1 / 19

Closing reflections on mimeticism: Colin Lyas on representation

Closing reflections on mimeticism: Colin Lyas on representation. From Colin Lyas. Chap. 3, “Nature’s Mirror.” Aesthetics. Montreal: McGill-Queen’s University Press, 1997. Representation remains commonplace Why are representative images so powerful? 1. Inadequate senses of representation

ossie
Download Presentation

Closing reflections on mimeticism: Colin Lyas on representation

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. Closing reflections on mimeticism:Colin Lyas on representation • From Colin Lyas. Chap. 3, “Nature’s Mirror.” Aesthetics. Montreal: McGill-Queen’s University Press, 1997. • Representation remains commonplace • Why are representative images so powerful? • 1. Inadequate senses of representation • (1) Representation as imitating • What does Lyas mean by imitation? Closing reflections on mimeticism - Lyas - chap. 2 - slide 1

  2. Closing reflections on mimeticism:Colin Lyas on representation • Lyas’s objection to representation as imitation: little of art is mere imitation • trompe l’oeil • Unswept Dining Room Floor • Ken Davies, The Ken Davies Trompe • anamorphosis • Holbein the Younger, The Ambassadors • - detail Closing reflections on mimeticism - Lyas - chap. 2 - slide 2

  3. Closing reflections on mimeticism:Colin Lyas on representation • (2) Representation as copying • How does Lyas distinguish between imitating and copying? • Any position which holds that the copy is an exact replica assumes a view from nowhere (39). • Comment: but does it? Closing reflections on mimeticism - Lyas - chap. 2 - slide 3

  4. Closing reflections on mimeticism:Colin Lyas on representation • Ernst Gombrich & Nelson Goodman’s critique of the copying model • The creation of works of art is always as much making as it is re-presenting Closing reflections on mimeticism - Lyas - chap. 2 - slide 4

  5. Closing reflections on mimeticism:Colin Lyas on representation • Lyas’s first conclusion: Representation in art is not principally about imitating & definitely not about copying. • 2. Can the mimetic theory fit all art? • Abstract art, much of music & dance? • Response: But even non-representational art has some representational elements. Closing reflections on mimeticism - Lyas - chap. 2 - slide 5

  6. Closing reflections on mimeticism:Colin Lyas on representation • And what about photography? • Roger Scruton’s suggestion • What about fiction? • Lyas’s “as if” suggestion Closing reflections on mimeticism - Lyas - chap. 2 - slide 6

  7. Closing reflections on mimeticism:Colin Lyas on representation • 3. Other critiques of representational art • Clive Bell’s critique of representational art • In works of art, representation is always irrelevant; form is all that counts • Lyas’s response to Bell • We often see form through representation Closing reflections on mimeticism - Lyas - chap. 2 - slide 7

  8. Closing reflections on mimeticism:Colin Lyas on representation • Form & representation are intertwined. • But Bell’s critique of representational has some value • It proposes that we should not look at works of art as surrogates for the real thing; when art is representational, it must have some other function. Closing reflections on mimeticism - Lyas - chap. 2 - slide 8

  9. Closing reflections on mimeticism:Colin Lyas on representation • 4. Lyas’s position on the value of representation in art. Is he saying that this is what representational art is really about? • delight in the act of imitating itself • Our attention in a representational work of art is [should be] on the act of imitating itself--the skill & the imagination which it requires (53). Closing reflections on mimeticism - Lyas - chap. 2 - slide 9

  10. Closing reflections on mimeticism:Colin Lyas on representation • Delight in the wit & cleverness of imitation • Rene Magritte’s Cette n’est pas une pipe CHECK • trompe l’oeil • An effective way of expressing emotions Closing reflections on mimeticism - Lyas - chap. 2 - slide 10

  11. Closing reflections on mimeticism:Colin Lyas on representation • Comments • Is Lyas an essentialist with respect to constructing a theory of art? (See Lyas 103-104) • Does Lyas reject representation as the essence of art? Closing reflections on mimeticism - Lyas - chap. 2 - slide 11

  12. Closing reflections on mimeticism: Gombrich, Wilde, & Lyas • Virtues of representation • delight in skill • vehicle for expressing feelings & emotions Closing reflections on mimeticism - Lyas - chap. 2 - slide 12

  13. Closing reflections on mimeticism: Gombrich, Wilde, & Lyas • The Aesthetic Movement • Wilde’s position on the autonomy of art reflects an intellectual movement in 19th century France & England called Aestheticism or the Aesthetic Movement • Roots in France in the 1820s - Théophile Gautier, Baudelaire, and later Flaubert. Closing reflections on mimeticism - Lyas - chap. 2 - slide 13

  14. Closing reflections on mimeticism: Gombrich, Wilde, & Lyas • Earliest & most uncompromising version • Works of art should be judged only by internal standards • Any external purpose or function which art may serve should be counted as a defect Closing reflections on mimeticism - Lyas - chap. 2 - slide 14

  15. Closing reflections on mimeticism: Gombrich, Wilde, & Lyas • And art is the cause, the substratum, of all else (Walter Pater & Wilde’s version) • For Walter Pater, aesthetic values are primary and override all other value, even moral ones. • The aesthetic quest is the highest way of life a human can follow Closing reflections on mimeticism - Lyas - chap. 2 - slide 15

  16. Closing reflections on mimeticism: Gombrich, Wilde, & Lyas • Wilde - “People will give mup war when they consider it to be vulgar instead of wicked.” • Wilde - it is better to be beautiful than to be good. Closing reflections on mimeticism - Lyas - chap. 2 - slide 16

  17. Closing reflections on mimeticism: Gombrich, Wilde, & Lyas • More moderate version • Although art of an earlier time may have been utilitarian, these works may today be taken as pure aesthetic objects • A work of art should be valued for its purely internal & aesthetic qualities & not for its relationship to anything external Closing reflections on mimeticism - Lyas - chap. 2 - slide 17

  18. Closing reflections on mimeticism: Gombrich, Wilde, & Lyas • What are some of these internal qualities? Elegance, grace, balance, harmony, expressiveness, depth, atmostphere. • Critique • Aestheticisms position on the evaluation & appreciation of art is too restrictive • E.g., Appreciating a Gothic cathedral Closing reflections on mimeticism - Lyas - chap. 2 - slide 18

  19. Closing reflections on mimeticism: Gombrich, Wilde, & Lyas • What justification is there for making the aesthetic the basic causal factor and evaluative standard for everything else? Closing reflections on mimeticism - Lyas - chap. 2 - slide 19

More Related