1 / 31

MH-12: Breaking Hold of the Trenches 1918

MH-12: Breaking Hold of the Trenches 1918. Breaking the Hold of the Trenches – 1918 Strategic Overview. Nov –Dec 1917: prospects looked bad for Allies: Russia soon collapsed after Battle of Riga Italian Army routed at Battle of Caporetto

omer
Download Presentation

MH-12: Breaking Hold of the Trenches 1918

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript


  1. MH-12: Breaking Hold of the Trenches1918

  2. Breaking the Hold of the Trenches – 1918Strategic Overview Nov –Dec 1917: prospects looked bad for Allies: Russia soon collapsed after Battle of Riga Italian Army routed at Battle of Caporetto Unrestricted SS warfare taking severe toll on Brits Germans also developing improved infiltration tactics: Confirmed effective at Caporetto & Eastern Front Potential for application on Western Front Impact on Battlefield if proved correct? Mobility and possible breakthrough But window of opportunity was closing rapidly: Time to exploit this opportunity was running out – why?

  3. Unfulfilled Expectations & Domestic Discontent • Impact of growing German domestic discontent & unrest: • Food shortages, Naval mutinies, & political strikes; • Motivation for German military leaders to end war: • Search for strategy & tactics to achieve victory • Impact of German success on Eastern Front: • What treaty resulted & what was its initial impact?* • Heightened expectations of ?________ ________Treaty: • Hopes for relief – increased foodstuffs & raw materials • Unfortunately for Germans – + fall significantly short • Result? Impact on German people? • ?___________________ => increased pressure to end war

  4. Ludendorff’s Strategic Aim • Ludendorff’s growing power, agenda, & strategy: • By late 1917 – Ludendorffdominates German Gov. • (Doctrines of von Clausewitz are stood on their head): • Now Political officials are subordinated to Military • Mons Strategy meeting (Nov’17) – • Ludendorff presides: • Sets agenda - Goal: strategy for major military victory • Strategic aim: prove to allies US can’t help them: • Assumption: US arrival will be too late & won’t matter • Take action to convince allies military success unlikely • Persuade the allies to this conclusion & decide: • Stop the war & negotiate a peace settlement

  5. 1918 Spring Offensive Objectives • Tactical &operationalmotives? Overall strategic aim? • Ludendorff convinced major offensive needed: • Reverse German despair & restore fighting spirit • Drives decision for major offensive in spring 1918: • Packaged as series of assaultsat various times & points • Ludendorff’s tactical & operational motives: • 1. Restore battlefield ?_____________ • 2. End static trench stalemate on Western Front • Germany’s Operational strategy & overall strategic aim: • 1. ?_____________ the French & British allies • 2. Drive ?_____________ from the war • 3. Force ?_____________ to give up & negotiate a settlement

  6. Initial Operational Objectives • Initial Operational Objectives (focused in ?_____________): • Aim: Sever BEFfrom their LOC to Channel with Britain • Impact of tacticalconcerns force Operational changes: • Weather, terrain, & enemy force dispositions; • Flanders: rains soak terrain – must delay attack until May • Arras: too well defended to penetrate; • Above concerns drive search for more vulnerable pointfor assault: • Somme (to South) appears most vulnerable- why? • BEF (5th Army)looks ?___________ & unprepared with weak defense lines

  7. Adjusted Operational Strategy • Operational Strategy modified: • Drive wedge between Brits & French • In and around St. Quenton & Cambrai • Divert attention away from prime AOobjective: Flanders • Operational and Strategic Objectives: • Push Brits to English Channel (Operational) • Force them out of War (Strategic) • Tactical considerations & logistic requirements: • Adequate assault forces & equipment a must in order to prevail: • Requires Force build up: from 150 to 192 divisionson Western front • Also requires necessary arms, equipment, & supplies for support • Observation - for Ludendorff: • Tactical considerations drive military strategy • Just as – Military Strategy drove Germany’s policies • The very reverse of von Clausewitz’s assertion=> • i.e. war is an extension of politics by other means…

  8. New Infiltration Tactics • To accomplish the desired breakthrough: • New innovative assault tactics were essential • Military’s extensive review: • Focus: innovative assault methods • Goal: breakthrough=> restore mobility to the battlefield • Result: “Attack in Position Warfare” – ground breaking tactical study • What was the new tactic used for infiltration? • New German tactical assault innovations: • Small ?___________ unitswith extensive C2 latitude (SOF) • By pass strong resistance points of enemy • Push forward as far as possible • Tactical objective? • Mission of follow-on units? –clean up strong points left behind by SOF • Mission of Reserve units– exploit ?____________- how? • Fire support: mobile mortars &followin-depth artillery fire w/rolling barrage • Pulkowski method: Predicted fires w/improved maps: • Major emphasis onSurprise • Hurricanes of fire? Enemy’s ?__________ ?______ ______ _________ bombardment

