1 / 31

Flat Earth News

News reporting in the age of Churnalism , based on Flat Earth News by Nick Davies. Flat Earth News. The previous news stories were all from 2006. The story initially appeared in local newspapers, then in national newspapers. It soon appeared on prominent websites such as the BBC.

paulinemiller
Download Presentation

Flat Earth News

An Image/Link below is provided (as is) to download presentation Download Policy: Content on the Website is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use and may not be sold / licensed / shared on other websites without getting consent from its author. Content is provided to you AS IS for your information and personal use only. Download presentation by click this link. While downloading, if for some reason you are not able to download a presentation, the publisher may have deleted the file from their server. During download, if you can't get a presentation, the file might be deleted by the publisher.

E N D

Presentation Transcript

  1. News reporting in the age of Churnalism, based on Flat Earth News by Nick Davies Flat Earth News

  2. The previous news stories were all from 2006. The story initially appeared in local newspapers, then in national newspapers. It soon appeared on prominent websites such as the BBC. Before long it went international, and within 48 hours was reported in, amongst others, the Sydney Morning Herald, the Washington Post, and the Malaysia Star. It had been translated into Italian, German, Polish, Romanian, Dutch and Chinese. But a few minutes of internet research turns up the following story from the previous World Cup, four years earlier.

  3. Same policy, same Paul Hucker!

  4. And here's another story, from 2006. It's the same firm, and again features Simon Burgess’ name.

  5. Why is the news media printing such bad stories? Davies suggests that the cause of the problem is the climate of financial cutbacks as a result of the competition between the huge profit-oriented companies that own the British news media. 1986: Rupert Murdoch moves his newspapers from Fleet Street to Wapping, in complete secrecy, and breaks the print unions. This is the end of an era, the end of family-owned (and expensive to run) newspapers that prioritised journalism. They are replaced by corporate owners that prioritise profit.

  6. The result of this corporate takeover and the move to Wapping was less resources for editors and increased profits for owners. The following figures are the pre-tax profits of Murdoch’s UK titles and the total staff employed before and after the move to Wapping (p.63). 1985 £35.6 million 8,731 1988 £144.6 million 949

  7. Because newspapers employ considerably less journalists, these journalists face dramatically increased workloads. To make matters worse, in the digital age there is increasing pressure from managers to get stories published as quickly as possible. Davies quotes an internal BBC memo: “We should be getting ‘breaking news’ up within 5 minutes.” (p.69) “Getting up” here means publishing a one-line version of the story on the ticker, writing a four-paragraph summary of the story, and checking the story. Clearly under these circumstances, the “checking” will not be very effective.

  8. One striking example of the pressures newspapers feel to get the scoop is the Daily Mail's reporting of the result of Amanda Knox's appeal in 2011: (Her appeal was actually upheld, the Mail got it wrong.)

  9. Here are some interesting quotes from the article, which the facts of the event reveal to be completely made up. "Amanda Knox looked stunned this evening after she dramatically lost her prison appeal against her murder conviction. ... As Knox realized the enormity of what judge Hellman was saying she sank into her chair sobbing uncontrollably while her family and friends hugged each other in tears. A few feet away Meredith's mother Arline, her sister Stephanie and brother Lyle, who had flown in especially for the verdict remained expressionless, staring straight ahead, glancing over just once at the distraught Knox family. Prosecutors were delighted with the verdict and said that 'justice has been done' although they said on a 'human factor it was sad two young people would be spending years in jail'. Following the verdict Knox and Sollecito were taken out of court escorted by prison guards and into a waiting van which took her back to her cell at Capanne jail near Perugia and him to Terni jail, 60 miles away. Both will be put on a suicide watch for the next few days as psychological assessments are made on each of them but this is usual practice for long term prisoners."

  10. The Mail had been tricked by the way the judge announced the verdict, and in their rush to break the news before their competitors had published a story which had been written in advance. (The Daily Mail was censured by the Press Complaints as a result of this story.) The following screenshot is quite revealing: (3 hectic minutes in the offices of the Daily Mail!)

  11. Scarce resources and intense competition mean that journalists have little time and are rarely able to research stories in the way they used to. Instead, they rely on two main sources. • News agencies (also called wire agencies)‏ • Public Relations (consisting of private companies’ PR as well as the press agencies of different organisations, such as the government or the police)‏ Davies commissioned a study by specialist researchers which found that 60% of news reports published over two weeks in the quality press “consisted wholly or mainly of wire copy and/or PR material” (p.52).

  12. Needless to say, PR material is highly subjective by its very nature, and the BritishInsurance stories are a clear example of crude marketing. The news industry's reliance on wire copy, with few journalists able to check stories from the wire, allows enterprising PR companies to access the world media if they can get their story accepted by an agency.

  13. The reporting of the death of Ian Tomlinson at the G20 meeting disturbances in London was another good example of PR (in this case police statements) which attempted to subvert the truth in order to serve the interests of the organisation that published the statement.

