 36 Other Biodiesel Partnership Activities Planned for FY07 Explore biodiesel projects for:
Ports
Intermodal use between vessels to rail and road
High priority for RA
Greening DOD
Expand US Navy B20 policy to other branches and other federal facilities
Hawaii and other Pacific Islands
Create energy independence and local cradle-to-cradle markets
Superfund and Corrective Action cleanup sites (“Cleanup and clean air”)
Requirement for contractors to use B20 in equipment
Food Processing Industry
Large users of frying oil and large fleets at same location
US-Mexico border
Nogales fire department grant to collect grease
Supplemental Environmental Projects (SEP)
Biodiesel as fuel for RCRA violator, modeled after Region 1
37. 37 Thank you