  9. New Infiltration Tactics - C2 • Leading from the front: • New location of Division Commanders? ?_____________ • Exacting training, exercise, live fire rehearsals: • 56 division specially trained • Doctrine as guide for aggressive initiative • Rehearse & exercise as you would fight: • No simulation – what you see you’ve got • Live fire exercise a must • Beginning of special ops tactics for May 1940 • These new tactics to be employed in Spring 1918: • Beginning at the Somme when 3 German armies strike

  10. 1st Battle Offensive -1918: The Somme • 3 German Armies attack into Somme area • British 3rd & 5th -spread out: • German 17th on right, 2nd in Center, 18th on left; • 21 March 1918: 0440=> Arty Prep starts: Arty, gas, smoke, HE shells • 0940=> rolling barrage begins • 32 infantry divisions follow in wake • Additional 28 infantry divisions follow • Tactical Objective: • Brit artillery 5 miles to rear; • 18th reaches most objectives by dusk; • 17th meets stiff resistance from Brit 3rd Army

  11. 1st Battle Offensive: results • Ludendorff decides to reinforce which Army? • 18th advances fwd 35 miles/captures Montdidier by D+6 • Then Ludendorff halts offensive - why? • 18th overextended, out of supplies, exhausted; • Transportation problems (trains & Arty) • Reserves & support can’t keep up • Lack of troop discipline (like at Shiloh - troops pillage supplies) • Allies rapidly reinforce defenders by rail LOCs • Result: Germans fail to breakthrough– significance? • Tactical success (35 miles), but Operational failure • NTL – allies severely shaken – impact on Allies? • Allies meet in late March to strengthen their ?______________ • Especially at the operational level=> objective?*

  12. Allied Unity of Command • Improved C2 unity made after Russia’s collapse & Caporetto’s rout • Allies commit to formal C2 system: • Coordinate strategy • Form Supreme War Council: • Comprised of national & military leaders • Also form board of military reps: • Task: “watch” day to day ops – but its effectiveness was mixed • Furthermore Allies fail to form needed Allied general reserve • Following shock of Somme=> Foch given more authority: • Charged w/coordination of allied action on Western Front • 3 April: Foch authority even further extended: • Assigned strategic direction of military Ops: • But with a limiting caveat – what is this caveat? • Allied commanders can ?______ __ ______National leadership authority

  13. Spring Offensive continues 9-29 April • April 9: Germans attackNorth of Somme: • Battle Offensive #2 => ?_____ river • German attack realizes significant gains by 12 Apr • Foch sends only token reinforcements to Haig: • Foch concerned about further attacks in French sector • Haig orders: backs to wall defense • Hard fighting & gallantry delivered by British troops • German’s 2nd offensive then stalls on 29 April– why? • 2nd offense stalls due to lack of ?_______________: • Brit supply dumps attract troops’ focus • What serious problem is indicated?

  14. Battle Offensive #3 => ?________ des Dames • May 27: Germans attackvicinity of Champagne: • Enjoy significant penetration: • Operational Objective: Diversion: • Divert Allied reserves from Flanders • Then resume attack in North on British • French Cmdr Duchene unprepared for assault: • No defense in depth – Germans overrun on D-day • Relieved of command as a result • The AEF would play a key defensive role during this period

  15. US Actions & German Results • US actions at Chateau Thierry & Belleau Wood key: • Help halt German advance by 4 June; • Germans establish salient near Marne & halt; • German progress to date: 3 large salients (see previous map): • Somme, Lys, & the Marneare tactical victories only • Operational & strategic impact? • No ?______ _______or ?____________ gain • But does deplete German troops & their logistics support

  16. Battle Offensive #4 => ?___________ & Marne • June 8 Germans attack between Somme & Marne • Another attempted diversion • Operational Aim? • Draw Allied Reserves away for where? • ?___________________ • Tactical Objective: • Expand salient into 1 large one • Problem for Germans? • Allies ?________ German attack preparations • Establish defense in depth: • French preempt w/counter-arty & attack w/tanks & surprise Germans • Result: • German advance halted w/only limited gains