  14. Reliance on wire copy has also led to some very dubious science reporting. This example reports claims about causes of the UK 2011 riots that the researchers have claimed are completely untrue.

  15. At this point, it would be useful to compare Davies' ideas with Chomsky's. • What are the similarities and differences between the way these two analysts explain the workings of news media? List both.

  16. Similarities Differences

  17. Davies characterises the way modern journalism works with 9 satirical “rules of churnalism”. (p.114) These 9 rules all fit into two major categories: Rules 1-5: Cutting the costs Rules 6-9: Increasing the revenue

  18. RULE 1: Run cheap stories To qualify under this rule, stories should be both quick to cover and safe to publish. Anything that requires tricky investigation (or indeed any investigation at all) is out of the question.

  19. RULE 2: Select safe facts In practice, the safety of a fact doesn't necessarily have a relationship to its truth value. No matter how much evidence there is to prove something is true, even if that includes photographs and TV footage, a fact only becomes safe when it can be attributed to an official source.

  20. RULE 3: Avoid the electric fence This means that it is best to avoid running stories that might upset any individual, group, company or organisation that has the power to “hurt news organisations” (p.122).

  21. RULE 4: Select safe ideas Ideas are safe when they fulfil two criteria: • They agree with general consensus • They are not stated overtly in the news report, but instead “are the undeclared assumptions on which it is built” (p. 125).

  22. RULE 5: Always give both sides of the story Although it is sometimes vital that a journalist presents both sides of a story, such as when she is unable to uncover the truth, it can also be a strategy used by journalists and editors to protect themselves in controversial issues when they know there is a danger of upsetting a powerful interest group. For example, journalists spent two decades nullifying the warnings of scientists on both global warming and the dangers of smoking in order to “give both sides”, i.e. presenting the interests of the oil and tobacco companies (http://www.guardian.co.uk/science/2011/jul/20/bbc-climate-change-science-coverage).

  23. A good example of how the concept of “balance” has shifted the debate away from truth is a petition organised by the Astrological Association of Great Britain after a presenter on a BBC science programme claimed astrology was “rubbish” and “nonsense”. The association organised a petition in which they requested that “the BBC will commit to making a fair and balanced representation of astrology when aired in the future”.

  24. RULE 6: Give them what they want In contrast to the traditional approach of journalistic standards dictating content, the new media managers (the big corporations) are fundamentally motivated by profit, and will, to paraphrase Davies, tell anything they can sell (p.133).

  25. RULE 7: The bias against truth A consequence of rule 6, when there is a constant imperative to only print what people want to read, important contextual information gets left out. The commercial logic of rule 6 favours: • the concrete over the abstract • the event over the process • the current over the historic • the simple over the complicated • the certain over the doubtful The result is a serious decontextualisation of news reports that creates a bias against a full understanding of the truth.

  26. RULE 8: Give them what they want to believe in Rule 6 suggests facts should be populist in their appeal; rule 8 suggests that ideas should also be. Davies quotes a memo written by Piers Morgan in 2003 while editor of the Daily Mirror: “I'm afraid I misjudged how our readers would respond to the start of the war... One thing I won't be doing is sitting here defiantly telling myself how I'm right and they're all wrong. The readers are never wrong. Repulsive, maybe, but never wrong.“ (p.141)

  27. RULE 9: Go with the moral panic This rule suggests that journalists should attempt to “sell the nation a heightened version of its own emotional state in its crudest possible form” (p.142). Unlike the other rules, Davies claims that this one is compulsory, and that journalists who fail to adhere are “hunted down and attacked” (p.142).

  28. References Davies, Nick (2009) Flat Earth News. London: Vintage Paul Hucker articles http://www.thesun.co.uk/sol/homepage/news/150584/Pauls-football-mad.html http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/uk_news/england/suffolk/4968092.stm http://news.sky.com/skynews/Home/Sky-News-Archive/Article/200806413521882?f=rss http://www.guardian.co.uk/money/2006/may/03/healthinsurance Immaculate conception article http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/uk_news/scotland/highlands_and_islands/5105946.stm Amanda Knox appeal http://www.guardian.co.uk/commentisfree/2011/oct/04/amanda-knox-mistake-media-guilty-secret http://www.malcolmcoles.co.uk/blog/daily-mail-guuilt/ http://www.guardian.co.uk/media/greenslade/2011/oct/04/dailymail-amanda-knox http://www.pcc.org.uk/cases/adjudicated.html?article=NzUzOQ==?oxid=ptrh3ejilugnrmioe81q99aii2 Brain study and riots http://uk.news.yahoo.com/brain-chemical-lack-spurs-rioting-144015646.html http://www.guardian.co.uk/science/blog/2011/aug/22/riot-control-newspapers-distorting-science Astrological Association of Great Britain's petition http://www.guardian.co.uk/science/the-lay-scientist/2011/jan/24/1 http://www.astrologicalassociation.com/pages/bbc/submit.php

More Related