  17. Battle Offensive #5 (15-17 July) • Final attack #5 made along Marne east of Chateau Thierry: • Problem: Alliesaware of German plans inadvance received from German deserters • Enables allies to prepare defense in depth; • Also preempts German arty prep w/counter battery; • US 3rd Division holds • US 38th regiment on Left Flank remains solid • Withstands assaults by 2 German divisions • Earns title of “Rock of the Marne” for 3rd Division • Results of Ludendorff’s Offensive: • Desperate gamble fails: Tactical gains only • Cost in German casualties very high: • Depleted army’s reserves, supplies, & morale; • No Strategic or operational gain to show for it • Resumption of attack in the North cancelled • Foch now prepares for a counter-offensive

  18. Allied Offensives - 1918 • Foch’s initial Operational objectives: • Reduce the 3 German salients resulting from the gains made by German Spring Offensive • Marne, Somme, St. Mihiel (Map) • 2nd Battle of the Marne(18 July): • 1st Battle in a series of allied drives to push Germans back • French 10th main attack into west side of salient: • While 6th, 9th, & 5th attacked east side • US role in 2nd Battle of Marne: • 9 US divisions participate as part of 3 Fr. armies • 1st & 2nd US divisions play key role at 2nd Battle of the Marne: • Attack Soissons • Threaten German main supply line • Germans forced to withdraw • Operational impact: • Initiative now shifts to ?_______________

  19. Reduction of Somme Salient (August 1918) • Battle of Amiens (Map p. 359)=> turning point: • Open warfare & maneuver resumes since war’s start; • Ludendorff: Black Day for German army • Execution: • Brit 4th (Rawlinson)hits salient North side: • 1 Corps consisting of 4 Canadian & 5 Ausie Divisions • Supported by 12 tank battalions (414 combat) • OPSEC: no prep arty or pre-registration to alert Ger. • Canadians advance 10 miles & capture 16K POWs • French begin 45 minute prep at H-Hour: • 1st Fr Army attacks remaining part of salient: • Makes slow but steady progress • Haig continues to press & force Germans back as they conduct an orderly withdrawal: • By late Aug, Germans fall back to Hindenburg line • Significance of German Army’s forced withdrawal? • Apparent to both sides that ?___________________

  20. Reduction of St. Mihiel Salient (Sept 1918) • Events rapidly unfolding dictate an acceleration of the allied timeline to 1918: • Dramatic allied gains push major offenses ahead from 1919 to Fall of 1918- why? • German army’s rapid ?_____________ • Potential impact of orderly withdrawal: • German army & logistics in tact; • Destruction of bridges, roads & rail • Establish defense line close to border • Foch’sOperational Plan (Map): • 2 major simultaneous ?_____________ • (giant pinchers from North & South): • 1st: employs combined Fr-Brit force advance: • Tactical objectives: • Cambrai, Le Cateau, & Aulnoye Rail junction • 2nd: employs combined Fr-American force advance: • Tactical objectives: • Mezieres Rail junction • Between Meuse & Argonne

  21. Pershing’s Counter Proposal • Pershing resisted Foch’s Plan – why? • US 1st Army only recently ?_____________ in July • Foch wants to split American forces to use in above • Pershing to keep unit cohesion –compromises - how? • Pershing agrees to conduct ?_____________ operations • i.e. Attack St. Mihiel, disengage & redeploy to NE: • To Meuse-Argonne for major offensive • Complex operational & logistic challenge during combat • Effectively planned & executed by who? • Col. George ?_____________

  22. St. Mihiel Execution • Pershing executed “as planned” in 2 days (Map): • 0500 12 Sept: assault follows 4 hour arty preparation • 4 corps (4 Fr & 8 1/2 American divisions); • Fire support: 3010 Arty & 267 tanks; • 1481 A/C (Fr) effectively commanded by Billy Mitchell • Results: Americans capture 450 guns & 16K POWs • Tactical success – Pershing halts at base of salient • Continue logistics planning & prep to redeploy to NW

  23. Meuse- Argonne Offensive • As promised, Pershing redeploys to relieve Fr 2nd: • Foch tasks American 1st & Fr 4th to attack NW (Map): • Tactical Objective: • Cut/interdict E-W rail thru Sedan & Mezieves • Operational Objective: • Prevent Ger lateral reinforce. & supply to front • Preclude orderly withdrawal of German supplies • Meanwhile- Marshall’s simultaneous logistics op is BZ

  24. Meuse-Argonne Offensive- Execution • Germans expect assault & reorganize & reinforce: • Prepared defense line to receive attack • Allied assault follows 6 hour arty prep: • 26 Sept: troops move out at 0500=> • Overwhelm German forward defenses; • Some units advance 4 miles • Then American Cmdrs lose C2: • Units become confused & disorganized; • Inexperienced officers lose control of troops; • No infantry-arty coordination; • Troops bunch up & die altogether – arty; • Traffic control problem emerges; • March discipline declines/units mixed up

  25. Friction & more of the same • 27 Sept: offense continues but suffers heavy casualties • 4 & 8 Oct: attack again with little effect – more casualties • 12 Oct: Pershing splits American Army in two: • Appoints himself as army group commander • 1st Armycommanded by Hunter Leggett: • Focus: Meuse-Argonne • 2nd Army commanded by R.L. Bullard • Focus: St. Mihiel Salient

  26. Crisis in the AEF? • 14-19Oct: 1st Army attacks & then halts • Suffers high casualties • 55K casualties & possible C2 problems • Clemenceau complains of AEF crisis • Foch defends Pershing – • Asserts problem at lower command levels • 1 Nov: 0530 1st Army attacks w/7 vet divisions: • 2 hour artillery prep & supported by 18 tanks • This time attacks goes smoothly • Most units reach tactical objectives • As Germans withdraw, Americans pick up pace: • 3-5 Nov: 5th Div fight across to Meuse east bank • Beat Germans to east bank & cut them off; • By 11 Nov Armistice: • 850K Americans participated in WWI • 1st Army captured 26K POWs • 875 arty, 3K MGs • Suffer 117K casualties & inflict 100K

  27. Final Allied Offensives • Meanwhile=> other allied offensives press Germans • North: Flanders • (Belgium, French, Brits) siege Ypres • Somme: (key operation) along West Front=> by early Oct=> • 1 Fr & 2 Brit Armies breakthrough Hindenburg line: • Force Germans to withdraw • Maintain pressure • South:French continue to press all along front • German Crisis: morale rapidly plummets • Hindenburg & Ludendorff tell Kaiser: • It’s all over => must seek armistice • Urge establish new democratic government • Ger/Austria-Hung request Wilson grant armistice • Based on what? • Wilson’s ?_____________ Points • Austria-Hung then seeks separate Peace

  28. Germany Collapses • 26 Oct:Kaiser relieves Ludendorff • (Had proposed continuing the war) • 8 Nov: German Armistice commission meet with Foch: • Foch has authority to conclude conditional armistice: • Not based on President Wilson’s 14 Points – why? • Allies too heavily invested in ?____________ and ?___________ to forget • Germany complains – but Foch stays tough: • Hostilities will resume unless harsh terms offered are accepted • Meanwhile- German people revolt=> • Kaiser then advocated • Provisional Government granted permission to accept terms • Delegates sign under protest- significance? • German people feel ?________ & don’t think they ?_______ WWI (Hitler)

  29. Assessment • WWI: 8.5 million soldiers killed & 20 million wounded • Total War: unlimited resources expended or dedicated: • New technology => advanced weapons => • Endless cycle of violence & attrition ensues; • Draft provided millions of troops to fight; • Both men & women worked in factories, agro, etc. • Vast majority of $$$ resources dedicated to war • Massive logistical systems established • WWI was a “turning point” in history => why? • Central & Eastern European Empires ?_____________ • Euro state system fundamentally ?_____________ forever • Former colonies & rest of world ?_____________ : • Close gap with former European industrial masters • Women worked in previously closed jobs: • Changed society’s view of women’s role in society

  30. Assessment- Major Changes • Although Central Governments remain dominate following War • And a major factor in peoples lives from then on- other things changed: • WWI changed the nature of land warfare: • Tactics & strategy, & Logistics & supply systems; • Reorganized Army & developed new methods: • organize, equip, supply, & deploy massive armies; • New tech. innovations & weapons systems developed: • Tank, flamethrower, light machine gun, plane; • Naval warfare: CV & naval air (initial), SS • Conceptual & Tactical changes introduced: • Close coordination of combined arms: • Infantry, arty, tank, aircraft (all integrated into Blitzkrieg of WWII) • Also Rolling barrage, predicted fire, hurricane fire • New Infiltration tactics • Limited offensives & tactical objectives • French would continue to maintain tight control of their advancing forces • Germans would draw opposite lesson (Local C2 as per their 1918 offensive) • Defense in depth & elastic defense became the main defense model by 1918

  31. Assessment- Tactical Lessons Learned? • Big difference between 1914 soldier & that of ?_________ & the tactics he employed • Still questions remained unanswered: • i.e. How best to break through well prepared defense • Germany especially would learn war’s tactical lessons: • Effectively apply these lessons, concepts, weapons, & tactics to next the war • The French would not & fight the last war in the next • This time: the Defense over Offense & the Maginot Line

More Related